An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 20.4

Inequality Problems Combined with Syllogism-Style Multiple Conclusions

Reasoning › Inequality (Direct and Coded) · Topic 20.4

Inequality problems with syllogism-style multiple conclusions give several statements and three or four conclusions, and ask which of them follow, in a format such as only I and II, all of them, or either III or IV. The rule is to build the full chain once, test every conclusion against it one by one, and then spot any complementary pair for an either-or answer.

Share:
Inequality Problems Combined with Syllogism-Style Multiple Conclusions - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Inequality problems with syllogism-style multiple conclusions give several statements and three or four conclusions, and ask which of them follow, in a format such as only I and II, all of them, or either III or IV. The rule is to build the full chain once, test every conclusion against it one by one, and then spot any complementary pair for an either-or answer.

At a Glance

  • Question type Several statements, three or four conclusions
  • Answer forms Only I, I and II, all, none, either-or combinations
  • Step 1 Build the full chain
  • Step 2 Test each conclusion separately
  • Step 3 Look for complementary pairs
  • Time per set About 90 seconds

Where Does It Fit?

This topic applies the rules of Direct Inequality Problems (Combining Given Relations to Draw a Conclusion), Coded Inequality Problems (Symbols Representing Mathematical Relations) and Inequality Problems Involving ‘Either-Or’ Conclusions together in one set. The multiple-conclusion format is borrowed from syllogism questions. The next topic, Inequality Problems Requiring Combination of Direct and Coded Relations, mixes coded and direct statements in the same set.

What Does a Multiple-Conclusion Set Look Like?

In short: you get three or four statements that link five or six letters, followed by three or four conclusions. You must say which of them follow.

Part What to do
Statements Join them into one chain through common letters
Conclusion I, II, III, IV Test each against the chain
Answer options Pick the option that lists exactly the conclusions that follow
Complementary pair If two untested conclusions cover all cases, answer either-or

Sometimes all follow, sometimes none do. The conclusions are tested independently. One conclusion being true never makes another true.

How Do You Solve a Set Quickly?

In short: draw one chain, mark each conclusion Y or N, and then check the N conclusions for a complementary pair.

  1. Build the chain. Place the letters in order through the common letters, flipping relations if needed. If the statements form two separate chains, keep them apart.
  2. Test each conclusion. Write Y if the chain proves it and N if it does not.
  3. Check the N conclusions. If two of them compare the same pair of letters and are complementary, answer either-or for that pair.
  4. Choose the option. Match your list of Y conclusions and either-or pairs with the options.

Rules to apply in every set

  • Strict with any gives strict; two non-strict give non-strict.
  • Opposite arrows give no relation.
  • A weaker relation than the chain proves still follows.
  • Either-or needs the same pair, neither proved, and a complementary pair such as (>, ≤) or (<, ≥).

The either-or rule is explained fully in Inequality Problems Involving ‘Either-Or’ Conclusions.

How Do You Avoid Errors in Sets?

In short: test each conclusion alone, do not assume a relation between letters that are not in the same chain, and always check the strictness.

  • Strictness: a conclusion with > needs a strict link somewhere in the chain.
  • Same chain: two letters from separate chains are not comparable.
  • Complementary conclusions: they are easy to miss when the set has four conclusions. Look for the same pair of letters twice.

The first-principles chain method is in Direct Inequality Problems (Combining Given Relations to Draw a Conclusion).

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: Statements: D > E, E ≥ F, F ≥ G, G = H. Conclusions: I. D > H II. E ≥ H III. F > H IV. G ≤ D. Which follow?

  1. Chain: D > E ≥ F ≥ G = H.
  2. I: D > E ≥ F ≥ G = H gives D > H. Follows.
  3. II: E ≥ F ≥ G = H gives E ≥ H. Follows.
  4. III: F ≥ G = H gives only F ≥ H, so F > H does not follow.
  5. IV: G ≤ F ≤ E < D gives G < D, so G ≤ D follows.

Answer: I, II and IV follow

Example 2

Question: Statements: A ≥ B, B > C, C > D, D = E. Conclusions: I. A > E II. B > D III. C ≥ E IV. A = B. Which follow?

  1. Chain: A ≥ B > C > D = E.
  2. I: A ≥ B > C > D = E gives A > E. Follows.
  3. II: B > C > D gives B > D. Follows.
  4. III: C > D = E gives C > E, so C ≥ E follows.
  5. IV: A ≥ B does not prove equality. Does not follow.

Answer: I, II and III follow

Example 3

Question: Statements: P > Q, Q ≤ R, S < P. Conclusions: I. P ≥ R II. P Q IV. S ≤ Q. Which follow?

  1. The chains are P > Q ≤ R and S < P. P and R lie on opposite arrows, and S and Q are both below P, so neither pair is related.
  2. I and II are about the same pair, P and R. Neither follows alone, and (≥, <) is complementary.
  3. III and IV are about the same pair, S and Q. Neither follows alone, and (>, ≤) is complementary.

Answer: Either I or II follows, and either III or IV follows

Example 4

Question: Using $ for >, # for <, @ for ≥ and * for ≤. Statements: J $ K, L # K, M @ L. Conclusions: I. J $ L II. J $ M III. K $ L IV. M * J. Which follow?

  1. Decode: J > K, L K > L ≤ M.
  2. I: J > K > L gives J > L. Follows.
  3. III: K > L is given. Follows.
  4. II and IV compare J and M, which are on opposite arrows. Neither follows, and (>, ≤) is complementary.

Answer: I and III follow, and either II or IV follows

Example 5

Question: Statements: A = B, B ≥ C, D > C. Conclusions: I. A ≥ C II. D > B III. D > A IV. B < D. Which follow?

  1. Chain: A = B ≥ C < D. D is above C, and A, B are at least C, so D and B have no relation.
  2. I: A = B ≥ C gives A ≥ C. Follows.
  3. II, III and IV compare D with A or B. None is proved.

Answer: Only I follows

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Draw the chain as one line of letters before reading the conclusions.
  • Mark each conclusion Y or N in the margin.
  • Look for two conclusions on the same pair of letters; that signals either-or.
  • If all conclusions look true, recheck the strictness of each.
  • For two separate chains, no conclusion across them follows.

Common Mistakes

  • Accepting a strict conclusion from a chain with only non-strict links.
  • Missing a complementary pair among the unproved conclusions.
  • Comparing letters from different chains.
  • Choosing an option that lists a conclusion that fails.
  • Giving either-or when a conclusion of the pair follows alone.

Practice Questions

  1. P > Q ≥ R = S. I. P > S II. Q ≥ S III. R < P. Which follow?
  2. A ≤ B D. I. A D III. D < C. Which follow?
  3. M > N ≥ O

    O II. N

    O. Which follow?

  4. X ≥ Y, Z ≥ Y. I. X > Z II. X ≤ Z. What follows?
  5. C < D = E ≤ F. I. C C. Which follow?
  6. G ≥ H > I J II. H ≤ J. What follows?

Answers: 1) All three; 2) I and III only; 3) I and III only; 4) Either I or II; 5) All three; 6) Either I or II.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Exam use The standard format of bank inequality sets.
  • Accuracy Practises disciplined conclusion testing.
  • Speed A single chain answers every conclusion.
  • Link to other topics Pairs with Inequality Problems Involving ‘Either-Or’ Conclusions and Inequality Problems Requiring Combination of Direct and Coded Relations.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Inequality Problems Requiring Combination of Direct and Coded Relations. It mixes direct and coded relations in one set.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Set A group of statements with its conclusions
  • Chain The joined line of relations
  • Follows True in every permitted case
  • Complementary pair Conclusions that deny each other
  • Either-or One of two untested conclusions must be true
  • Separate chains Statements with no common letter
  • Inequality Problems Involving ‘Either-Or’ Conclusions
  • Inequality Problems Requiring Combination of Direct and Coded Relations
  • Direct Inequality Problems (Combining Given Relations to Draw a Conclusion)
  • Coded Inequality Problems (Symbols Representing Mathematical Relations)

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Draw one chain and test every conclusion on it.
  • Conclusions are independent of each other.
  • Look for complementary pairs among failed conclusions.
  • Strictness matters.
  • Separate chains cannot be compared.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Multiple conclusions vs single conclusion Each conclusion is tested separately in a set.
  • Either-or vs neither Either-or needs a complementary pair on the same letters.
  • Follows vs may follow Follows means always true.
  • Set vs syllogism Inequality sets use chains; syllogisms use groups.

Memory Hook

One chain, test each conclusion, then hunt for a complementary pair.

GS Relevance

The standard five-statement format of IBPS PO, SBI PO and clerk prelims, and a useful practice ground for the logic of conclusion testing used in syllogisms and CSAT reasoning.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you solve inequality questions with multiple conclusions?

Join the statements into one chain through the common letters, then test each conclusion separately against that chain, marking each as following or not. Finally look among the conclusions that fail for two on the same pair of letters that are complementary, which gives an either-or answer.

What does only I and II follow mean in inequality?

It means that conclusions I and II are true in every case allowed by the statements, while the other conclusions are not proved. Each conclusion is judged on its own, so you must check them one by one against the chain before choosing the option.

How do you spot an either-or pair in a set of conclusions?

Look for two conclusions that compare the same two letters and are complementary, such as greater than with at most, or less than with at least. If neither is proved by the chain alone, the answer for that pair is either one or the other follows.

Can a set contain two either-or pairs?

Yes. A set with four conclusions can contain two different pairs of letters, each with complementary conclusions. The answer is then either I or II follows, and either III or IV follows. Each pair is tested on its own, using the same rules.

Why do conclusions across separate chains never follow?

If the statements form two chains with no common letter, there is nothing that links a letter in one chain to a letter in the other. Without a link, no relation can be proved, so any conclusion comparing them fails, although an either-or pair may exist.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 In a set of conclusions, each conclusion is tested independently.
True

One conclusion being true does not make another true.

2 If A ≥ B ≥ C, the conclusion A > C follows.
False

Only A ≥ C follows.

3 Conclusions A > C and A ≤ C can give an either-or answer when neither is proved.
True

They are complementary.

4 Letters in two separate chains can be compared.
False

There is no link between them.

Share: