Categorising Poverty: Chronic Poor, Churning Poor, Occasionally / Transient Poor; Human Poverty Index (HPI)
Indian Economy › Poverty, Inequality, Human and Sustainable Development · Topic 20.4
Poverty can be categorised by how long people stay poor. The chronic poor are always poor or usually poor; the churning poor move in and out of poverty, sometimes above and sometimes below the line; the occasionally or transient poor are usually not poor but fall below the line during shocks such as illness or crop loss; and the never poor remain above the line. The Human Poverty Index (HPI), introduced by UNDP in the Human Development Report of 1997, measured deprivation in longevity, knowledge and living standards, and was replaced by the Multidimensional Poverty Index in 2010. The distinction matters because chronic poverty needs long-term asset and skills support, while transient poverty needs insurance and safety nets.
5 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Poverty, Inequality, Human and Sustainable Development
At a Glance
- Chronic poor Always or usually poor
- Churning poor Move in and out of poverty
- Transient poor Occasionally poor, due to shocks
- Never poor Always above the line
- HPI UNDP, 1997, replaced by MPI in 2010
- Policy need Chronic: assets and skills; transient: insurance
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Poverty, Inequality, Human and Sustainable Development
Where Does It Fit?
This topic follows Expert Groups for Estimating Poverty: Alagh, Lakdawala, Tendulkar, Rangarajan and leads to NITI Aayog, 12 indicators Poor if deprived in…">Multidimensional Poverty: Global MPI (Health, Education, Standard of Living); National MPI (OPHI and UNDP Reference); Socio-Economic Caste Census (SECC) on multidimensional poverty. The Mains view is in Poverty in India: types of poverty, causes, vicious circle of poverty; trickle-down approach, inclusive growth, MPI. Previous topic: Expert Groups for Estimating Poverty: Alagh, Lakdawala, Tendulkar, Rangarajan. Next topic: Multidimensional Poverty: Global MPI (Health, Education, Standard of Living); National MPI (OPHI and UNDP Reference); Socio-Economic Caste Census (SECC).
What Are the Categories of the Poor?
| Category | Meaning | Typical cause and policy |
|---|---|---|
| Chronic poor | Always poor or usually poor over a long period | Landlessness, low skills, social exclusion and disability. Need asset transfers, skills, health and education |
| Churning poor | Poor in some periods and non-poor in others, moving around the poverty line | Irregular income and low savings. Need stable jobs and access to credit |
| Occasionally poor | Usually not poor but fall below the line in some periods | Shocks such as illness, drought or job loss |
| Transient poor | People who are poor for short spells | Insurance and safety nets such as employment guarantee help them |
| Never poor | Always above the poverty line | Not targeted by poverty programmes |
| Vulnerable | Not poor now but at risk of falling into poverty | Health expenses and climate shocks |
| Why it matters | Different groups need different policies | Targeting improves with panel data that follows households over time |
What Was the Human Poverty Index?
| Aspect | Facts |
|---|---|
| Introduction | UNDP introduced the Human Poverty Index in the Human Development Report of 1997 |
| Purpose | To measure deprivation, rather than only average achievement as in the HDI, as in Human Development: Meaning; Approaches: Income, Welfare, Basic Needs, Capability (Amartya Sen); Human Development Report; HDI Dimensions; Gender Development Index |
| HPI-1 dimensions | For developing countries: the probability of not surviving to age 40, adult illiteracy, and deprivation in living standards measured by lack of access to safe water and underweight children |
| HPI-2 | For industrialised countries, with a different set of indicators including long-term unemployment |
| Replacement | The HPI was replaced by the Multidimensional Poverty Index from the Human Development Report of 2010 |
| Difference from MPI | The HPI used country averages, while the MPI uses household-level deprivation, as in Multidimensional Poverty: Global MPI (Health, Education, Standard of Living); National MPI (OPHI and UNDP Reference); Socio-Economic Caste Census (SECC) |
| Legacy | The HPI helped move poverty measurement beyond income |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Also called: Churning poverty is also called transitory movement around the line. HPI is the Human Poverty Index. Panel data follows the same households over several years
- Why panel data: Only repeated surveys of the same households can show who is chronically poor and who is churning
- Link to shocks: Health costs and crop failures push people into poverty, which insurance schemes address, as in pmjjby-pmsby-atal-pension-yojana-employees-provident-fund/" class="maargx-auto-link" data-preview="At a Glance Launch date 9 May 2015 (PMJJBY, PMSBY, APY) PMJJBY Rs 2 lakh life cover, Rs 436 a year PMSBY…">PMJJBY, PMSBY, Atal Pension Yojana; Employees’ Provident Fund and Health Schemes: National Health Mission, ASHA, Janani Suraksha Yojana, Ayushman Bharat
- Link to employment guarantee: MGNREGA gives work in lean periods and helps the transient poor, as in pmegp-anti-poverty-fund-monitoring/" class="maargx-auto-link" data-preview="At a Glance REGP and PMRY 1995 and 1993, merged into PMEGP in 2008 SJSRY 1997, urban self-employment and wage employment SGSY…">Poverty Alleviation Programmes: REGP, PMRY, Swarna Jayanti Shahari Rozgar Yojana, SGSY, DRDAs, MGNREGA (Guarantee Act), PMEGP; Anti-Poverty Fund Monitoring
- Policy mix: Chronic poverty needs long-term investment, and churning needs stable income and credit, as in DAY-NRLM in 2015 SHG members About 10 crore rural…">Self Help Groups and Credit; SGSY / NRLM
- Social groups: Chronic poverty is higher among groups facing exclusion, such as Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
- Exam hint: Remember the four groups and that HPI was replaced by MPI in 2010
- Common errors: Mixing HPI and HDI. HPI measures deprivation while HDI measures average achievement
- Another common error: Treating all poor as the same. Policy design depends on the duration of poverty
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Chronic: Always poor
- Churning: In and out
- Transient: Occasionally, from shocks
- HPI: 1997, replaced by MPI in 2010
- HPI-1: Survival to 40, illiteracy, living standards
As an analytical point, poverty is a flow as well as a stock. Many households move across the line, so protecting the near-poor from shocks is as important as helping the chronic poor out of poverty.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Types Chronic, churning, transient
- HPI Deprivation index
- Policy Differentiated
What Came Next?
The next topic covers multidimensional poverty: the Global MPI, the national MPI and the Socio-Economic Caste Census. Next topic: Multidimensional Poverty: Global MPI (Health, Education, Standard of Living); National MPI (OPHI and UNDP Reference); Socio-Economic Caste Census (SECC).
Key People and Terms
- Chronic poverty Long-term poverty
- Churning Movement around the line
- Transient Short-term poverty
- HPI Human Poverty Index
- Vulnerability Risk of falling into poverty
- Panel data Repeated household data
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Chronic: always poor; churning: in and out.
- Transient: shock-driven.
- HPI: 1997; replaced by MPI in 2010.
- HPI-1: survival, illiteracy, living standards.
- Chronic poor need assets and skills.
Do Not Confuse With
- Chronic and transient poor Long-term versus short-spell poverty
- HPI and HDI Deprivation versus average achievement
- HPI and MPI Older country-level index versus household-level index
Memory Hook
Chronic stays, churning moves, transient falls by shock, and HPI gave way to MPI.
Mains Angle
Prelims tests the categories and the HPI. Mains answers differentiate policies by duration.
- Categories Duration of poverty
- Policy Assets versus insurance
- Index HPI to MPI
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Distinguish between chronic and transient poverty and explain how policy should differ for each.”
How to Answer
- Intro Poverty dynamics.
- Categories Chronic, churning, transient.
- Policy Assets, insurance, jobs.
- Conclude Targeted support.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is chronic poverty?
Chronic poverty is a condition in which people are always poor or poor for long periods, often because of landlessness, low skills, disability or social exclusion. It needs long-term support such as assets, skills, health and education to break the cycle.
What are the churning poor?
The churning poor are households that move in and out of poverty, being poor in some periods and above the poverty line in others, because of irregular income and low savings. They need stable employment and access to credit and insurance.
Who are the transient poor?
The transient or occasionally poor are households that are usually not poor but fall below the poverty line for short periods because of shocks such as illness, drought or job loss. Insurance and safety nets such as employment guarantee schemes help them.
What was the Human Poverty Index?
The Human Poverty Index was introduced by UNDP in the Human Development Report of 1997 to measure deprivation in longevity, knowledge and living standards, such as the probability of not surviving to 40, adult illiteracy and lack of safe water and underweight children.
Why was the HPI replaced?
The HPI was replaced by the Multidimensional Poverty Index from the Human Development Report of 2010 because the MPI measures deprivation at the household level and shows who is poor and in what ways, while the HPI used averages for countries.
Why does the duration of poverty matter for policy?
Policy design depends on whether poverty is long-term or short-term. Chronic poverty needs investments in assets, skills and services, while transient poverty needs insurance, safety nets and stable income, so panel data on households is useful for targeting.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The churning poor move in and out of poverty.
They are poor in some periods only.
2 The HPI was introduced by UNDP in 1997.
It was replaced by the MPI in 2010.
3 The HPI measures average achievement in human development.
That is the HDI. HPI measures deprivation.
4 The chronic poor are those who fall below the line only during shocks.
They are always or usually poor.
5 MPI replaced the HPI in 2010.
It uses household-level data.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index