Inequality Problems Involving ‘Either-Or’ Conclusions
Reasoning › Inequality (Direct and Coded) · Topic 20.3
An either-or conclusion in inequality arises when two conclusions relate the same pair of letters, neither follows alone, and together they cover every possible relation. The rule is to check each conclusion separately first, and only if both fail to follow and they form a complementary pair such as greater than with at most, or less than with at least, answer either I or II follows.
7 min read · Reasoning · Inequality (Direct and Coded)
Quick Answer
An either-or conclusion in inequality arises when two conclusions relate the same pair of letters, neither follows alone, and together they cover every possible relation. The rule is to check each conclusion separately first, and only if both fail to follow and they form a complementary pair such as greater than with at most, or less than with at least, answer either I or II follows.
At a Glance
- Question type Two conclusions on the same pair of letters
- Condition 1 Same two letters in both conclusions
- Condition 2 Neither conclusion follows alone
- Condition 3 Together they cover all cases
- Complementary pairs > with ≤, and < with ≥
- Answer Either I or II follows
Where Does It Fit?
Either-or is the logical extension of the rules in Direct Inequality Problems (Combining Given Relations to Draw a Conclusion) and Coded Inequality Problems (Symbols Representing Mathematical Relations). It is used in sets with several conclusions, as practised in Inequality Problems Combined with Syllogism-Style Multiple Conclusions, and when direct and coded statements are mixed, as in Inequality Problems Requiring Combination of Direct and Coded Relations. It is the inequality version of an either-or pair in syllogisms.
When Does Either I or II Follow?
In short: answer either-or when the two conclusions are about the same pair of letters, neither is individually certain, and one of them must be true because together they leave no gap.
| Conclusion I | Conclusion II | Either-or? |
|---|---|---|
| A > C | A ≤ C | Yes, together they cover everything |
| A < C | A ≥ C | Yes |
| A > C | A < C | No, the equal case is left out |
| A ≥ C | A ≤ C | Always exhaustive; see the convention below |
A pair is complementary when one is exactly the denial of the other. “A greater than C” is denied by “A less than or equal to C”, and “A less than C” is denied by “A greater than or equal to C”.
What Are the Three Conditions?
In short: check the three conditions in order. If any fails, the answer is not either-or.
- Same pair of letters. Both conclusions must compare the same two letters.
- Neither follows alone. If one follows by itself, the answer is simply that conclusion. If the chain gives the exact relation, then no either-or is needed.
- The pair is complementary. It must be greater than with at most, or less than with at least.
Convention used on this page
- The pairs (>, ≤) and (<, ≥) are always either-or when neither follows alone.
- The pair (>, <) is never either-or because equality is left out.
- A pair of non-strict relations (≥, ≤) is logically always exhaustive, yet publishers differ in treating it as either-or, so exam sets keep to the first two pairs.
- If the two letters are equal, then both ≥ and ≤ follow, which is a both-follow case and not either-or.
Where the chain does give a definite relation, apply the rules of Direct Inequality Problems (Combining Given Relations to Draw a Conclusion) first.
How Is Either-Or Different From Both and Neither?
In short: both follow when the letters are proved equal, neither follows when the pair is not complementary, and either-or follows when the pair is complementary and unproved.
- Both follow: A = B gives A ≥ B and A ≤ B together.
- Neither follows: A > B C and A < C. The equal case is missing, so neither is certain and the answer is not either-or.
- Either-or: A ≥ B ≤ C with conclusions A > C and A ≤ C.
Several conclusions can be tested in one set, and this is the theme of Inequality Problems Combined with Syllogism-Style Multiple Conclusions.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Statements: A ≥ B, B ≤ C. Conclusions: I. A > C II. A ≤ C.
- Chain: A ≥ B ≤ C. The arrows point in opposite directions, so A and C have no definite relation.
- Neither I nor II follows alone.
- The pair A > C and A ≤ C is complementary.
Answer: Either I or II follows
Example 2
Question: Statements: P < Q, R < Q. Conclusions: I. P ≥ R II. P < R.
- Chain: P
R. P and R have no definite relation.
- Neither follows alone.
- The pair P ≥ R and P < R is complementary.
Answer: Either I or II follows
Example 3
Question: Statements: X > Y, Y ≤ Z. Conclusions: I. X > Z II. X < Z.
- X > Y ≤ Z has opposite arrows, so no relation between X and Z follows.
- The pair X > Z and X < Z is not complementary, because X = Z is possible.
Answer: Neither follows
Example 4
Question: Statement: P = Q. Conclusions: I. P ≥ Q II. P ≤ Q.
- P = Q proves both relations directly.
- Each conclusion follows alone, so no either-or is needed.
Answer: Both follow
Example 5
Question: Using $ for >, @ for ≥ and * for ≤. Statements: R @ S, T @ S. Conclusions: I. R $ T II. R * T.
- Decode: R ≥ S ≤ T. R and T have no relation.
- Neither follows alone, and the pair R > T and R ≤ T is complementary.
Answer: Either I or II follows
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Check the letters first: either-or needs the same pair.
- Test each conclusion alone before thinking of either-or.
- Learn the two complementary pairs: (>, ≤) and (<, ≥).
- If the relation between the letters is fully proved, the answer is never either-or.
- Opposite arrows in the chain are the usual starting point of an either-or case.
Common Mistakes
- Calling a pair with > and < either-or.
- Giving either-or when one conclusion follows alone.
- Using either-or for conclusions on different pairs of letters.
- Giving neither when the pair is complementary.
- Giving either-or when both are proved.
Practice Questions
- X ≥ Y, Z ≥ Y. I. X > Z II. X ≤ Z. What follows?
- P < Q, R < Q. I. P ≥ R II. P < R. What follows?
- A > B, C > B. I. A > C II. A < C. What follows?
- M = N. I. M ≥ N II. M ≤ N. What follows?
- K ≤ L, L ≥ M. I. K < M II. K ≥ M. What follows?
- A ≥ B, B ≥ C. I. A C. What follows?
Answers: 1) Either I or II; 2) Either I or II; 3) Neither; 4) Both; 5) Either I or II; 6) Neither.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Exam use A standard answer option in bank exam inequality sets.
- Logic Teaches the notion of complementary statements.
- Scoring Knowing the rule avoids losing marks in easy sets.
- Link to other topics Used in Inequality Problems Combined with Syllogism-Style Multiple Conclusions and Inequality Problems Requiring Combination of Direct and Coded Relations.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Inequality Problems Combined with Syllogism-Style Multiple Conclusions. It combines inequalities with several conclusions, much as syllogism sets do.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Either-or One of two conclusions must be true, but neither is certain alone
- Complementary pair Two statements that deny each other
- Both follow Each conclusion is individually proved
- Neither follows Neither conclusion is proved and they are not complementary
- Denial The opposite of a relation
- Exhaustive Covering every possible case
Related Topics
- Coded Inequality Problems (Symbols Representing Mathematical Relations)
- Inequality Problems Combined with Syllogism-Style Multiple Conclusions
- Direct Inequality Problems (Combining Given Relations to Draw a Conclusion)
- Inequality Problems Requiring Combination of Direct and Coded Relations
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Either-or needs the same pair of letters.
- Neither conclusion may follow alone.
- The pair must be (>, ≤) or (<, ≥).
- The pair (>, <) is not either-or.
- Proved equality gives both follow.
Do Not Confuse With
- Either-or vs neither Either-or needs a complementary pair; neither does not.
- Either-or vs both Both means each is proved; either-or means only one must be true.
- > and ≤ vs > and < The first pair covers all cases; the second misses equality.
- Same pair vs different pair Different pairs never give either-or.
Memory Hook
Same pair, neither proved, complementary: either I or II.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
When does either I or II follow in inequality questions?
Either I or II follows when both conclusions compare the same two letters, neither follows by itself from the statements, and the two conclusions are complementary, such as greater than with less than or equal to, or less than with greater than or equal to.
What are the complementary pairs for either-or?
The standard complementary pairs are greater than with less than or equal to, and less than with greater than or equal to. Each pair covers all possible cases, so one of the two must be true even though the statements do not tell which one.
Why is the pair greater than and less than not either-or?
The pair greater than and less than leaves out the case where the two letters are equal. Since equality may be possible, both conclusions can be false, so neither is guaranteed. Such a pair therefore gives the answer neither follows, not either-or.
How is either-or different from both follow?
Both follow when each conclusion is individually proved, for example when two letters are equal, which gives at least and at most together. Either-or applies when neither is proved alone, yet one of the two must be true because they cover all possibilities.
Can either-or apply to conclusions on different letters?
No. Either-or needs both conclusions to relate exactly the same pair of letters. If the conclusions involve different pairs, they are independent and must each be tested on their own. A conclusion that is not proved simply does not follow.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The conclusions A > C and A ≤ C can form an either-or pair.
They are complementary, so one of them must be true.
2 The conclusions A > C and A < C always form an either-or pair.
The equal case is missing.
3 Either-or applies when one of the conclusions follows alone.
If one follows alone, that conclusion is the answer.
4 If P = Q, then both P ≥ Q and P ≤ Q follow.
Equality gives both relations.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index