Expert Groups for Estimating Poverty: Alagh, Lakdawala, Tendulkar, Rangarajan
Indian Economy › Poverty, Inequality, Human and Sustainable Development · Topic 20.3
India's official poverty estimates have been guided by successive expert groups. The Task Force chaired by Y K Alagh (1979) defined poverty by the cost of a food basket giving 2,400 calories in rural and 2,100 calories in urban areas. The Lakdawala Committee (1993) used state-specific lines updated with the Consumer Price Index for Industrial Workers and for Agricultural Labourers and estimated poverty at 36 per cent in 1993-94. The Tendulkar Committee (2009) moved to a Mixed Reference Period consumption method and a single urban-based basket, giving 21.9 per cent in 2011-12. The Rangarajan Committee (2014) used a wider basket of food and non-food items and estimated 29.5 per cent in 2011-12.
5 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Poverty, Inequality, Human and Sustainable Development
At a Glance
- Alagh 1979, 2,400 and 2,100 calorie norms
- Lakdawala 1993, state-specific lines, 36 per cent in 1993-94
- Tendulkar 2009, MRP method, 21.9 per cent in 2011-12
- Rangarajan 2014, wider basket, 29.5 per cent in 2011-12
- Rural line (Tendulkar) Rs 816 a month
- Urban line (Rangarajan) Rs 1,407 a month
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Poverty, Inequality, Human and Sustainable Development
Where Does It Fit?
This topic follows Poverty Line: World Bank Definition; Urban vs Rural Daily Expenditure; State-wise Poverty Lines vary due to Price Levels; Price Indices (CPI-IW, CPI-AL) and matches Poverty Estimation Groups: Alagh, Lakdawala, Tendulkar, Rangarajan. The Mains view is in Poverty lines in India: estimations and committees; addressing poverty / poverty eradication schemes. Previous topic: Poverty Line: World Bank Definition; Urban vs Rural Daily Expenditure; State-wise Poverty Lines vary due to Price Levels; Price Indices (CPI-IW, CPI-AL). Next topic: Categorising Poverty: Chronic Poor, Churning Poor, Occasionally / Transient Poor; Human Poverty Index (HPI).
How Did Each Expert Group Estimate Poverty?
| Group | Method | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Alagh Task Force (1979) | Calorie-based: a food basket giving 2,400 calories a day in rural and 2,100 in urban areas, with the cost used as the line | The basis of the early official estimates from 1973-74 prices |
| Lakdawala Committee (1993) | Kept the calorie norms but used state-specific poverty lines and updated them with CPI-IW for urban and CPI-AL for rural areas | 36 per cent poverty in 1993-94 |
| Tendulkar Committee (2009) | Dropped the calorie norm and used a Mixed Reference Period consumption estimate, with a single basket based on urban consumption and inclusion of spending on health and education | 37.2 per cent in 2004-05 and 21.9 per cent in 2011-12 |
| Rangarajan Committee (2014) | Used a wider basket with a normative level of food, non-food items such as housing, education and health, and different rural and urban baskets | 29.5 per cent in 2011-12 with lines of Rs 972 rural and Rs 1,407 urban |
| Tendulkar lines, 2011-12 | Rs 816 rural and Rs 1,000 urban per person per month | Lower than Rangarajan lines |
| Number of poor, 2011-12 | 26.9 crore under Tendulkar and 36.3 crore under Rangarajan | The difference is due to the line level |
| Official position | After Rangarajan, no new official line was adopted, and policy refers to multidimensional measures | As in NITI Aayog, 12 indicators Poor if deprived in…">Multidimensional Poverty: Global MPI (Health, Education, Standard of Living); National MPI (OPHI and UNDP Reference); Socio-Economic Caste Census (SECC) |
What Do the Differences Show?
| Issue | Analysis |
|---|---|
| Calorie norm | Alagh and Lakdawala used calories, but calorie needs differ and consumption of calories can fall as incomes rise, so Tendulkar dropped the norm |
| Mixed Reference Period | A method that asks about consumption of some items over 365 days and others over 7 days, to better capture spending on infrequent items |
| State lines | Lakdawala’s state-specific lines recognised price differences across states |
| Wider basket | Rangarajan included more non-food spending to define a more adequate minimum |
| Why numbers differ | Different baskets and methods give different poverty ratios for the same year, such as 21.9 and 29.5 per cent in 2011-12 |
| Policy use | Targeting of schemes uses other criteria, such as the Socio-Economic Caste Census, as in Multidimensional Poverty: Global MPI (Health, Education, Standard of Living); National MPI (OPHI and UNDP Reference); Socio-Economic Caste Census (SECC) |
| Data issue | Poverty lines depend on consumption survey data, and the consumption surveys had comparability issues across years |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Also called: Tendulkar’s method is called the Mixed Reference Period (MRP). The Planning Commission used these estimates until 2014
- Chronology: Alagh 1979, Lakdawala 1993, Tendulkar 2009, Rangarajan 2014, in that order
- Link to NITI Aayog: The Planning Commission was replaced by NITI Aayog in 2015, which now publishes the national multidimensional poverty index
- Method change: The shift from calorie to expenditure-based lines reflects the finding that calorie intake fell even as incomes rose
- Worked check: The difference between 29.5 and 21.9 per cent is 7.6 percentage points, which equals about 9.4 crore more poor people under Rangarajan, since 36.3 minus 26.9 is 9.4
- Link to inequality: Poverty estimates depend on the lower tail of the consumption distribution, as in Inequality: Definition and Measures; Lorenz Curve, Gini Coefficient, Palma Ratio, Kuznets Curve; Income Held by Top 10%
- Exam hint: Match each group with its year and its main change in method
- Common errors: Writing that Tendulkar used calories. It dropped the calorie norm
- Another common error: Mixing the years: Rangarajan was 2014 and Tendulkar was 2009
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Alagh: 1979, calories
- Lakdawala: 1993, state lines
- Tendulkar: 2009, MRP, 21.9 per cent
- Rangarajan: 2014, wider basket, 29.5 per cent
- Difference: 9.4 crore more poor under Rangarajan
As an analytical point, the evolution of expert groups shows a move from nutrition to broader living standards. No single line is correct, and the choice of basket shapes the number of poor, which is why the policy emphasis has shifted to multidimensional measures.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Groups Four expert groups
- Methods Calories to expenditure
- Results 21.9 versus 29.5 per cent
What Came Next?
The next topic covers categories of the poor: chronic, churning and transient poverty, and the Human Poverty Index. Next topic: Categorising Poverty: Chronic Poor, Churning Poor, Occasionally / Transient Poor; Human Poverty Index (HPI).
Key People and Terms
- Task Force Expert group on a task
- Calorie norm Minimum calories for a line
- MRP Mixed Reference Period
- State-specific line Line by state
- Normative basket Basket of needed goods
- Poverty ratio Share of the poor
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Alagh: 1979; Lakdawala: 1993.
- Tendulkar: 2009; Rangarajan: 2014.
- 2011-12: 21.9 and 29.5 per cent.
- Tendulkar dropped the calorie norm.
- Lakdawala: state-specific lines.
Do Not Confuse With
- Tendulkar and Rangarajan Narrow basket giving 21.9 per cent versus wider basket giving 29.5 per cent
- Alagh and Lakdawala Calorie-based national lines versus state-specific lines
- MRP and URP Mixed reference period versus uniform recall
Memory Hook
Alagh counted calories, Lakdawala went state by state, Tendulkar used spending, Rangarajan widened the basket.
Mains Angle
Prelims asks to match groups with methods and years. Mains answers use the debate on the line.
- Evolution Calories to expenditure
- Numbers 21.9 versus 29.5
- Shift To MPI
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Trace the evolution of poverty estimation in India through the expert groups and explain why their estimates differ.”
How to Answer
- Intro Poverty line debate.
- Groups Alagh to Rangarajan.
- Differences Baskets and methods.
- Conclude Move to MPI.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Alagh Task Force recommend?
The Task Force on Projections of Minimum Needs and Effective Consumption Demand, chaired by Y K Alagh in 1979, defined poverty by the cost of a food basket giving 2,400 calories a day in rural areas and 2,100 in urban areas, which was the basis of early official estimates.
What was the Lakdawala Committee's contribution?
The Lakdawala Committee of 1993 kept calorie norms but introduced state-specific poverty lines, updated using the Consumer Price Index for Industrial Workers for urban areas and for Agricultural Labourers for rural areas, and estimated poverty at 36 per cent in 1993-94.
What did the Tendulkar Committee change?
The Tendulkar Committee of 2009 dropped the calorie norm, used a Mixed Reference Period method of consumption and a single basket based on urban consumption including health and education spending, and estimated poverty at 37.2 per cent in 2004-05 and 21.9 per cent in 2011-12.
What did the Rangarajan Committee estimate?
The Rangarajan Committee of 2014 used a wider basket of food and non-food items and set lines of Rs 972 per month for rural and Rs 1,407 for urban areas in 2011-12, giving a poverty ratio of 29.5 per cent, or about 36.3 crore people.
Why do the Tendulkar and Rangarajan estimates differ?
They differ because of the baskets and methods used. Tendulkar's narrower basket gave 21.9 per cent poverty, while Rangarajan's wider basket with more non-food items gave 29.5 per cent for the same year, a difference of about 9.4 crore people.
Is there an official poverty line in India now?
No new official line has been adopted after the Rangarajan report of 2014, and the Planning Commission was replaced by NITI Aayog in 2015. Policy now relies on multidimensional measures such as the national MPI, alongside consumption survey data.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The Tendulkar Committee reported in 2009.
It estimated 21.9 per cent poverty in 2011-12.
2 The Rangarajan Committee gave a lower poverty ratio than the Tendulkar Committee for 2011-12.
It gave 29.5 per cent against 21.9 per cent.
3 Lakdawala introduced state-specific poverty lines.
It reported in 1993.
4 The Alagh Task Force used a 2,400 calorie norm for rural areas.
The urban norm was 2,100 calories.
5 The Tendulkar Committee used the calorie norm.
It dropped the calorie norm.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index