Banking sector reforms: Narasimham I and II, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak
Indian Economy › Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality · Topic 6.27
Banking sector reforms in India are the successive changes in how banks are regulated, owned and run, recommended mainly by four committees. The Narasimham Committee of 1991 began liberalisation by cutting reserve ratios, freeing interest rates and bringing in prudential norms. The Narasimham Committee of 1998 pushed capital adequacy, lower non-performing assets and bank mergers. The Nachiket Mor Committee of 2014 proposed universal accounts and differentiated banks for inclusion. The P.J. Nayak Committee of 2014 reviewed governance and recommended reducing government control. Together they shaped today's sector, where scheduled commercial banks had a gross NPA ratio of 1.8 per cent in March 2026.
8 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality
At a Glance
- Narasimham I 1991: SLR and CRR cuts, prudential norms, four tier banks
- Narasimham II 1998: CAR 9% by 2000 and 10% by 2002, NPAs lower, mergers
- Nachiket Mor 2014: universal bank account, payments and wholesale banks
- P.J. Nayak 2014: bank governance, Bank Investment Company
- Outcome (Mar 2026) GNPA 1.8%, CRAR 17.7% for scheduled commercial banks
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality
Where Does It Fit?
This Mains topic reads the committee list in Banking Sector Reforms: Narasimham Committees (1991, 1998), Verma Committee, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act 2020; Mission Indradhanush as a story of reform. It is a bridge between the structure pages, such as Differentiated Banks: Payments Banks (Nachiket Mor Committee); Small Finance Banks (Narasimham / Sivaraman Committee); Minimum Capital and Lending Norms, and the credit quality pages, such as Problem of NPAs in India: causes, impact, resolution mechanisms. Previous topic: Problem of NPAs in India: causes, impact, resolution mechanisms. Next topic: NBFCs in India: role, regulation and concerns.
What Did the Four Committees Recommend and What Was Implemented?
| Committee | Key recommendations and outcome |
|---|---|
| Narasimham Committee I (1991), Committee on the Financial System | It recommended a phased cut in the statutory liquidity ratio (SLR) to 25 per cent and a lower cash reserve ratio, deregulation of interest rates, prudential norms for income recognition, asset classification and provisioning, a capital adequacy norm in line with Basel, a four tier banking structure, an Asset Reconstruction Fund, debt recovery tribunals, a separate supervisory body and freer entry of private banks. Most were adopted from 1992 onwards, and tribunals followed in 1993. A fully four tier structure was not built |
| Narasimham Committee II (1998), Committee on Banking Sector Reforms | It recommended raising capital adequacy to 9 per cent by 2000 and 10 per cent by 2002, cutting gross NPAs to 5 per cent by 2000 and 3 per cent by 2002, merging strong banks, narrow banking for weak banks, lower government equity, a stronger supervisory board and asset reconstruction companies. Capital norms and the Securitisation Act of 2002 followed. Narrow banking and a quick fall in government holdings were not adopted |
| Nachiket Mor Committee (2014), Committee on Comprehensive Financial Services for Small Businesses and Low-Income Households | It recommended a universal electronic bank account for every resident above 18, a vertical set of differentiated banks, namely payments banks and wholesale banks, a stronger national payments system, and a rethink of priority sector lending. Payments banks and small finance banks were created from 2015, and Jan Dhan accounts delivered account access, as in Differentiated Banks: Payments Banks (Nachiket Mor Committee); Small Finance Banks (Narasimham / Sivaraman Committee); Minimum Capital and Lending Norms |
| P.J. Nayak Committee (2014), review of governance of bank boards | It recommended that the government create a Bank Investment Company (BIC) to hold its stakes, reduce its holding below 50 per cent, make boards professional, align pay with private banks and ease external vigilance burdens. The Bank Board Bureau followed in 2016, and the Financial Services Institutions Bureau replaced it later, as in Bank Board Bureau / Financial Services Institutions Bureau; Banking Ombudsman; Priority Sector Lending (PSL) and PSL Certificates; Weaker Sections Categories. The BIC was not created and the government stayed the majority owner |
How Do the Committees Compare on Themes?
| Theme | Narasimham I, Narasimham II, Mor, Nayak |
|---|---|
| Liberalisation | Narasimham I freed interest rates and cut SLR and CRR. Narasimham II continued it but stressed risk management |
| Safety and capital | Both Narasimham reports focused on capital adequacy and NPAs, a path that led to Basel II and III, as in Basel Norms I, II, III: Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR), Tier-1 and Tier-2 Capital; Capital Conservation Buffer |
| Structure and consolidation | Narasimham I wanted four tiers. Narasimham II wanted mergers of strong banks. Mergers cut public sector banks from 27 to 12 by 2020, as in Nationalisation of Banks; State Bank of India; Merger of Associate Banks with SBI; PSB Consolidation |
| Inclusion | Mor placed small borrowers at the centre and led to payments banks, small finance banks and universal accounts |
| Ownership and governance | Narasimham II and Nayak asked for less government ownership and more board autonomy. Mission Indradhanush of 2015 adopted several governance steps but not a fall in ownership |
| Resolution of bad loans | The 1991 report proposed tribunals and a reconstruction fund. These ideas grew into DRTs, SARFAESI, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code and NARCL, as in NPA Resolution: SARFAESI Act 2002, Debt Recovery Tribunals (DRTs), Lok Adalat, Asset Reconstruction Companies (ARC), Inter-Creditor Agreement (Project Sashakt), Bad Bank / NARCL |
| Competition | Entry of private banks after 1993, foreign banks and differentiated licences raised competition |
| Supervision | A separate body for supervision led to the Board for Financial Supervision, and from 2020 cooperative banks came under tighter RBI control through an amendment to the Banking Regulation Act |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Narasimham I in context: the committee was formed in 1991 during the balance of payments crisis, under former RBI Governor M. Narasimham. Banks were then burdened by high SLR and CRR, administered rates and directed credit, so profit and capital were weak
- Narasimham II in context: it came after the Asian crisis of 1997 and examined whether Indian banks were strong enough to meet global norms. It is the base of risk weights for government securities and asset liability management guidelines
- Mor in context: it recognised that millions lacked a basic account in 2014. Account access has since expanded, with the Financial Inclusion Index at 70.0 in March 2026, as reported by the RBI, as discussed in pmjdy-payment-banks-and-small-banks/" class="maargx-auto-link" data-preview="At a Glance FI-Index (Mar 2026) 70.0, up from 67.0 in Mar 2025 and 64.2 in Mar 2024 PMJDY launch 28 August…">Financial inclusion: need, significance, steps, challenges and way forward; PMJDY; Payment Banks and Small Banks
- Nayak in context: governance failures in public sector banks were seen as a root of bad loans. Board quality, term of heads and pay structure were the main concern
- What worked: capital and asset quality rose, with a GNPA ratio of 1.8 per cent in March 2026 and CRAR of 17.7 per cent, public sector banks earned a record net profit of Rs 1,98,210 crore in 2025-26, as reported, and digital access grew
- What did not work fully: government still owns most large banks, the Bank Investment Company was not set up, narrow banking was not adopted, and payments banks have found low margins difficult because they cannot lend
- Critique: reform came in waves after crises rather than as a steady programme. Credit to large borrowers rose with weak monitoring in the 2000s despite earlier prudential steps, showing that rules alone do not fix incentives
- Way forward: complete governance reform with professional boards and longer tenures, move ahead with stake sales, reduce political and vigilance fear in lending decisions, use technology for inclusion, adopt expected loss provisioning, and review the differentiated bank model as in Banking sector: challenges and measures taken to promote its growth
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Typical question: discuss the recommendations of the Narasimham committees and subsequent reforms, and evaluate their impact
- Structure: committee by committee table; implemented versus pending; impact data; way forward
- Data points: SLR target 25 per cent, CAR 9 per cent by 2000 and 10 per cent by 2002, NPA 5 and 3 per cent targets, GNPA 1.8 per cent in March 2026
- Prelims angle: matching committee with theme, as in Banking Sector Reforms: Narasimham Committees (1991, 1998), Verma Committee, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act 2020; Mission Indradhanush
- Common error: mixing up the 1991 and 1998 recommendations, or crediting Mor with the Bank Board Bureau
As an analytical point, the reforms of the Narasimham committees built the rules of the sector, Mor widened its reach and Nayak aimed at governance. The unfinished part is ownership and governance, which will decide whether the gains of 2026 last.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Committees Frequent factual questions
- Mains Evaluation of reform
- Link Credit quality and inclusion
What Came Next?
The next topic examines non-banking financial companies, their role, regulation and concerns. Next topic: NBFCs in India: role, regulation and concerns.
Key People and Terms
- SLR Share of deposits held in liquid assets
- CAR Capital to risk weighted assets
- Narrow banking Deposits only in safe assets
- BIC Bank Investment Company holding government stakes
- Payments bank Deposit and payment bank that cannot lend
- Prudential norms Rules for income, classification and provisioning
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Narasimham I: 1991; II: 1998.
- Narasimham II CAR: 9 per cent by 2000, 10 per cent by 2002.
- Nachiket Mor: 2014, payments banks and universal account.
- Nayak: 2014, governance and BIC.
- Public sector banks: 27 to 12.
Do Not Confuse With
- Narasimham I and II Liberalisation and prudential norms versus capital, NPA targets and mergers
- Nachiket Mor and P.J. Nayak Inclusion and differentiated banks versus governance of bank boards
- Bank Board Bureau and Bank Investment Company A body to select heads versus a proposed holding company for government stakes
Memory Hook
Narasimham freed and fortified, Mor widened, Nayak governed.
Mains Angle
Questions ask for a comparison and for an evaluation. These points give a clean frame.
- Liberalise Narasimham I
- Strengthen Narasimham II
- Include Nachiket Mor
- Govern P.J. Nayak
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Critically examine the recommendations of the Narasimham committees, the Nachiket Mor Committee and the P.J. Nayak Committee and assess how far they have been implemented.”
How to Answer
- Intro Banking reform as a series of committees from 1991 to 2014.
- Body 1 Narasimham I and II recommendations and results.
- Body 2 Mor and Nayak, and what was adopted.
- Body 3 Gaps in ownership and governance.
- Conclusion Strong rules help only when ownership and boards support risk based lending.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What were the recommendations of the Narasimham Committee 1991?
The 1991 Narasimham Committee recommended a phased cut in SLR to 25 per cent and a lower CRR, free interest rates, prudential norms for income recognition and provisioning, a capital adequacy norm, a four tier banking structure, debt recovery tribunals, a separate supervisory body and entry of private banks.
What did the Narasimham Committee 1998 recommend?
The 1998 committee recommended capital adequacy of 9 per cent by 2000 and 10 per cent by 2002, a reduction of gross NPAs to 5 per cent by 2000 and 3 per cent by 2002, mergers of strong banks, narrow banking for weak banks, lower government equity and asset reconstruction companies.
What is the Nachiket Mor Committee report?
The Nachiket Mor Committee of 2014 examined financial services for small businesses and low-income households. It recommended a universal electronic bank account for every resident above 18, payments banks and wholesale banks, and better payment systems. Payments banks and small finance banks were created from 2015.
What did the P.J. Nayak Committee recommend?
The P.J. Nayak Committee of 2014 reviewed the governance of bank boards. It proposed a Bank Investment Company to hold government stakes, a reduction of government holding below 50 per cent, professional boards and pay in line with private banks. The Bank Board Bureau was created in 2016.
What is the difference between the Narasimham and Nachiket Mor committees?
The Narasimham committees dealt with the stability and efficiency of the banking system, covering reserve ratios, capital and bad loans. The Nachiket Mor Committee focused on financial inclusion, proposing universal accounts and differentiated banks such as payments banks. One built soundness and the other expanded reach.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The Narasimham Committee of 1991 recommended a phased reduction of SLR to 25 per cent.
This was a key liberalising recommendation.
2 The Nachiket Mor Committee recommended the creation of payments banks.
Along with a universal electronic bank account.
3 The P.J. Nayak Committee dealt with priority sector lending targets.
It reviewed the governance of bank boards.
4 The Narasimham Committee of 1998 recommended capital adequacy of 9 per cent by 2000.
And 10 per cent by 2002.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index