An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 5.8

Blood Relations Involving Ambiguous Gender Requiring Additional Deduction from Clues

Reasoning › Blood Relations · Topic 5.8

In blood relation problems with ambiguous gender, words such as sibling, child, parent, spouse and cousin do not say whether a person is male or female. Deduce the gender from clues elsewhere (father, mother, wife, husband, brother, sister), use the convention that a husband and wife are of opposite sex, and give a neutral answer or state that the relation cannot be determined when no clue fixes the gender.

Share:
Blood Relations Involving Ambiguous Gender Requiring Additional Deduction from Clues - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

In blood relation problems with ambiguous gender, words such as sibling, child, parent, spouse and cousin do not say whether a person is male or female. Deduce the gender from clues elsewhere (father, mother, wife, husband, brother, sister), use the convention that a husband and wife are of opposite sex, and give a neutral answer or state that the relation cannot be determined when no clue fixes the gender.

At a Glance

  • Neutral terms Sibling, child, parent, spouse, cousin
  • Gender clues Father, mother, wife, husband, brother, sister
  • Spouse rule Husband and wife are of opposite sex
  • If no clue Neutral answer or cannot be determined
  • Check Does any later statement fix the gender?
  • Trap Guessing gender from a name

Where Does It Fit?

This is the last topic of the Blood Relations macro. It refines the gender marking of Direct Blood Relation Problems (Family Tree Based on Direct Statements) and Blood Relations Requiring Drawing a Family Tree Diagram and stops you from giving gendered answers without proof. The next macro starts with Basic Direction Sense Problems (North, South, East, West Movement).

Which Words Hide the Gender?

In short: a word hides the gender when it can describe either a man or a woman.

Hides gender Shows gender
Sibling Brother, sister
Child Son, daughter
Parent Father, mother
Spouse Husband, wife
Cousin Uncle, aunt, nephew, niece
Grandchild Grandson, granddaughter

A name never gives gender in a reasoning question, so ignore names. Only the relation words count.

Gender rules

  • The first person in “X is the father of Y” is male, and the second person is unknown.
  • Husband and wife are of opposite sex.
  • A person called a father, brother, husband or son is male; mother, sister, wife or daughter is female.
  • A person called by a neutral term stays unknown until another statement fixes it.

How Do You Deduce Gender From the Clues?

In short: collect every statement about the same person, because a gender fixed in one statement applies in all.

  • Same person, two statements: if A is a sibling of B in one statement and A is the father of C in another, A is male, so A is B’s brother.
  • Spouse rule: if M is the spouse of N and N is the mother of K, then M is the husband of N, so M is the father of K.
  • Chain clue: if D is the husband of E, then D is male and E is female, even if no other statement says so.
  • Parent clue: a person described as mother of someone is female.

When a person is described only by neutral terms, the answer should also be neutral. For example, a father’s sibling is an uncle or aunt, and the answer is stated as such.

When Is the Answer Cannot Be Determined?

In short: when the final person’s gender decides the word in the answer and no clue fixes it, the answer is cannot be determined, or a neutral word.

  • Brother or sister: if C is a sibling of A, then C is A’s brother or sister, and the gender cannot be fixed.
  • Uncle or aunt: a sibling of a parent is an uncle or aunt, and without a clue the best answer is the neutral phrase “uncle or aunt”.
  • Options: if the options include both a male and a female term for the relation, and the data supports neither, choose cannot be determined.
  • Exam convention: use only the clues in the question. Do not use outside assumptions such as typical names.

The same idea of insufficient data appears in Fictitious/Made-Up Language Coding Problems for made-up languages and in Data Sufficiency Based on Blood Relations.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: A is the brother of B. B is the sister of C. How is C related to A?

  1. A is male, being a brother.
  2. B is the sister of C, and B is female, but C’s gender is not given.
  3. C is a sibling of B, and so a sibling of A.

Answer: C is A’s sibling (brother or sister); the gender cannot be determined.

Example 2

Question: M is the spouse of N, and N is the mother of K. How is M related to K?

  1. N is a mother, so N is female.
  2. A spouse of a woman is her husband.
  3. The husband of K’s mother is K’s father.

Answer: M is the father of K.

Example 3

Question: A is a sibling of B. B is the mother of C. C is the brother of D. D is the wife of E. How is A related to E?

  1. B is a mother, so B is female. C and D are children of B.
  2. D is a wife, so D is female, and E is her husband.
  3. A is a sibling of B, who is D’s mother, and so A is D’s uncle or aunt. A’s gender is not given.

Answer: A is the uncle or aunt of E’s wife; the gender of A cannot be determined.

Example 4

Question: A and B are siblings. A is the father of C. B is the mother of D. How is B related to A?

  1. A is a father, so A is male.
  2. B is a mother, so B is female.
  3. B is a sister of A.

Answer: B is A’s sister.

Example 5

Question: D is the husband of E. E is the sister of F. F is the mother of G. How is D related to G?

  1. D is a husband, so D is male, and E is female.
  2. E is the sister of G’s mother F, so E is G’s maternal aunt.
  3. D is the husband of the maternal aunt.

Answer: D is G’s maternal uncle (husband of the maternal aunt).

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Make a list of each person with M, F or the question mark.
  • Use words like father, wife and sister as hard clues.
  • Apply the spouse rule of opposite sex.
  • Prefer neutral answers when no gender is given.
  • Never guess gender from a name.

Common Mistakes

  • Treating sibling as brother.
  • Giving a gendered answer when the question allows a neutral one.
  • Ignoring the spouse rule.
  • Missing a clue given for the same person in a later statement.
  • Using outside assumptions about names.

Practice Questions

  1. A is the sibling of B, and B is the father of C. How is A related to C?
  2. P is the spouse of Q, and Q is the father of R. How is P related to R?
  3. M is the male child of N. N is the sister of O. O is the father of P. How is M related to P?
  4. A is a sibling of B. B is the wife of C. C is the father of D. How is A related to D?
  5. X and Y are spouses, and Y is the grandfather of Z. How is X related to Z?
  6. S is the brother of T. T is the child of U. U is the husband of V. How is V related to S?

Answers: 1) paternal uncle or aunt (gender not given); 2) mother; 3) paternal cousin (cousin brother); 4) maternal uncle or aunt (gender not given); 5) grandmother; 6) mother.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Accuracy It saves you from wrong gendered answers.
  • Exam use Questions with sibling or child as a link are common.
  • Link It reinforces Blood Relations Requiring Drawing a Family Tree Diagram and Blood Relation Puzzles Requiring a Three-Generation Family Tree.
  • Logic It trains you to separate what is given from what is assumed.

What Comes Next?

The next macro is Direction and Distance. Its first topic, Basic Direction Sense Problems (North, South, East, West Movement), teaches movement in the four main directions.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Neutral term A relation word with no gender
  • Spouse rule Husband and wife are of opposite sex
  • Deduction Finding a fact from other statements
  • Clue word A word that shows gender
  • Sibling A brother or sister
  • Cannot be determined The data does not fix the answer

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Names never show gender.
  • Sibling, child, parent, spouse and cousin are neutral.
  • Husband and wife are of opposite sex.
  • Collect every clue about a person.
  • Give a neutral answer if no gender is fixed.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Sibling vs brother A sibling may be a brother or sister; a brother is male.
  • Spouse vs husband Spouse is neutral; husband is male.
  • Parent vs father Parent is neutral; father is male.
  • Cousin vs cousin brother Cousin is neutral; cousin brother is male.

Memory Hook

Names say nothing; relation words and the spouse rule decide.

GS Relevance

Appears in CSAT, SSC CGL, banking and CAPF reasoning when words like sibling or child hide the gender and the answer has to be deduced from other statements.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you solve blood relation questions when gender is not given?

Collect every statement about each person and look for clue words such as father, mother, husband, wife, brother and sister. Apply the rule that husband and wife are of opposite sex. If no clue fixes the gender, give a neutral answer or state that it cannot be determined.

Which relation words do not show gender?

Sibling, child, parent, spouse, cousin and grandchild do not show whether a person is male or female. Words such as father, mother, brother, sister, husband, wife, son and daughter do show it. Names are never used to decide gender in reasoning questions.

What is the spouse rule in blood relations?

The spouse rule says that husband and wife are of opposite sex. So if a person is the spouse of a mother, the person is her husband and the father of her children. The rule lets you fix a gender from a neutral word like spouse.

When is the answer cannot be determined in blood relation questions?

It is the right answer when the gender of the final person decides the relation word and no statement fixes it, and the options give both a male and a female term. For example, a father's sibling may be an uncle or an aunt.

Can names be used to guess gender in reasoning questions?

No. Names are never used as clues, since a name does not prove gender. Only relation words in the statements, such as father, wife or sister, and general rules such as the spouse rule, can be used. Guessing from names causes avoidable errors.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The word sibling shows that a person is male.
False

A sibling may be a brother or a sister.

2 A spouse of a mother is the father of her children, by the standard convention.
True

Husband and wife are of opposite sex, so the spouse is the husband.

3 Names can be used to decide gender in blood relation questions.
False

Only relation words and general rules are used.

4 A father's sibling is always an uncle.
False

A father's sibling may be an uncle or an aunt unless the gender is given.

Share: