An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 6.15

Early Phase of the Indian National Congress and the Moderate Congress (1885–1905)

Modern History › Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements · Topic 6.15

The Moderate phase of the Indian National Congress, from 1885 to 1905, was led by Dadabhai Naoroji, Pherozeshah Mehta, Surendranath Banerjea, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, W.C. Bonnerjee and others. They believed in constitutional agitation, the method of prayers, petitions and memorials, and in working through public opinion in India and in Britain. They criticised the economy of colonial rule and asked for greater Indian share in government.

Share:
Early Phase of the Indian National Congress and the Moderate Congress (1885–1905) - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • What it is The first phase of the Congress, 1885-1905
  • Leaders Naoroji, Pherozshah Mehta, Wacha, W.C. Bonnerjea, S.N. Banerjea
  • Method Constitutional agitation; prayer and petition
  • Belief British connection was in India’s interest at that stage
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 6.15 of the category “Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements”. The Moderate phase is the first of the three phases of the Congress before independence. It precedes the Extremist phase that began after the partition of Bengal and sets up the comparison between the two schools that is asked in almost every Prelims and Mains paper. Previous topic: Peasant Movements: Telangana Movement.

Who Were the Moderates?

The national leaders who dominated the Congress in its early period (1885-1905) were Dadabhai Naoroji, Pherozshah Mehta, D.E. Wacha, W.C. Bonnerjea (Bonnerjee) and S.N. Banerjea. They were staunch believers in liberalism and moderate politics and came to be labelled Moderates, to distinguish them from the neo-nationalists of the early twentieth century, who were called Extremists. Other great presidents of this phase, as listed in Foundation of the Indian National Congress and the Safety-Valve Debate, included Badruddin Tyabji, P. Anandacharlu, Romesh Chandra Dutt, Ananda Mohan Bose and Gopal Krishna Gokhale.

What Was the Moderate Approach?

Moderate political activity involved constitutional agitation within the confines of law and showed slow but orderly political progress. The Moderates believed that the British basically wanted to be just to Indians but were not aware of the real conditions. If public opinion could be created in the country and public demands presented to the government through resolutions, petitions and meetings, the authorities would concede them gradually.

They worked on a two-pronged method: first, to create a strong public opinion to arouse consciousness and national spirit, and to educate and unite people on common political questions; second, to persuade the British government and British public opinion to introduce reforms in India on the lines laid out by the nationalists. They used the method of prayer and petition and, if that failed, resorted to constitutional agitation.

Feature Detail
Method Constitutional agitation within the law; resolutions, petitions, meetings
Assumption The British basically wanted to be just but were unaware of real conditions
Two prongs Public opinion in India; persuasion of the British government and public
Escalation Prayer and petition first; constitutional agitation if that failed

How Did They Campaign in Britain?

A British committee of the Indian National Congress was established in London in 1889, with the journal India as its organ. Dadabhai Naoroji spent a substantial part of his life and income campaigning for India’s case abroad. In 1890 it was decided to hold a session of the Congress in London in 1892, but owing to the British elections of 1891 the proposal was postponed and never revived. The early links of Naoroji with London are in Political Associations Before the Indian National Congress.

Why Did They Accept the British Connection?

The Moderate leaders believed that political connections with Britain were in India’s interest at that stage of history and that the time was not ripe for a direct challenge to British rule. They therefore considered it appropriate to try to transform colonial rule to be as close to national rule as possible.

As an analytical point, the Moderate approach was a reasoned choice, not simply timidity. A small educated group with no mass base, as seen in Evaluation of the Early Nationalists, had few other options in the 1880s and 1890s, and public opinion was a resource that colonial rule had not yet learnt to suppress. Their contributions, taken in turn in Economic Critique of British Imperialism by the Early Nationalists and Constitutional Reforms, Administrative Reforms and Civil Rights Campaigns, were therefore ideas and constitutional pressure. The militant reaction that followed is told in later categories.

Who Presided Over the Early Congress Sessions?

Year Place President
1885 Bombay W.C. Bonnerjee
1886 Calcutta Dadabhai Naoroji
1887 Madras Badruddin Tyabji
1888 Allahabad George Yule
1889 Bombay Sir William Wedderburn
1890 Calcutta Pherozeshah Mehta
1893 Lahore Dadabhai Naoroji
1905 Benares Gopal Krishna Gokhale

The early presidents were chosen from different regions and religions, to show that the Congress represented all of India. The first session in December 1885 was attended by 72 delegates.

What Did the Moderates Achieve?

The Moderates won a few concessions. The Indian Councils Act of 1892 enlarged the Legislative Councils and allowed a limited right of discussing the budget and asking questions, though no election as such was recognised. The Public Service Commission of 1886 to 1887 and the Welby Commission on Indian expenditure (1895) followed Congress agitation, and the demand for simultaneous civil service examinations in London and India, passed by the House of Commons in 1893, was never carried out. These results seemed small to younger nationalists, and the gap between demands and gains was one reason for the rise of the Extremists.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Leaders and methods The names and the prayer-and-petition method are asked often
  • Contrast It sets up the contrast with the Extremists
  • Mains theme Why the Moderates chose their path

What Came Next?

Next topic: Differences Between the Moderates and the Extremists.

Key People and Terms

  • Moderates Liberal leaders of the Congress, 1885-1905
  • Constitutional agitation Agitation within the confines of law
  • Prayer and petition The Moderate method of requesting reforms
  • British committee The Congress committee set up in London in 1889
  • Extremists The neo-nationalists of the early twentieth century
  • Public opinion The collective view of the people created by the Moderates

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Leaders: Naoroji, Pherozshah Mehta, Wacha, W.C. Bonnerjee, S.N. Banerjea.
  • Method: constitutional agitation; prayer and petition.
  • Belief: the British were basically just but unaware.
  • British committee of the Congress, London, 1889; journal India.
  • London session proposed for 1892, postponed.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Moderates and Extremists Moderates: petitions within law; Extremists: more militant methods
  • British committee and East India Association The committee was the Congress’s own London body of 1889; the Association was Naoroji’s of 1866
  • Constitutional agitation and prayer and petition Prayer and petition came first; constitutional agitation followed

Memory Hook

Petition first, agitate within law, persuade Britain.

Mains Angle

Questions ask for the approach and methods of the Moderates. These points add depth.

  • Faith in British justice They believed the British were basically fair
  • Public opinion Education and unity of the people came first
  • Timing A direct challenge was premature

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Describe the methods and approach of the Moderates in the Indian National Congress.”

How to Answer

  1. Who The leaders and their liberal beliefs.
  2. How Constitutional agitation, prayer and petition.
  3. Where In India and in Britain.
  4. Conclude Explain their acceptance of the British connection.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements. GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who were the Moderates in the Indian National Congress?

The Moderates were leaders like Dadabhai Naoroji, Pherozshah Mehta, D.E. Wacha, W.C. Bonnerjee and S.N. Banerjea, who dominated the Congress from 1885 to 1905 and believed in liberalism and constitutional methods. They were later distinguished from the Extremists.

What was the Moderate approach to politics?

The Moderates used constitutional agitation within the law, believing the British basically wanted to be just but were unaware of the real conditions. They created public opinion and presented demands through resolutions, petitions and meetings, so that authorities would concede gradually.

What was the two-pronged methodology of the Moderates?

The Moderates first created a strong public opinion to arouse national spirit and unite people on common questions, and second persuaded the British government and British public opinion to introduce reforms on the lines laid out by the nationalists.

What was the British committee of the Congress?

A British committee of the Indian National Congress was established in London in 1889, with the journal India as its organ. Dadabhai Naoroji spent a large part of his life and income campaigning for India's case in Britain.

Why did the Moderates accept the British connection?

They believed that political connection with Britain was in India's interest at that stage and that the time was not ripe for a direct challenge. They therefore tried to transform colonial rule so that it came as close as possible to national rule.

What happened to the proposed Congress session in London?

In 1890 it was decided to hold a session of the Congress in London in 1892, but the British elections of 1891 caused it to be postponed, and the proposal was never revived afterwards, so the Congress never met in London.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Moderates believed in constitutional agitation within the confines of law.
True

They used prayer and petition.

2 The British committee of the Congress was set up in London in 1889.
True

Its organ was the journal India.

3 The Moderates believed that the time was ripe for a direct challenge to British rule.
False

They believed the time was not ripe.

4 The Moderates were later called Extremists.
False

The neo-nationalists of the early twentieth century were called Extremists.

5 A Congress session in London in 1892 was held as planned.
False

It was postponed because of the British elections of 1891 and never revived.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: