Banking Sector Reforms: Narasimham Committees (1991, 1998), Verma Committee, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act 2020; Mission Indradhanush
Indian Economy › Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality · Topic 6.11
Banking sector reforms in India are the committee recommendations and laws that moved banks from a controlled, state dominated system to a market based, prudentially regulated one. The two Narasimham Committees (1991 and 1998) cut the cash reserve ratio and statutory liquidity ratio, freed interest rates, set capital adequacy and income recognition norms and urged consolidation. The Verma Committee (1999) dealt with weak public sector banks, the Nachiket Mor Committee (2014) proposed differentiated banks and universal access, and the P.J. Nayak Committee (2014) proposed governance reform. The Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act, 2020 brought cooperative banks under closer RBI control, and Mission Indradhanush (2015) was a seven point plan for public sector banks.
9 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality
At a Glance
- Narasimham I 1991: SLR and CRR cuts, 8 per cent CAR, interest deregulation
- Narasimham II 1998: 9 per cent CAR, narrow banking, 90 day NPA norm
- Verma Committee 1999: weak public sector banks
- Nachiket Mor 2013-14: payments banks, universal access
- P.J. Nayak 2014: governance, Bank Investment Company
- BR (Amendment) Act 2020: cooperative banks under RBI
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Banking Structure, Banking Reforms and Credit Quality
Where Does It Fit?
This topic converts the Basel capital rules of Basel Norms I, II, III: Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR), Tier-1 and Tier-2 Capital; Capital Conservation Buffer into the reform history behind them. It also sets up the entry of differentiated banks, first listed in Differentiated Banks: Payments Banks (Nachiket Mor Committee); Small Finance Banks (Narasimham / Sivaraman Committee); Minimum Capital and Lending Norms, and the governance bodies in Bank Board Bureau / Financial Services Institutions Bureau; Banking Ombudsman; Priority Sector Lending (PSL) and PSL Certificates; Weaker Sections Categories. Previous topic: Basel Norms I, II, III: Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR), Tier-1 and Tier-2 Capital; Capital Conservation Buffer. Next topic: Bank Board Bureau / Financial Services Institutions Bureau; Banking Ombudsman; Priority Sector Lending (PSL) and PSL Certificates; Weaker Sections Categories.
What Did the Narasimham Committees Recommend?
| Theme | Narasimham I (1991) | Narasimham II (1998) |
|---|---|---|
| Mandate | Committee on the Financial System, chaired by M. Narasimham | Committee on Banking Sector Reforms, chaired by M. Narasimham |
| Reserve ratios | Cut the statutory liquidity ratio from 38.5 per cent to 25 per cent in stages and the cash reserve ratio from 15 per cent downwards | Further reduction in the SLR to 25 per cent and CRR to 3 to 5 per cent |
| Capital adequacy | 8 per cent of risk weighted assets by March 1996 | 9 per cent by 2000 and 10 per cent by 2002 |
| Asset quality | Four category classification and provisioning, income recognition norms | Move the NPA test to 90 days from 180 days, by 2004, and cut net NPAs |
| Structure | A tiered system: 3 large international banks, 8 to 10 national banks, local banks and rural banks | Merge strong banks, allow narrow banking for weak ones, review the number of banks |
| Institutions | Debt recovery tribunals and an asset reconstruction fund | Asset reconstruction company, reduce government stake in PSBs to 33 per cent |
| Interest rates | Deregulate deposit and lending rates in phases | Create a competitive banking market and strengthen supervision |
How Do the Other Committees and Laws Compare?
| Reform | Year | Core recommendation or provision |
|---|---|---|
| Verma Committee | 1999 | Looked at three weak public sector banks (Indian Bank, UCO Bank and United Bank of India) and urged restructuring and operational turnaround |
| Nachiket Mor Committee | 2013-14 | Committee on Comprehensive Financial Services for Small Businesses and Low Income Households: payments banks, wholesale banks, universal electronic bank account, Differentiated Banks: Payments Banks (Nachiket Mor Committee); Small Finance Banks (Narasimham / Sivaraman Committee); Minimum Capital and Lending Norms |
| P.J. Nayak Committee | 2014 | Review of the governance of bank boards: a Bank Investment Company, reduce government stake below 50 per cent, a Bank Boards Bureau, better pay and board autonomy |
| Mission Indradhanush | August 2015 | Seven point plan for PSBs: Appointments, Bank Boards Bureau, Capitalisation, De-stressing, Empowerment, Accountability, Governance reforms (A B C D E F G) |
| Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act | 2020 | Cooperative banks (urban and multi-state) come under the RBI for management, audit and capital, with a new power of amalgamation without moratorium |
| Banking Laws (Amendment) Act | 2025 | Nomination of up to four persons in deposits and lockers, longer director tenure in cooperative banks, as reported |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Also called: The first report is called the Narasimham Committee I or the Report of the Committee on the Financial System (CFS), and the second is Narasimham Committee II or the Committee on Banking Sector Reforms (CBSR). The 1991 report was the base for the financial sector reforms that followed the 1991 crisis, as in Liberalisation in 1991: Industrial Sector Reforms, Financial Sector Reforms (Pre-1991 Financial Sector Regulation), Tax Reforms (Reduction in Income and Corporate Taxes; Indirect Tax Reforms; GST), Foreign Exchange Reforms, Trade and Investment Policy Reforms (Dismantling Pre-Reform Policies)
- Worked SLR example: On deposits of Rs 1,000 crore, an SLR of 38.5 per cent forces Rs 385 crore into government securities. At 25 per cent the figure is Rs 250 crore. The reform therefore freed 385 – 250 = Rs 135 crore of every Rs 1,000 crore of deposits for lending to firms and households. The ratios themselves are in Cash Reserve Ratio and Reserve Ratio; Statutory Liquidity Ratio; Repo, Reverse Repo, Call Rate, Bank Rate, Marginal Standing Facility (MSF), Marginal Requirements
- What narrow banking meant: Narasimham II suggested that weak banks be allowed to put deposits only in safe, short term, risk free assets such as treasury bills, with little or no lending, until they recovered. The idea was not adopted, and weak banks were later handled by recapitalisation, Prompt Corrective Action and mergers, as in Nationalisation of Banks; State Bank of India; Merger of Associate Banks with SBI; PSB Consolidation
- Verma Committee: The Verma Committee of 1999 was a working group on weak public sector banks that identified structural weaknesses in three banks and set the template of restructuring with performance targets. It is sometimes confused with the Narasimham reports, which dealt with the whole system
- Nachiket Mor Committee: Nachiket Mor chaired the committee that gave the idea of payments banks and wholesale banks and the principle of universal access to a bank account. The RBI issued payments bank licences in 2015 and these are in Differentiated Banks: Payments Banks (Nachiket Mor Committee); Small Finance Banks (Narasimham / Sivaraman Committee); Minimum Capital and Lending Norms
- P.J. Nayak Committee: P.J. Nayak led a committee in 2014 that found PSB boards weak. Its main proposals were to set up a Bank Investment Company to hold government shares, to bring the government stake below 50 per cent, and a Bank Boards Bureau to select heads. The bureau idea was acted on in 2016 and is covered in Bank Board Bureau / Financial Services Institutions Bureau; Banking Ombudsman; Priority Sector Lending (PSL) and PSL Certificates; Weaker Sections Categories
- Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act, 2020: Promulgated as an ordinance in June 2020 and later enacted, it applies the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 more closely to urban cooperative banks and multi-state cooperative banks, giving the RBI powers over capital, audit, management and reconstruction. It does not apply to primary agricultural credit societies or societies for long term agricultural finance. Cooperative banks are discussed in Cooperative Banks: Short-Term (State, Central/District, Primary) and Long-Term (Land Development Banks); Urban Cooperative Banks
- Mission Indradhanush: Launched in August 2015, it called for recapitalisation of Rs 70,000 crore from the Budget over four years (2015-16 to 2018-19) and a further amount to be raised from the market to meet Basel III norms, as reported. The seven pillars spell the rainbow of the name. The recapitalisation story continues in Recapitalisation of PSBs; Alternative Mechanism Panel for PSB Consolidation; Domestic Systemically Important Banks (D-SIBs)
- Consolidation outcome: The 2019 announcement of merging 10 public sector banks into 4, effective April 2020, followed the long standing push of the Narasimham reports to have fewer, stronger banks. PSBs fell from 27 in 2017 to 12 after the mergers, as reported
- Reform scorecard: Capital adequacy and income recognition norms of 1991 are now standard, but ideas on narrow banking and the Bank Investment Company were not implemented. The record low gross NPA ratio of 1.8 per cent of scheduled commercial banks in March 2026 shows that the clean-up of asset quality, helped by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code covered in Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) 2016: Insolvency Resolution, Information Utilities, IBBI, Liquidation, Bail-in vs Bail-out; Overleveraged Companies, worked
- Legal framework today: Banks function under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 and the RBI Act, 1934. The Banking Laws (Amendment) Act, 2025 received assent on 15 April 2025, and nomination changes came into force on 1 November 2025, as reported
- Open reform issues: Government ownership of PSBs remains above 50 per cent, a question first raised in the Nayak report, and the effect of the expected credit loss regime from April 2027 on lending is still to be seen
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Match type: Committee with its main idea: Narasimham with SLR and CRR cuts and 8 per cent CAR, Nachiket Mor with payments banks, Nayak with governance
- Number questions: 38.5 to 25 per cent SLR, CAR 8 per cent then 9 per cent, NPA 180 to 90 days
- Mission Indradhanush: Seven pillars, launched in 2015, with recapitalisation of Rs 70,000 crore
- BR Amendment Act: Brings cooperative banks under RBI regulation, 2020
- Common errors: Saying Narasimham II proposed payments banks, or placing the Nayak Committee before 2014
As an analytical point, the reform story of Indian banking has been strong on rules and weaker on ownership. Capital norms, asset classification and supervision matured since 1991, but a government majority in most large banks keeps governance reform unfinished.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Match tables Committees and ideas are standard MCQs
- Numbers SLR, CRR, CAR, NPA days
- Current link Cooperative bank rules, 2025 laws
What Came Next?
The next topic covers the Bank Board Bureau, the banking ombudsman and priority sector lending. Next topic: Bank Board Bureau / Financial Services Institutions Bureau; Banking Ombudsman; Priority Sector Lending (PSL) and PSL Certificates; Weaker Sections Categories.
Key People and Terms
- CFS Committee on the Financial System
- CBSR Committee on Banking Sector Reforms
- Narrow banking Deposits only in safe assets
- BIC Bank Investment Company
- A B C D E F G Seven pillars of Indradhanush
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Narasimham I: 1991; II: 1998.
- SLR 38.5% to 25%.
- Nachiket Mor: payments banks.
- P.J. Nayak: governance, BIC.
- BR Amendment Act: 2020, cooperative banks.
Do Not Confuse With
- Narasimham I and II 1991 system level versus 1998 banking sector level
- Verma Committee and Nayak Committee Weak banks versus board governance
- Nachiket Mor and Narasimham Differentiated banks versus reserve ratio cuts
- Mission Indradhanush and Indradhanush for health Bank reform plan versus vaccination mission
Memory Hook
Narasimham cut the ratios, Verma fixed the weak, Mor made new banks, Nayak fixed the boards.
Mains Angle
A Mains question may ask for an evaluation of the reform journey. These points give a frame and link to the Mains page of this macro.
- 1991-98 Liberalise and strengthen
- 2014-15 Inclusion and governance
- 2020 onward Cooperative and legal reform
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Examine the recommendations of the Narasimham Committees and assess their contribution to banking sector reforms in India.”
How to Answer
- Intro Reform need after 1991.
- Body 1 Narasimham I and II.
- Body 2 Mor, Nayak, Indradhanush.
- Conclusion Governance still pending.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What were the main recommendations of the Narasimham Committee?
The 1991 committee recommended cutting the SLR from 38.5 to 25 per cent and the CRR, deregulating interest rates, an 8 per cent capital adequacy norm, income recognition rules and debt recovery tribunals. The 1998 committee proposed 9 per cent CAR, a 90 day NPA norm, narrow banking for weak banks and an asset reconstruction company.
What is the difference between Narasimham Committee I and II?
Narasimham I of 1991 reformed the whole financial system, with SLR and CRR cuts, an 8 per cent capital norm and interest deregulation. Narasimham II of 1998 focused on banking sector strengthening with a 9 per cent capital target, the 90 day NPA rule, mergers and narrow banking.
What did the Nachiket Mor Committee recommend?
The Nachiket Mor Committee of 2013-14 on financial services for small businesses and low income households recommended payments banks, wholesale banks and a universal electronic bank account with universal access to deposits. The RBI acted on it by issuing payments bank and small finance bank licences from 2015.
What is the P.J. Nayak Committee on bank governance?
The P.J. Nayak Committee of 2014 reviewed the governance of bank boards and found PSB boards weak. It proposed a Bank Investment Company to hold government shares, reduction of the government stake below 50 per cent and a Bank Boards Bureau to select heads, which started in 2016.
What is Mission Indradhanush for banks?
Mission Indradhanush of August 2015 is a seven point plan for public sector banks, with the pillars Appointments, Bank Boards Bureau, Capitalisation, De-stressing, Empowerment, Accountability and Governance reforms. It planned Rs 70,000 crore of government capital over four years, as reported.
What did the Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act, 2020 change?
The Act brought urban and multi-state cooperative banks under RBI control on management, audit and capital, and gave the RBI power to prepare reconstruction or amalgamation schemes. It excludes primary agricultural credit societies and societies for long term agricultural finance. It followed the Punjab and Maharashtra Cooperative Bank failure of 2019.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The Narasimham Committee of 1991 recommended a reduction in the SLR.
SLR was cut from 38.5 per cent to 25 per cent in stages.
2 The Nachiket Mor Committee recommended payments banks.
It also proposed universal access to a bank account.
3 The P.J. Nayak Committee dealt with the governance of bank boards.
It proposed a Bank Investment Company.
4 Mission Indradhanush has five pillars.
It has seven pillars, A B C D E F G.
5 The Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act, 2020 excluded cooperative banks from RBI control.
It brought them under closer RBI regulation.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index