An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 10.22

GST (Compensation to States) Act 2017: rationale; impact of COVID-19 on GST Compensation Fund and strained federal relations

Indian Economy › Taxation System in India · Topic 10.22

The Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act, 2017 guarantees states a 14 per cent annual growth in their GST revenue over the base year 2015-16 for the first five years of GST, that is up to June 2022, and pays the shortfall from the GST Compensation Fund. The Fund is filled by a compensation cess on sin and luxury goods such as tobacco, aerated drinks and large cars. The Act was the price of getting states to give up their own taxing powers. In 2020, the COVID-19 lockdown caused a large shortfall, the Centre chose a borrowing route, and the dispute strained federal relations.

Share:
GST (Compensation to States) Act 2017: rationale; impact of COVID-19 on GST Compensation Fund and strained federal relations - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Guarantee 14 per cent a year over 2015-16 base, five years to June 2022
  • Funding Compensation cess into the GST Compensation Fund
  • Pandemic borrowing Rs 2.69 lakh crore borrowed by the Centre across 2020-21 and 2021-22
  • Supreme Court Mohit Minerals, 19 May 2022: Council recommendations are persuasive, not binding
  • Cess regime change 1 February 2026 notified for the new excise and health and national security cess laws
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Taxation System in India

Where Does It Fit?

This Mains topic explains the money side of the Council described in Functions of the GST Council: Recommendations on GST Laws, Rate Structure, Special Provisions for States, Model GST Laws, Compensation to States and the cess concept in GST Compensation Cess; Cess and Surcharge. It follows from Indirect taxation: merits, issues, initiatives; indirect taxes subsumed under GST, which listed the taxes states surrendered when they joined GST. Previous topic: Indirect taxation: merits, issues, initiatives; indirect taxes subsumed under GST. Next topic: Taxation on virtual digital assets: proposed framework, significance, concerns, way forward.

What Was the Rationale of the GST Compensation Act and How Did It Work?

Feature Detail and reason
Why a guarantee States gave up VAT, entry tax and octroi, which were their own taxes. Many feared revenue loss in a new, untested system, so the Centre promised protection
The 14 per cent rule Revenue of a state for compensation is taken from the base year 2015-16 and projected at 14 per cent annual growth. Compensation equals the gap between this projected figure and actual GST revenue
Duration Five years from 1 July 2017, so up to June 2022
Source of money A compensation cess on demerit goods such as tobacco, pan masala, aerated drinks, coal and large cars, collected into the non-lapsable GST Compensation Fund
Constitutional anchor The 101st Amendment Act, 2016 and Article 279A, with the Council recommending cess rates, as in GST Council (Article 279A): Composition, Quorum, Decision-Making Majority, Weightage of Votes, Nature of Recommendations, Scope of Binding Recommendations, Dispute Resolution, Periodic Review
What it did It bought political consensus for a single GST and let the Centre pass the law, as the Centre and states later agreed the guarantee was central to the bargain
Limit It was a time-bound protection, not a permanent entitlement. The Act itself had a sunset in June 2022

How Did COVID-19 Strain the Fund and Centre-State Relations?

Stage What happened
Shortfall The 2020 lockdown collapsed GST and cess collections, so the cess pool fell short of the compensation promised to states under the 14 per cent rule
Centre’s position The Centre said the pandemic was an act of God that had hit the economy and collections, and that the Fund could pay only from cess receipts
States’ position States argued that the guarantee was a legal duty of the Centre and that asking them to borrow shifted the risk to them
Borrowing route The Centre borrowed about Rs 2.69 lakh crore across 2020-21 and 2021-22 to meet the shortfall and passed the money to states as back-to-back loans, repayable from later cess collections
Extension of cess Because the loans needed repayment with interest, the cess ran past June 2022. Repayment was originally due by March 2026, and the plan was to finish earlier
Federal friction The dispute weakened trust in the GST Council, where states had agreed to pool their taxing powers on the strength of the guarantee
Judicial anchor In Mohit Minerals v Union of India (19 May 2022), the Supreme Court held that GST Council recommendations are not binding on the Centre or states and have persuasive value, because binding force would upset the balance of Indian federalism

What Else Should You Remember?

  • End of compensation: Compensation payments stopped in June 2022, when the five-year guarantee lapsed. Since then, states depend on the growth of their own GST receipts
  • Cess after 2025: From 22 September 2025, the compensation cess was dropped for aerated drinks, cars and coal as the 40 per cent GST rate took over, while tobacco and allied products kept the cess until the loans were repaid
  • Cess regime change: The government notified 1 February 2026 as the date for the Central Excise (Amendment) Act, 2025 and the Health Security se National Security Cess Act, 2025, so that tobacco moves to excise duty and pan masala to a new cess in place of the compensation cess
  • Sharing of the new cess: The Finance Minister said in December 2025 that the Centre would share part of the health and national security cess collection with states, which shows the sharing question is still live
  • Why cess matters to states: A cess is not part of the divisible pool of central taxes shared under the Finance Commission award, so states have a standing interest in how cess receipts are used and shared
  • Lesson from 2020: A guarantee funded by a narrow cess is fragile in a shock. A contingency fund or a pre-agreed shock facility would give states more certainty
  • Constitutional frame: Article 279A and the 101st Amendment Act, 2016 created the Council. Parliament and state legislatures hold simultaneous power to legislate on GST, as the Supreme Court noted in Mohit Minerals
  • Link to other levies: Cess and surcharge are distinguished in GST Compensation Cess; Cess and Surcharge, and the cess has a role in the compensation to states described in Functions of the GST Council: Recommendations on GST Laws, Rate Structure, Special Provisions for States, Model GST Laws, Compensation to States
  • Link to GST structure: The Council decision making is explained in GST Council (Article 279A): Composition, Quorum, Decision-Making Majority, Weightage of Votes, Nature of Recommendations, Scope of Binding Recommendations, Dispute Resolution, Periodic Review, and the taxes states gave up are listed in Indirect taxation: merits, issues, initiatives; indirect taxes subsumed under GST
  • Way forward: Set a rule for shock-time compensation, share the new cess with states on a clear formula, strengthen the Council consultation culture, and expand the GST base, including petroleum, in stages

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Typical question: explain the rationale of the GST Compensation Act 2017 and how COVID-19 affected the Fund and federal relations
  2. Key terms: 14 per cent, 2015-16 base year, five years, compensation cess, GST Compensation Fund
  3. Numbers to quote: Rs 2.69 lakh crore pandemic borrowing, compensation to June 2022
  4. Court case: Mohit Minerals (19 May 2022) on non-binding recommendations
  5. Common errors: saying the guarantee is permanent, or saying that the Fund is financed by GST itself rather than the cess

As an analytical point, the Act solved a trust problem in 2017 but showed its limits in 2020. A shock-proof design, a clear legal duty and a shared decision culture would make the next fiscal bargain stronger.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Rationale Why states needed a guarantee
  • COVID shock Fund shortfall and loans
  • Federalism Mohit Minerals and trust

What Came Next?

The next topic moves to a new tax base, virtual digital assets, and asks what policy framework fits it. Next topic: Taxation on virtual digital assets: proposed framework, significance, concerns, way forward.

Key People and Terms

  • Compensation cess Levy on demerit goods
  • GST Compensation Fund Pool for payments to states
  • Base year 2015-16 revenue
  • Back-to-back loan Centre borrows and lends to states
  • Cooperative federalism Joint decisions by Centre and states
  • Sunset Fixed end date of a law

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Guarantee: 14 per cent a year over 2015-16.
  • Period: July 2017 to June 2022.
  • Loans: about Rs 2.69 lakh crore.
  • Court: Mohit Minerals, 2022.
  • Fund: compensation cess, not GST itself.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Compensation cess and ordinary cess GST compensation purpose versus general purpose cess
  • Binding and persuasive recommendations Mohit Minerals held them persuasive

Memory Hook

Fourteen to promise, five years to pay, a pandemic to test the trust.

Mains Angle

Questions ask why the Act was needed, what broke in 2020 and what it did to federal trust. A timeline plus the court ruling gives depth.

  • Rationale Trust bargain for surrender of taxes
  • COVID impact Shortfall and borrowing
  • Federal strain Opinions, options, cess sharing
  • Way forward Shock facility and Council reform

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Explain the rationale behind the GST (Compensation to States) Act, 2017. Discuss how the COVID-19 pandemic affected the GST Compensation Fund and strained Centre-state relations.”

How to Answer

  1. Intro Describe the 14 per cent guarantee as the bargain for GST.
  2. Body 1 Design of the Act and the cess.
  3. Body 2 COVID shortfall, borrowing options, loans.
  4. Body 3 Federal strain, Mohit Minerals.
  5. Conclusion Cooperative federalism survives on predictable guarantees, not only on consensus.

GS Relevance

GS Paper 3: Indian economy, taxation, resource mobilisation; GS Paper 2: federal structure, Centre-state financial relations. Asked in UPSC Mains 2020: the rationale of the compensation Act and the effect of COVID-19 on the Fund and federal relations.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the GST (Compensation to States) Act, 2017?

It is the law that guarantees states 14 per cent annual growth in GST revenue over the 2015-16 base year for five years from July 2017. Shortfall is paid from the GST Compensation Fund, which is funded by a compensation cess on sin and luxury goods.

Why was the GST Compensation Act needed?

States gave up VAT, entry tax, octroi and other taxes to join GST and feared revenue loss in a new system. The Centre assured them 14 per cent growth in revenue for five years, which created political consensus for a single national tax.

How did COVID-19 affect the GST Compensation Fund?

The lockdown cut GST and cess collections, so the Fund could not meet promised compensation. The Centre borrowed about Rs 2.69 lakh crore across 2020-21 and 2021-22 and passed it to states as back-to-back loans.

Why did the compensation issue strain Centre-state relations?

States argued that compensation was a legal guarantee and that asking them to borrow shifted the risk to them. The Centre said the pandemic was exceptional and cess money was limited. The dispute weakened trust in the GST Council.

What did the Supreme Court say in Mohit Minerals?

On 19 May 2022 the Supreme Court held that GST Council recommendations are not binding on the Centre or states and have persuasive value. The judgment stressed cooperative federalism and the right of both Parliament and legislatures to legislate on GST.

What happened to the compensation cess after 2022?

Compensation payments to states ended in June 2022, but the cess continued to repay the pandemic loans. After GST 2.0, cess was removed on most goods, and from 1 February 2026 the tobacco and pan masala levies were notified to be replaced by excise duty and a health and national security cess.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Compensation Act guarantees states 14 per cent annual growth in revenue over the base year 2015-16.
True

The guarantee ran for five years to June 2022.

2 The GST Compensation Fund is financed mainly by SGST.
False

It is financed by the compensation cess on demerit goods.

3 The Centre borrowed to meet the COVID-19 shortfall and lent to states as back-to-back loans.
True

About Rs 2.69 lakh crore across two years.

4 The Supreme Court in Mohit Minerals held that Council recommendations are binding on states.
False

It held them persuasive, not binding.

Share: