An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 5.5

False Weight and Dishonest Dealer Problems

Quantitative Aptitude › Profit, Loss and Discount · Topic 5.5

A dishonest dealer uses a false weight, giving the customer less than the stated weight, so he gains even when he claims to sell at cost price. His gain percentage is the error divided by the weight actually given, multiplied by 100.

Share:
False Weight and Dishonest Dealer Problems - Quantitative Aptitude - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

A dishonest dealer uses a false weight, giving the customer less than the stated weight, so he gains even when he claims to sell at cost price. His gain percentage is the error divided by the weight actually given, multiplied by 100.

At a Glance

  • Gain % (sells at cost) Error/(True weight – Error) × 100
  • Error True weight – False weight
  • Gain % (alternative) (True/False – 1) × 100
  • With stated profit Multiply the two multipliers
  • Buys heavy, sells light Multiply both effects

Where Does It Fit?

This topic applies Profit Percentage and Loss Percentage Calculation to a case where the profit comes from weight, not price. It uses the multiplier method of Successive Percentage Change (Two or More Successive Changes), and combines with markup in Marked Price Set Above Cost Price to Allow a Discount and Still Yield a Target Profit.

How Does a False Weight Give a Dealer a Gain?

In short: the dealer takes money for a full kilogram but delivers less, so the goods he gives cost him less than the money he receives.

Formulas

  • Gain % = (True weight – False weight)/False weight × 100
  • Gain % = (Error/(True weight – Error)) × 100
  • Gain multiplier from the weight alone = True weight/False weight
False weight for 1 kg Error Gain multiplier Gain %
950 g 50 g 1000/950 5.26%
900 g 100 g 1000/900 11.11%
800 g 200 g 1000/800 25%
750 g 250 g 1000/750 33.33%

What If the Dealer Also Claims a Profit?

In short: the stated profit and the weight gain multiply, because the customer pays the marked-up price for less goods.

  • Example: a dealer uses 800 g for a kilogram and sells at a 10% profit. The combined multiplier is 1.1 × 1000/800 = 1.375, a gain of 37.5%.
  • Another case: a 20% stated profit with 900 g gives 1.2 × 1000/900 = 1.3333, a gain of 33.33%.
  • Method: convert each effect to a multiplier, multiply them, and subtract 1.

What If the Dealer Uses False Weights While Buying and Selling?

In short: a dealer who buys with a heavier weight and sells with a lighter weight gains twice.

  • Buying: he receives 1,100 g while paying for 1,000 g.
  • Selling: he delivers 900 g while charging for 1,000 g.
  • Net gain: goods bought for the price of 1,000 g are sold as 1,100/900 kilograms worth of price, so the multiplier is 1,100/900 = 1.2222, a gain of 22.22%.
  • Finding the false weight: if the gain is 20% by false weight alone, 1000/x = 1.2, so x = 833.33 g.

The percentage ideas behind this are explained in Profit Percentage and Loss Percentage Calculation, and multiple transactions are in Problems Involving Multiple/Successive Transactions and Overall Profit or Loss.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: A dealer claims to sell at cost price but uses a 900 g weight for 1 kg. Find his gain percentage.

  1. Error = 1,000 – 900 = 100 g.
  2. Gain % = 100/900 × 100.
  3. 100/900 × 100 = 11.11%.

Answer: 11.11%

Example 2

Question: A dealer uses an 800 g weight for 1 kg. Find his gain percentage.

  1. Error = 200 g.
  2. Gain % = 200/800 × 100 = 25%.

Answer: 25%

Example 3

Question: A dealer uses an 800 g weight for 1 kg and also sells at a profit of 10% on cost. Find his total gain.

  1. Multiplier from the weight = 1000/800 = 1.25.
  2. Multiplier from profit = 1.1.
  3. Total = 1.25 × 1.1 = 1.375, a gain of 37.5%.

Answer: 37.5%

Example 4

Question: A dealer buys with a weight of 1,100 g for 1 kg and sells with a weight of 900 g for 1 kg. Find his gain.

  1. He gets 1,100 g and delivers 900 g for each kg-priced unit.
  2. Multiplier = 1,100/900 = 1.2222.

Answer: 22.22%

Example 5

Question: A dealer gains 20% through a false weight alone. Find the weight he uses for a kilogram.

  1. 1000/x = 1.2.
  2. x = 1000/1.2 = 833.33.

Answer: About 833.33 g

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Divide the error by the weight actually given, not by the true weight.
  • Use fraction pairs: 1/10 error gives 11.11% gain, 1/5 error gives 25%, 1/4 error gives 33.33%.
  • Combine stated profit and weight gain by multiplying the multipliers.
  • For a gain g%, the false weight is 100/(100 + g) of the true weight.
  • Reduce the problem to 1 kg to avoid unit confusion.

Common Mistakes

  • Dividing the error by the true weight, which gives 10% in place of 11.11% for a 900 g weight.
  • Adding the stated profit and the weight gain instead of multiplying them.
  • Forgetting to convert kilograms to grams.
  • Using false weights both ways but counting only one of them.
  • Treating a false weight as a discount.

Practice Questions

  1. A dealer uses a 750 g weight for 1 kg. Find his gain.
  2. A dealer uses a 900 g weight and charges a 20% profit. Find his total gain.
  3. A dealer gains 25% by a false weight alone. What weight does he use for 1 kg?
  4. A dealer uses a 960 g weight for 1 kg. Find his gain.
  5. A dealer uses a 950 g weight for 1 kg. Find his gain.
  6. A dealer buys with 1,200 g for 1 kg and sells with 1,000 g for 1 kg. Find his gain.

Answers: 1) 33.33%; 2) 33.33%; 3) 800 g; 4) 4.17%; 5) 5.26%; 6) 20%.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Exam favourite It is a regular trick question.
  • Real life It shows why standard weights matter.
  • Link It extends Profit Percentage and Loss Percentage Calculation.
  • Multiplier skill It reinforces Successive Percentage Change (Two or More Successive Changes).

What Comes Next?

The next topic, Problems Involving Multiple/Successive Transactions and Overall Profit or Loss, covers articles bought and sold more than once and how to find the overall profit or loss.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • False weight A weight lighter than its label
  • True weight The weight the buyer pays for
  • Error True weight minus false weight
  • Gain percentage Gain as a percentage
  • Dishonest dealer A seller who uses false weights

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Gain % = error/(true – error) × 100.
  • 900 g for 1 kg gives 11.11% gain.
  • 800 g for 1 kg gives 25% gain.
  • Combine profit and weight gain by multiplying.
  • Divide by the weight actually given.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Error on true vs on false weight The denominator is the weight actually given.
  • Sum vs product of effects Stated profit and weight gain multiply.
  • False weight vs discount A false weight is cheating, not a price reduction.

Memory Hook

Error over what is given, not over what is promised.

GS Relevance

Common SSC CGL and CAT trick type: gain from a false weight, with or without an additional stated profit.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you calculate the gain of a dishonest dealer?

The gain percentage of a dishonest dealer who sells at cost price is the error divided by the weight actually given, multiplied by 100. A dealer who uses a 900 g weight for 1 kg has an error of 100 g, so the gain is 100 over 900, which is 11.11 per cent.

Why is the gain divided by the false weight and not the true weight?

The gain is divided by the false weight because the false weight is what the dealer actually gives up, so it represents his true cost. Dividing the 100 g error by 900 g gives 11.11 per cent, while dividing by 1,000 g would wrongly give 10 per cent.

How is the gain calculated when a dealer also claims a profit?

When a dealer uses a false weight and also claims a profit, multiply the weight multiplier by the profit multiplier. A dealer using 800 g for 1 kg and charging 10 per cent profit has a multiplier of 1.25 times 1.1, which is 1.375, a total gain of 37.5 per cent.

How do you find the false weight from the gain?

To find the false weight from a gain of g per cent, divide the true weight by one plus g over 100. A dealer who gains 20 per cent through false weight alone uses 1,000 divided by 1.2, which is about 833.33 g for each kilogram.

What happens if the dealer cheats in both buying and selling?

If a dealer buys with a heavier weight and sells with a lighter weight, the two gains multiply. Receiving 1,100 g for each kilogram bought and delivering 900 g for each kilogram sold gives a multiplier of 1,100 over 900, a gain of 22.22 per cent.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 A dealer who uses a 900 g weight for 1 kg and sells at cost gains 10%.
False

The gain is 100/900 × 100 = 11.11 per cent.

2 A dealer who uses an 800 g weight for 1 kg and sells at cost gains 25%.
True

The error 200 g divided by 800 g is 25 per cent.

3 A false weight of 750 g for 1 kg gives a gain of 33.33%.
True

250/750 = 1/3.

4 Stated profit and weight gain add together to give the total gain.
False

They combine by multiplication.

Share: