Indirect taxation: merits, issues, initiatives; indirect taxes subsumed under GST
Indian Economy › Taxation System in India · Topic 10.21
Indirect taxation in India is the system of taxes on production, sale, import and consumption of goods and services, whose burden is shifted to the final consumer through the price. Since 1 July 2017, most of it has been merged into the Goods and Services Tax (GST), a destination-based, multi-stage tax with input tax credit, created by the 101st Constitution Amendment Act, 2016. GST subsumed central excise duty, service tax, additional customs duty, state VAT, central sales tax, entry tax, octroi and luxury tax. The GST 2.0 reform from 22 September 2025 cut the rate slabs to 5 and 18 per cent, with a 40 per cent rate for sin and luxury goods.
8 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Taxation System in India
At a Glance
- GST launched 1 July 2017 under the 101st Amendment Act, 2016
- GST 2.0 effective 22 September 2025 (56th Council meeting, 3 September 2025)
- Slabs after reform 5 per cent and 18 per cent, plus 40 per cent for sin and luxury goods
- Gross GST, FY26 Rs 22.27 lakh crore, up 8.3 per cent
- Gross GST, October 2026 Rs 2.31 lakh crore, up 22.9 per cent
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Taxation System in India
Where Does It Fit?
This Mains topic builds on the classification in Tax: Direct Tax and Indirect Tax; Classification of Taxes Based on Incidence; Tax Incidence; Taxation System in India and the mechanics in Goods and Services Tax (GST): Introduction, Dual GST Model, CGST, SGST, IGST, UTGST; Destination-Based Tax; Multiple Tax Levels; Input Tax Credit; Compliance and Reporting. It asks the evaluative question behind Indirect Taxes: Customs, Excise, VAT (VAT in India), Service Tax, Sales Tax; Anti-Dumping and Countervailing Duties and Classification of taxes: recent trends in tax collection: what indirect taxes did GST replace and has the consolidation worked. Previous topic: Direct taxation: government initiatives to improve; difference between GAFA tax and Equalisation Levy. Next topic: GST (Compensation to States) Act 2017: rationale; impact of COVID-19 on GST Compensation Fund and strained federal relations.
Which Indirect Taxes Were Subsumed Under GST and Which Were Left Out?
| Group | Levies and what happened |
|---|---|
| Central taxes subsumed | Central excise duty (including additional excise duties), service tax, additional customs duty (countervailing duty), special additional duty of customs, central surcharges and cesses related to supply of goods and services, and the central sales tax |
| State taxes subsumed | State value added tax (VAT) and sales tax, entertainment tax (other than that levied by local bodies), octroi and entry tax, purchase tax, luxury tax, taxes on lottery, betting and gambling, and state surcharges and cesses on supply |
| Left outside GST | Basic customs duty on imports, central excise on tobacco products (alongside GST), state excise on alcohol for human consumption, stamp duty, property tax and electricity duty |
| Petroleum products | Crude oil, petrol, diesel, natural gas and aviation turbine fuel stay outside GST for now. They carry central excise and state VAT, so tax credit chains break for businesses that use them as inputs |
| Compensation cess | A temporary cess on sin and luxury goods funded compensation to states. Its rate was removed for most goods from 22 September 2025, while the tobacco cess continued until the pandemic-era loans were repaid, and 1 February 2026 was notified as the date the cess regime changed |
| Why subsume | Different taxes on one product at each stage caused cascading of taxes (tax on tax). One national market with input tax credit removes the double burden |
What Are the Merits and Issues of Indirect Taxation and GST?
| Dimension | Merit and issue |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Merit: indirect taxes are easy to collect and stable. Gross GST was Rs 22.27 lakh crore in 2025-26, up 8.3 per cent, and Rs 2.31 lakh crore in October 2026, up 22.9 per cent. Issue: refunds were Rs 2.92 lakh crore in 2025-26, up 17.8 per cent, which narrows net revenue growth to 7.1 per cent |
| Equity | Merit: the 5 per cent slab covers essential goods. Issue: indirect taxes are regressive because a poor household spends a larger share of income on taxed goods than a rich one |
| Single market | Merit: fewer checkposts, faster movement of goods and one tax identity across states. Issue: petrol, diesel and alcohol remain outside, so state-level distortions persist |
| Formalisation | Merit: input tax credit makes buyers ask for invoices, which pulls traders into the formal net. Issue: small firms face compliance costs and registration burdens |
| Rate structure | Merit: the 2025 reform replaced four rates with two main rates, easing classification disputes. Issue: the inverted duty structure, where inputs are taxed more than output, locks up working capital and drives refunds |
| Federalism | Merit: states share the base and decide rates jointly in the GST Council. Issue: states gave up taxing powers and depend on Council consensus, and the end of compensation has raised revenue anxiety |
| Dispute resolution | Merit: statutory appeal channels exist. Issue: classification, place of supply and credit disputes keep litigation high |
What Else Should You Remember?
- GST 2.0 reform: The 56th GST Council meeting on 3 September 2025 approved a two-rate structure of 5 per cent and 18 per cent, with a 40 per cent rate for sin and luxury goods such as tobacco, pan masala, aerated drinks and larger cars, effective 22 September 2025. The earlier 12 and 28 per cent slabs were removed
- Relief for households: The 5 per cent rate covers essential goods and the 18 per cent rate covers most others. Gross collection in October 2026 was Rs 2.31 lakh crore, up 22.9 per cent, with import-linked IGST of Rs 1.37 lakh crore the main driver and domestic collections up 15.8 per cent to Rs 1.59 lakh crore
- Initiatives for ease: Electronic invoicing and the e-way bill are the main compliance and tracking tools, backed by return matching
- Anti-evasion tools: Data analytics, matching of invoices with returns, fake invoice detection and biometric verification at registration target input tax credit fraud
- Issue of cascading in fuel: Because petroleum is outside GST, firms using fuel as input cannot claim credit. Bringing natural gas or ATF into GST has been discussed in Council, and states have resisted because fuel gives them large revenue
- Issue of regressive burden: Economists note that taxes on consumption fall harder on lower deciles. A lower rate on mass consumption goods offsets this, while a 40 per cent rate on luxury goods keeps the structure progressive at the top
- Issue of litigation: Classification, place of supply and input credit denial are the major sources of dispute. The Council issues circulars to settle them, but court cases continue
- Link to compensation: The guarantee of 14 per cent growth in revenue lasted to June 2022, as explained in GST (Compensation to States) Act 2017: rationale; impact of COVID-19 on GST Compensation Fund and strained federal relations. The framework for the Council is covered in GST Council (Article 279A): Composition, Quorum, Decision-Making Majority, Weightage of Votes, Nature of Recommendations, Scope of Binding Recommendations, Dispute Resolution, Periodic Review and Functions of the GST Council: Recommendations on GST Laws, Rate Structure, Special Provisions for States, Model GST Laws, Compensation to States
- Link to other levies: Anti-dumping and countervailing duties continue under customs, as in Indirect Taxes: Customs, Excise, VAT (VAT in India), Service Tax, Sales Tax; Anti-Dumping and Countervailing Duties. Cess and surcharge are distinguished in GST Compensation Cess; Cess and Surcharge
- Way forward: Bring petroleum into GST in stages, fix inverted duty structures, speed up dispute resolution, widen the base to cover real estate and electricity over time, raise e-invoicing coverage, and keep a stable rate structure so firms can plan
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Typical question: discuss the merits and issues of indirect taxation in India and state which taxes were subsumed under GST
- Taxes to list: central excise, service tax, additional customs duty, SAD, state VAT, central sales tax, octroi, entry tax, luxury tax
- Taxes outside GST: basic customs duty, alcohol excise, petroleum products, stamp duty
- Numbers to quote: 5 and 18 per cent slabs, 40 per cent special rate, gross GST Rs 22.27 lakh crore in 2025-26
- Common errors: saying that customs duty is subsumed fully, or that petrol is under GST
As an analytical point, GST has made indirect taxation larger and more stable, and the 2025 reform made it simpler. The unfinished work is fuel, the inverted duty structure and dispute resolution, which decide whether consolidation becomes real ease of doing business.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Taxes subsumed A list-type Mains question
- Merits and issues Balanced evaluation
- GST 2.0 Live 2025-26 reform
What Came Next?
The next topic examines how the Centre compensated states for revenue loss under GST, and why that guarantee strained federal relations. Next topic: GST (Compensation to States) Act 2017: rationale; impact of COVID-19 on GST Compensation Fund and strained federal relations.
Key People and Terms
- Indirect tax Tax shifted to the consumer
- Input tax credit Set-off for tax paid on inputs
- Cascading Tax on tax at each stage
- Inverted duty Input rate above output rate
- Destination-based Taxed where consumed
- GST 2.0 The 2025 slab reform
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- GST started on 1 July 2017 via the 101st Amendment.
- GST 2.0 effective 22 September 2025.
- Slabs: 5 and 18 per cent, plus 40 per cent.
- Outside GST: petroleum, alcohol, basic customs duty.
- Gross GST 2025-26: Rs 22.27 lakh crore .
Do Not Confuse With
- Indirect tax and direct tax Burden shifts to the consumer versus stays with the taxpayer
- Subsumed taxes and retained taxes Excise and VAT merged, customs and alcohol excise stayed
- Gross GST and net GST Before and after refunds
Memory Hook
Merge the many, keep the fuel, refund the credit, simplify the slab.
Mains Angle
Examiners want a list of what was merged plus a view on merits and issues. Give a table of taxes first, then dimensions, then reforms.
- Merits Single market, formalisation, revenue buoyancy
- Issues Fuel, regressivity, refunds, litigation
- Initiatives GST 2.0, e-invoicing, e-way bill
- Way forward Fuel in GST, stable rates
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Discuss the merits and issues of indirect taxation in India. Which indirect taxes were subsumed under the Goods and Services Tax, and what recent reforms have been made?”
How to Answer
- Intro Define indirect taxation and name GST as the consolidating reform of 2017.
- Body 1 Taxes subsumed and left out.
- Body 2 Merits and issues with figures.
- Body 3 GST 2.0 and other initiatives.
- Conclusion One nation, one tax works only when fuel, refunds and disputes are fixed.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
Which indirect taxes were subsumed under GST?
GST subsumed central excise duty, service tax, additional customs duty, special additional duty, central sales tax, state VAT, entry tax, octroi, luxury tax, purchase tax and entertainment tax levied by states, along with surcharges and cesses on supply of goods and services. Basic customs duty and alcohol excise stayed outside.
What are the merits of indirect taxation?
Indirect taxes are easy to collect, hard to evade at source and give stable revenue. Under GST they also remove cascading through input tax credit, create one national market and pull traders into the formal economy. Their weakness is that they are regressive for low income households.
What are the main issues with GST in India?
The main issues are petroleum products staying outside GST, the inverted duty structure that blocks working capital, high compliance for small firms, regressive impact on low incomes, and recurring classification disputes. Rising refunds, Rs 2.92 lakh crore in 2025-26, also narrow net revenue.
What changed under GST 2.0 in September 2025?
From 22 September 2025, GST moved to two main rates of 5 and 18 per cent, with 40 per cent for sin and luxury goods. The earlier 12 and 28 per cent slabs were dropped.
What were India's GST collections in 2025-26?
Gross GST collections for 2025-26 were about Rs 22.27 lakh crore, up 8.3 per cent, with domestic collections at Rs 16.32 lakh crore and import-linked collections at Rs 5.95 lakh crore. Net collections after refunds were about Rs 19.34 lakh crore, up 7.1 per cent.
Why is petrol not under GST?
Crude, petrol, diesel, natural gas and aviation fuel were kept outside GST in 2017 because they give the Centre and states large revenue through excise and VAT. Putting them in needs Council consensus. States fear losing revenue, so these products still cause tax on tax for fuel-using businesses.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 GST was introduced through the 101st Constitution Amendment Act, 2016.
It came into effect on 1 July 2017.
2 Basic customs duty was subsumed under GST.
Basic customs duty stays; additional customs duty and special additional duty were subsumed.
3 After September 2025, GST has two main slabs of 5 and 18 per cent.
A 40 per cent rate applies to sin and luxury goods.
4 Petrol and diesel are under GST at the standard rate.
They remain outside GST.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index