Profit and Loss on Whole and Part of Goods Sold Separately
Quantitative Aptitude › Profit, Loss and Discount · Topic 5.7
When goods bought together are sold in parts, the overall profit is the weighted average of the profits or losses on the parts, with the cost of each part as the weight. A missing profit on one part can be found by reversing this average.
6 min read · Quantitative Aptitude · Profit, Loss and Discount
Quick Answer
When goods bought together are sold in parts, the overall profit is the weighted average of the profits or losses on the parts, with the cost of each part as the weight. A missing profit on one part can be found by reversing this average.
At a Glance
- Overall profit Sum of (fraction × profit %)
- Fractions Based on cost, not selling price
- Missing rate (Target – known part)/remaining fraction
- Alternative method Compare total SP with total CP
- Link Alligation of profits
Where Does It Fit?
This topic follows Problems Involving Multiple/Successive Transactions and Overall Profit or Loss and uses weighted averages, which are formalised in Mixture and Alligation Rule (Rule of Alligation). The alligation shortcut for such problems is in Mixing Two or More Ingredients of Different Prices/Concentrations.
How Do You Find the Overall Profit When Goods Are Sold in Parts?
In short: if equal-cost parts earn different profits, take the weighted average of the profit percentages, weighting by the cost of each part.
Method
- Overall profit % = (CP1 × p1 + CP2 × p2 + …)/(CP1 + CP2 + …)
- If fractions f1, f2 of the goods (by cost) earn p1% and p2%, overall = f1 p1 + f2 p2
- A loss is a negative profit
| Part of goods | Profit or loss | Contribution to overall |
|---|---|---|
| 40% of the goods | +20% | 0.4 × 20 = +8 |
| 60% of the goods | +3.33% | 0.6 × 3.33 = +2 |
| Overall | +10% |
How Do You Find the Missing Profit or Loss?
In short: subtract the known contribution from the target and divide by the remaining fraction.
- Example: 40% of the goods are sold at a 20% profit. To earn 10% overall, the rest must give (10 – 8)/0.6 = 3.33% profit.
- Loss on the remainder: if 2/3 of the goods are sold at a 12% profit, the contribution is 8%. To have a 4% overall profit, the rest must give (4 – 8)/(1/3) = -12%, a 12% loss.
- Check: add the contributions again and compare with the target.
How Do You Solve Rupee-Based Part Sale Problems?
In short: when numbers of articles and prices are given, compute total cost and total revenue directly.
- Example: 50 articles cost Rs 20 each, a total of Rs 1,000. 20 sell at Rs 30 each (Rs 600) and 30 at Rs 25 each (Rs 750). Revenue = Rs 1,350, so the profit is Rs 350, which is 35%.
- Break-even example: 100 kg of sugar costs Rs 40 per kg. 60 kg sell at a 10% profit and 40 kg at a 15% loss. The revenue is 60 × 44 + 40 × 34 = Rs 4,000, equal to the cost, so there is no profit.
- Equal halves: if half the goods give a 24% profit and half a 4% loss, the overall profit is (24 – 4)/2 = 10%.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: A trader sells 40% of his goods at a 20% profit. At what profit percentage must he sell the rest to earn a 10% overall profit?
- Contribution of the first part = 0.4 × 20 = 8.
- Needed from the rest = 10 – 8 = 2.
- Remaining fraction = 0.6, so the rate = 2/0.6 = 3.33%.
Answer: 3.33% profit
Example 2
Question: A man sells 2/3 of his goods at a 12% profit. At what rate must he sell the rest to earn 4% overall?
- Contribution = 2/3 × 12 = 8.
- Needed from the rest = 4 – 8 = -4.
- Rate = -4/(1/3) = -12.
Answer: A loss of 12%
Example 3
Question: 50 articles cost Rs 20 each. 20 are sold at Rs 30 each and 30 at Rs 25 each. Find the overall profit percentage.
- Total CP = 50 × 20 = 1,000.
- Revenue = 20 × 30 + 30 × 25 = 600 + 750 = 1,350.
- Profit = 350, so 35%.
Answer: 35%
Example 4
Question: A dealer buys 100 kg of sugar at Rs 40 per kg. He sells 60 kg at a 10% profit and the rest at a 15% loss. Find the overall result.
- CP = 4,000.
- Revenue: 60 × 44 = 2,640 and 40 × 34 = 1,360, a total of 4,000.
Answer: No profit and no loss
Example 5
Question: Half of the goods are sold at a 24% profit and half at a 4% loss. Find the overall profit.
- Weighted average = 0.5 × 24 + 0.5 × (-4).
- = 12 – 2 = 10.
Answer: 10% profit
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Weight each profit percentage by the cost fraction of that part.
- Treat a loss as a negative profit.
- To find a missing rate, subtract the known contribution and divide by the remaining fraction.
- If the numbers are small, compute total revenue and total cost directly.
- Check by adding all contributions.
Common Mistakes
- Weighting by selling price when the question gives fractions of the cost.
- Averaging two percentages without weights.
- Ignoring a loss sign when combining parts.
- Using the profit of the first part as the overall profit.
- Forgetting that fractions must add to 1.
Practice Questions
- 40% of goods at 20% profit and 60% at 10% profit. Find the overall profit.
- Half of the goods at 30% profit and half at 10% loss. Find the overall profit.
- 1/3 of goods at 15% profit. At what rate must the rest be sold for 10% overall profit?
- Buys 100 articles at Rs 10 each, sells 40 at Rs 15 and 60 at Rs 12. Find the overall profit %.
- 3/4 of the goods at 8% profit. At what rate must the rest be sold to break even?
- Equal-cost halves at 25% profit and 15% loss. Find the overall result.
Answers: 1) 14%; 2) 10%; 3) 7.5%; 4) 32%; 5) a loss of 24%; 6) 5% profit.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Realistic Stocks are often sold in lots.
- Average skill It trains the weighted average used in Mixture and Alligation Rule (Rule of Alligation).
- Shortcut It prepares the alligation method in Mixing Two or More Ingredients of Different Prices/Concentrations.
- Link It builds on Problems Involving Multiple/Successive Transactions and Overall Profit or Loss.
What Comes Next?
The next topic, Marked Price Set Above Cost Price to Allow a Discount and Still Yield a Target Profit, goes back to marked price and asks how far above cost the price must be marked to earn a target profit after a discount.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Part of goods A share of the total stock
- Whole stock All the goods bought
- Weighted average Average weighted by sizes
- Remaining goods The part not yet sold
- Total cost Cost of the whole stock
Related Topics
- Problems Involving Multiple/Successive Transactions and Overall Profit or Loss
- Marked Price Set Above Cost Price to Allow a Discount and Still Yield a Target Profit
- Cost Price, Selling Price and Marked Price Relationships
- Profit Percentage and Loss Percentage Calculation
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Overall % = sum of (fraction × profit %).
- Weights are cost fractions.
- A loss is negative.
- Missing rate = (target – known)/remaining fraction.
- Check by adding contributions.
Do Not Confuse With
- Cost fraction vs SP fraction Weights are by cost.
- Average vs weighted average The ordinary average is wrong if parts differ.
- Profit vs loss Include the sign.
Memory Hook
Weight each profit by the cost it sits on.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you find overall profit when goods are sold in parts?
To find the overall profit when goods are sold in parts, multiply each part's cost fraction by its profit percentage and add the results, treating losses as negative. If 40 per cent of goods earn 20 per cent profit and 60 per cent earn 3.33 per cent, the overall profit is 10 per cent.
How do you find the missing profit on the remaining goods?
To find the missing profit on the remaining goods, subtract the known contribution from the target profit and divide by the remaining fraction. With 40 per cent of goods at 20 per cent profit and a target of 10 per cent, the rest need (10 minus 8) divided by 0.6, which is 3.33 per cent.
Why must the weights be cost fractions?
The weights must be cost fractions because profit percentage is measured on cost price, so each part's profit in rupees depends on its cost. Using selling prices or quantities without regard to cost would give an incorrect overall percentage.
What happens when a part is sold at a loss?
When a part is sold at a loss, treat the loss as a negative profit in the weighted average. If half of the goods earn a 24 per cent profit and half a 4 per cent loss, the overall profit is half of 24 minus half of 4, which is 10 per cent.
Can part sales give no profit and no loss?
Part sales can give no profit and no loss if the profits on some parts exactly offset the losses on others. For 100 kg of sugar at Rs 40 per kg, selling 60 kg at 10 per cent profit and 40 kg at 15 per cent loss gives revenue equal to cost.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 If equal-cost halves are sold at 24% profit and 4% loss, the overall profit is 10%.
The average is (24 - 4)/2 = 10.
2 The overall profit of unequal parts is the simple average of their profit percentages.
It is the cost-weighted average.
3 If 40% of goods earn 20% and 60% earn 3.33%, the overall profit is 10%.
8 + 2 = 10.
4 A loss on one part is treated as a positive number in the weighted average.
A loss is a negative profit.
Related Topics
Browse the full Quantitative Aptitude index