An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 5.5

Problems on Relationships Introduced Through a Photograph or Pointing Statement

Reasoning › Blood Relations · Topic 5.5

In photograph and pointing-statement problems, a speaker points at a person, or at a person in a photograph, and describes that person through the speaker's own relatives, for example "his mother is the wife of my father's only son". Treat the speaker as the starting point, reduce the description to a chain from the speaker, and give the relation of the pointed person to the speaker. The pointing words this, that and the man in the photograph only name the target.

Share:
Problems on Relationships Introduced Through a Photograph or Pointing Statement - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

In photograph and pointing-statement problems, a speaker points at a person, or at a person in a photograph, and describes that person through the speaker’s own relatives, for example “his mother is the wife of my father’s only son”. Treat the speaker as the starting point, reduce the description to a chain from the speaker, and give the relation of the pointed person to the speaker. The pointing words this, that and the man in the photograph only name the target.

At a Glance

  • Starting point The speaker, not the pointed person
  • Pointing words This, that, he, she, the person in the photograph
  • Task Relation of the pointed person to the speaker
  • Key habit Resolve my and only phrases first
  • Common traps Wrong speaker gender, wrong direction
  • Time 30 to 45 seconds

Where Does It Fit?

This is the fifth topic of the Blood Relations macro. It uses the single-sentence reducing skill of Blood Relations Based on a Single Statement with Multiple Relations and the family terms of Direct Blood Relation Problems (Family Tree Based on Direct Statements). For large families built from several statements see Blood Relation Puzzles Requiring a Three-Generation Family Tree.

How Do Pointing and Photograph Statements Work?

In short: the statement describes the pointed person through the speaker’s relatives, and the answer is that person’s relation to the speaker.

Speaker says Reduction Answer
She is the daughter of my father’s only son (Ravi) Father’s only son is Ravi’s father’s son, so Ravi himself if male Ravi’s daughter
His mother is the wife of my father’s only son (Arun, a man) Father’s only son is Arun, and Arun’s wife is the man’s mother Arun’s son
Her husband is the only son of my mother (Mohan, a man) Mother’s only son is Mohan Mohan’s wife
He is the son of the only daughter of my father (Priya, a woman) Father’s only daughter is Priya Priya’s son

The words this, that, he and she only identify the target. Never treat them as extra people. A photograph adds no new information; it is just another way of pointing.

What Is the Step-by-Step Method?

In short: note the speaker and the gender, shorten the description step by step, then read the last link.

Steps

  • Write the speaker and mark male or female.
  • Resolve every only phrase that points back to the speaker.
  • Write the chain from the speaker to the pointed person.
  • State the pointed person’s relation to the speaker, using gender if shown.
  • Same person twice: if the statement names the pointed person’s relative and that relative reduces to the speaker, the pointed person is a child or spouse of the speaker.
  • Reversed chains: in “His son is my son’s father”, the man’s son is the speaker’s husband, so the man is the speaker’s father-in-law.
  • Direction: the answer is the relation of the pointed person to the speaker, which is the reverse of the relation of the speaker to the pointed person.

For the term list used in these chains, see Direct Blood Relation Problems (Family Tree Based on Direct Statements).

Which Mistakes Are Most Common in Pointing Questions?

In short: most errors come from reading the speaker’s gender wrongly, answering from the wrong side, and treating the word only as a new person.

  • Wrong side: if the pointed man is the speaker’s son, the answer to “how is the speaker related to him” is father or mother, not son.
  • Gender loss: a woman’s father’s only son is her only brother, but a man’s father’s only son is himself.
  • Extra people: the phrase “my wife’s only son” is the speaker’s son, not a new member.
  • Photograph: a statement like “the man in the photograph” does not make him a relative by itself. The relation comes only from the description.

Read the question ending first, to see whose relation is asked, and then read the statement.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Pointing to a photograph, Ravi says, “She is the daughter of my father’s father’s only son.” How is she related to Ravi?

  1. Ravi’s father’s father is Ravi’s paternal grandfather.
  2. The only son of the grandfather is Ravi’s father.
  3. She is the daughter of Ravi’s father, so Ravi’s sister.

Answer: She is Ravi’s sister.

Example 2

Question: Pointing to a man, Arun, a man himself, says, “His mother is the wife of my father’s only son.” How is the man related to Arun?

  1. Arun is a man, so his father’s only son is Arun himself.
  2. The wife of Arun is the mother of the man.

Answer: The man is Arun’s son.

Example 3

Question: Pointing to a lady, Mohan, a man, says, “Her husband is the only son of my mother.” How is the lady related to Mohan?

  1. Mohan is a man, so his mother’s only son is Mohan.
  2. The lady’s husband is Mohan.

Answer: The lady is Mohan’s wife.

Example 4

Question: Pointing to a boy, Priya, a woman, says, “He is the son of the only daughter of my father.” How is the boy related to Priya?

  1. Priya is a woman, so the only daughter of her father is Priya.
  2. The boy is Priya’s son.

Answer: The boy is Priya’s son.

Example 5

Question: Pointing to a man in a photograph, a woman says, “His son is my son’s father.” How is the man related to the woman?

  1. The woman’s son’s father is her husband.
  2. So the man’s son is the woman’s husband.
  3. The man is the father of her husband.

Answer: The man is the woman’s father-in-law.

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Underline the speaker’s gender before reading anything else.
  • Replace every my phrase by a person, one at a time.
  • Check which direction is asked at the end of the question.
  • Treat pointing words as labels, not as extra people.
  • Test your answer by saying the relation back in a sentence.

Common Mistakes

  • Answering from the pointed person’s side.
  • Forgetting that the speaker may be the only son or only daughter mentioned.
  • Counting the person in the photograph as an extra relative.
  • Mixing up husband and wife when a woman is the speaker.
  • Ignoring the final question word.

Practice Questions

  1. Pointing to a man, a woman says, “His mother is the only daughter of my mother.” How is the man related to her?
  2. Pointing to a girl, Raj, a man, says, “She is the daughter of my father’s only son.” How is the girl related to Raj?
  3. Pointing to a woman, a man says, “She is the mother of my wife’s only son.” How is she related to him?
  4. Pointing to a boy, Neeta says, “He is my mother’s only brother’s only son.” How is the boy related to Neeta?
  5. Pointing to a man, Rekha, a woman, says, “He is the husband of my mother’s only daughter.” How is he related to Rekha?
  6. Pointing to a man in a photograph, a woman says, “His son is my son’s father.” How is he related to her?

Answers: 1) her son; 2) his daughter; 3) his wife; 4) maternal cousin (cousin brother); 5) her husband; 6) father-in-law.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Exam favourite Pointing statements appear in nearly every aptitude paper.
  • Skill They train you to start from the speaker.
  • Link They use the reducing skill from Blood Relations Based on a Single Statement with Multiple Relations.
  • Speed The solution is a two-line chain once the speaker is fixed.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Blood Relation Puzzles Requiring a Three-Generation Family Tree. It extends the tree to three generations with many statements.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Speaker The person who makes the statement
  • Pointed person The person being described
  • Reduction Shortening a phrase to one person
  • Direction Whose relation to whom is asked
  • Only A unique person in a role
  • Photograph Another way of pointing

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Start from the speaker.
  • Check the speaker’s gender.
  • Pointing words are labels.
  • Answer from the speaker’s side as the question asks.
  • Resolve only phrases first.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Speaker vs pointed person The speaker describes; the pointed person is described.
  • Son vs father The direction of the question decides which word is used.
  • Wife vs mother The wife of the speaker can be the mother of the pointed person.
  • Photograph vs relative A photograph is not a relation.

Memory Hook

Speaker first, reduce the phrase, answer from the speaker’s side.

GS Relevance

Frequent in SSC CGL, CHSL, banking, CDS and CSAT reasoning: a person is pointed out, or shown in a photograph, and described through the speaker's relatives.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you solve photograph blood relation questions?

Treat the photograph as just another way of pointing. Start from the speaker, reduce the description to a chain of relations from the speaker, and name the relation of the person in the photograph to the speaker. Check the speaker's gender because it can decide who an only son or daughter is.

How do you solve a pointing statement in blood relations?

Fix the speaker and the speaker's gender, then replace each my phrase with a person step by step. The last person in the chain is the one pointed at. State their relation to the speaker, taking care to give the answer from the side that the question asks.

What does this or that mean in a pointing statement?

The words this, that, he, she and the person in the photograph are only labels for the target. They do not add a new person to the family. The relation of the target to the speaker is found only from the description in the statement.

Why does the speaker's gender matter in pointing questions?

A woman's mother's only daughter is the woman herself, but a man's mother's only daughter is his sister. The same words give different answers depending on gender, so note the speaker's gender first and use it in every only phrase of the statement.

How can you avoid answering from the wrong side?

Read the last line of the question before the statement, and note whose relation to whom is asked. If the pointed man is the speaker's son, then the speaker is his father or mother, but the pointed person is the speaker's son. Say the answer back in a full sentence.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 In a pointing question, the answer is the relation of the pointed person to the speaker.
True

The speaker is the reference person unless the question states otherwise.

2 A man's father's only son is always his brother.
False

It is the man himself, since he is a son of his father and there is no other.

3 The words this and that add a new person to the family.
False

They only label the person pointed at.

4 If a woman's son's father is the son of a man, that man is her father-in-law.
True

Her son's father is her husband, so the man is her husband's father.

Share: