Basel Norms I, II, III: Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR), Tier-1 and Tier-2 Capital; Capital Conservation Buffer
Indian Economy › Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality · Topic 6.10
The Basel norms are international banking standards issued by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision at the Bank for International Settlements, which require banks to hold capital against the risks they run. The capital adequacy ratio (CAR, also called CRAR, capital to risk weighted assets ratio) equals Tier 1 plus Tier 2 capital divided by risk weighted assets. Basel I (1988) covered credit risk, Basel II (2004) added market and operational risk with three pillars, and Basel III (after 2008) raised capital quality and added the capital conservation buffer, leverage ratio and liquidity standards. In India the minimum CAR is 9 per cent plus a 2.5 per cent capital conservation buffer, so 11.5 per cent. Scheduled commercial banks had a CRAR of 17.7 per cent in March 2026.
9 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality
At a Glance
- CAR formula (Tier 1 + Tier 2) / RWA x 100
- India minimum CAR 9 per cent, plus CCB 2.5 per cent = 11.5 per cent
- India minimum CET1 5.5 per cent, plus CCB = 8 per cent
- Basel committee minimum 8 per cent total, CET1 4.5 per cent
- CRAR of SCBs, March 2026 17.7 per cent; CET1 15.3 per cent
- Basel III credit risk rules Final, effective 1 April 2027, as reported
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality
Where Does It Fit?
After the balance sheet and its ratios in Bank Balance Sheet: Assets (Investments, Money at Call, Loans and Advances, Bills Discounted), Liabilities, Net Worth; CASA; Provision Coverage Ratio; Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR), this topic explains the capital rule that governs the liability side. The reforms behind these norms, such as the committees that set the first Indian capital targets, are in Banking Sector Reforms: Narasimham Committees (1991, 1998), Verma Committee, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act 2020; Mission Indradhanush, and the supervisory action when capital falls is in CAMEL Parameters; Prompt Corrective Action (PCA); Selective Credit Control. Previous topic: Bank Balance Sheet: Assets (Investments, Money at Call, Loans and Advances, Bills Discounted), Liabilities, Net Worth; CASA; Provision Coverage Ratio; Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR). Next topic: Banking Sector Reforms: Narasimham Committees (1991, 1998), Verma Committee, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act 2020; Mission Indradhanush.
What Are Basel I, Basel II and Basel III?
| Feature | Basel I (1988) | Basel II (2004) | Basel III (2010 onwards) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trigger | Rising international bank risk in the 1980s | Need for a risk sensitive rule | Global financial crisis of 2007-09 |
| Risks covered | Credit risk only | Credit, market and operational risk | Same, plus liquidity, leverage and systemic risk |
| Minimum total capital | 8 per cent of risk weighted assets | 8 per cent | 8 per cent, plus 2.5 per cent conservation buffer |
| Structure | Simple risk weights of 0, 20, 50 and 100 per cent | Three pillars: minimum capital, supervisory review, market discipline | Higher quality capital, buffers, leverage ratio, LCR and NSFR |
| Indian adoption | 1992, with 8 per cent reached by March 1996 | March 2008 for some banks, March 2009 for all | Phased from April 2013 and completed on 31 March 2019 |
| Indian minimum CAR | 8 per cent, raised to 9 per cent by March 2000 | 9 per cent | 9 per cent plus 2.5 per cent buffer |
What Is Tier 1 and Tier 2 Capital in India?
| Layer | What it includes | Indian minimum (percent of RWA) |
|---|---|---|
| Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) | Equity share capital, share premium, statutory reserves and retained earnings, less deductions | 5.5 per cent |
| Additional Tier 1 (AT1) | Perpetual non-cumulative preference shares and perpetual debt instruments that can be written down | Up to 1.5 per cent, so Tier 1 totals at least 7 per cent |
| Tier 2 | Subordinated debt, revaluation reserves, general provisions up to a limit, hybrid debt | Up to 2 per cent, so total capital totals at least 9 per cent |
| Capital conservation buffer (CCB) | Extra CET1 held above the minimum, usable in stress | 2.5 per cent, so CET1 8 per cent, Tier 1 9.5 per cent, total 11.5 per cent |
| Countercyclical capital buffer (CCyB) | CET1 buffer built in credit booms, range 0 to 2.5 per cent | Available to the RBI, not activated so far, as reported |
| Leverage ratio | Tier 1 capital / total exposure, a non risk based backstop | 4 per cent for banks, higher for D-SIBs |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Also called: Capital adequacy ratio is also called capital to risk weighted assets ratio (CRAR) and, in older texts, capital to risk assets ratio (CRAR) or the solvency ratio. The Basel committee sits at the Bank for International Settlements in Basel, Switzerland, and its rules are not law, so each country issues them. In India the RBI issues them
- Risk weighted assets: Each asset is multiplied by a risk weight. Cash and government securities carry 0 per cent, a standard housing loan carries a lower weight than an unrated corporate loan at 100 per cent, and risky exposures carry more. The sum is the risk weighted assets (RWA), and the weighting makes a safe balance sheet need less capital
- Worked CAR example: Take a bank with CET1 of Rs 1,100 crore, Additional Tier 1 of Rs 150 crore, Tier 2 of Rs 400 crore and risk weighted assets of Rs 12,000 crore. Tier 1 = 1,100 + 150 = Rs 1,250 crore. CAR = (1,250 + 400) / 12,000 = 13.75 per cent. CET1 ratio = 1,100 / 12,000 = 9.17 per cent and Tier 1 ratio = 1,250 / 12,000 = 10.42 per cent. Against the buffer inclusive minimums of 8, 9.5 and 11.5 per cent, all three clear
- Worked risk weight example: A bank lends Rs 200 crore to a company with a 100 per cent risk weight and invests Rs 300 crore in government securities at 0 per cent. RWA = 200 x 1.00 + 300 x 0 = Rs 200 crore. At 11.5 per cent the capital needed is 200 x 0.115 = Rs 23 crore. If the Rs 200 crore loan were instead a housing loan at 50 per cent, the capital needed would halve to Rs 11.5 crore (an illustrative weight), showing how weights steer lending
- How the capital conservation buffer works: If CET1 falls into the buffer zone, the bank must retain part of its earnings and cannot pay full dividends or bonuses. With an India minimum CET1 of 5.5 per cent and a buffer of 2.5 per cent, the quartiles are 5.5 to 6.125 per cent (100 per cent of earnings retained), 6.125 to 6.75 (80 per cent), 6.75 to 7.375 (60 per cent), 7.375 to 8.0 (40 per cent) and above 8.0 (no restriction). The buffer was fully phased in by 31 March 2019 after one extension
- Why India is stricter than Basel: The Basel committee minimum is 8 per cent total and 4.5 per cent CET1. India requires 9 per cent total and 5.5 per cent CET1 before the buffer, reflecting the high share of PSBs and the history of bad loans, as covered in Non-Performing Assets (NPAs): Classification, Provisioning, Twin Balance Sheet Problem; Willful Defaulters; Rectification, Restructuring, Recovery
- Pillars of Basel II and III: Pillar 1 sets minimum capital for credit, market and operational risk, Pillar 2 is the supervisory review process in which the RBI can ask for more capital, and Pillar 3 is market discipline through disclosure
- Liquidity and leverage under Basel III: Basel III adds the liquidity coverage ratio and the net stable funding ratio, each with a minimum of 100 per cent, as explained in Bank Balance Sheet: Assets (Investments, Money at Call, Loans and Advances, Bills Discounted), Liabilities, Net Worth; CASA; Provision Coverage Ratio; Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR), and a leverage ratio. A 4 per cent leverage ratio means that a bank with Tier 1 capital of Rs 400 crore can have total exposure of at most Rs 10,000 crore, since 400 / 10,000 = 4 per cent
- Systemic banks: Banks that are too big to fail face a higher CET1 requirement, called the D-SIB surcharge. SBI, HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank have been named D-SIBs in the latest RBI lists, as reported. The method is in Recapitalisation of PSBs; Alternative Mechanism Panel for PSB Consolidation; Domestic Systemically Important Banks (D-SIBs)
- Latest Indian data: The RBI Financial Stability Report of June 2026 reports that scheduled commercial banks had a CRAR of 17.7 per cent and a CET1 ratio of 15.3 per cent at the end of March 2026, both multi decade highs, well above the 11.5 per cent buffer inclusive minimum
- Basel III final reforms in India: The RBI issued final directions on the standardised approach for credit risk on 27 April 2026, effective 1 April 2027, and final market risk directions on 21 September 2026, also effective 1 April 2027, as reported. These replace the older risk weights, so the RWA of some banks will change. The standardised approach for operational risk was issued earlier, and its effective date should be confirmed on the RBI site
- Expected credit loss link: From 1 April 2027 the RBI moves provisioning to an expected credit loss model. This affects capital because provisions reduce retained earnings, so the two reforms are read together, as reported and as discussed in Non-Performing Assets (NPAs): Classification, Provisioning, Twin Balance Sheet Problem; Willful Defaulters; Rectification, Restructuring, Recovery
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Core formula: CAR = (Tier 1 + Tier 2) / RWA x 100
- Indian numbers: Minimum CAR 9 per cent, CCB 2.5 per cent, total 11.5 per cent, CET1 minimum 5.5 per cent, Tier 1 minimum 7 per cent
- Order of the accords: Basel I 1988 credit risk, Basel II 2004 three pillars, Basel III after the 2008 crisis
- Tier 1 versus Tier 2: Tier 1 is going concern capital, Tier 2 is gone concern capital
- Common errors: Saying Basel norms are laws of the RBI, confusing the Basel minimum of 8 per cent with the Indian 9 per cent, or adding the buffer to Tier 2 only
As an analytical point, India’s capital ratios are at record highs while credit growth has to be funded in a decade of capex, so the debate has moved from survival to efficiency. Capital must now be used well, without weakening the buffers that took years of recapitalisation to build.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Asked before Basel III asked in Prelims 2015
- Numbers 9 per cent and 2.5 per cent are direct MCQs
- Current link April 2027 final reforms
What Came Next?
The next topic covers the banking sector reform committees and laws, from Narasimham to the Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act, 2020. Next topic: Banking Sector Reforms: Narasimham Committees (1991, 1998), Verma Committee, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act 2020; Mission Indradhanush.
Key People and Terms
- CRAR Capital to risk weighted assets ratio
- CET1 Common Equity Tier 1
- AT1 Additional Tier 1
- RWA Risk weighted assets
- CCB Capital conservation buffer
- CCyB Countercyclical capital buffer
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- CAR = (Tier 1 + Tier 2) / RWA.
- India: 9% + 2.5% CCB = 11.5%.
- CET1 min 5.5%; Tier 1 min 7%.
- Basel I 1988, II 2004, III post 2008.
- SCB CRAR 17.7%, March 2026.
Do Not Confuse With
- Tier 1 and Tier 2 capital Going concern versus gone concern capital
- CAR and leverage ratio Risk based versus non risk based
- Capital conservation buffer and countercyclical buffer Fixed 2.5 per cent versus variable 0 to 2.5 per cent
- Basel committee and RBI The standard setter versus the Indian rule maker
Memory Hook
Nine plus two and a half makes eleven and a half; Tier 1 lives on, Tier 2 pays when it dies.
Mains Angle
A Mains question may ask whether higher capital norms help or hurt credit. These points give a frame.
- Stability Capital absorbs losses
- Credit Higher capital can limit lending
- Reforms Basel III final rules 2027
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“What is the Basel III framework? Examine its significance for the Indian banking sector.”
How to Answer
- Define Basel, CAR, tiers.
- Compare Basel I, II, III.
- India 9 plus 2.5, 17.7 per cent.
- Conclude Capital with growth balance.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the capital adequacy ratio?
The capital adequacy ratio is a bank capital as a percentage of its risk weighted assets, equal to (Tier 1 + Tier 2) / RWA x 100. Rs 1,650 crore of capital against Rs 12,000 crore of risk weighted assets gives 13.75 per cent. The RBI minimum is 9 per cent plus a 2.5 per cent buffer.
What is the difference between Tier 1 and Tier 2 capital?
Tier 1 capital is going concern capital that absorbs losses while the bank keeps operating and includes equity, reserves and perpetual instruments. Tier 2 is gone concern capital that pays out only when the bank fails and includes subordinated debt and revaluation reserves. Tier 1 must be at least 7 per cent of RWA in India.
What is the capital conservation buffer in Basel III?
The capital conservation buffer is an extra layer of common equity of 2.5 per cent of risk weighted assets that banks must hold above the minimum so that it can be used in stress. If it is used, dividends and bonuses are restricted. With the 9 per cent minimum, an Indian bank must hold 11.5 per cent.
What are the differences between Basel I, II and III?
Basel I of 1988 set an 8 per cent capital rule for credit risk only. Basel II of 2004 added market and operational risk and three pillars of capital, review and disclosure. Basel III, after the 2008 crisis, raised the quality of capital and added buffers, a leverage ratio and the liquidity ratios LCR and NSFR.
What is the minimum CAR for banks in India?
The RBI minimum CAR is 9 per cent of risk weighted assets, higher than the Basel committee minimum of 8 per cent. With the 2.5 per cent capital conservation buffer, fully in place since 31 March 2019, the effective requirement is 11.5 per cent. The CET1 minimum is 5.5 per cent before the buffer and 8 per cent after.
What is the latest capital adequacy ratio of Indian banks?
Scheduled commercial banks had a CRAR of 17.7 per cent and a CET1 ratio of 15.3 per cent at the end of March 2026, both multi decade highs, according to the RBI Financial Stability Report of June 2026. This is well above the 11.5 per cent requirement that includes the buffer.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 Basel III norms relate to capital adequacy, leverage and liquidity of banks.
They raise capital quality and add the leverage ratio, LCR and NSFR. Asked in UPSC Prelims 2015.
2 Tier 2 capital is called going concern capital.
Tier 1 is going concern capital. Tier 2 is gone concern capital.
3 The RBI minimum capital adequacy ratio for banks is 9 per cent.
This is above the Basel minimum of 8 per cent.
4 The capital conservation buffer in India is 2.5 per cent of risk weighted assets.
Fully phased in by 31 March 2019.
5 Basel II covered credit risk only.
It covered credit, market and operational risk. Basel I covered credit risk only.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index