An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 6.17

The Extremist Phase of the Congress (1905–1920)

Modern History › Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements · Topic 6.17

The Extremist phase of the Congress, from 1905 to 1920, grew out of the partition of Bengal and the Swadeshi movement. Its leaders, Tilak, Bipin Chandra Pal, Lajpat Rai and Aurobindo Ghose, called for swaraj, boycott of foreign goods and passive resistance. They took the movement to wider sections of society, and after the Surat split of 1907 and government repression they were weakened until the Lucknow session of 1916.

Share:
The Extremist Phase of the Congress (1905–1920) - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • What it is The Swadeshi and Boycott Movement after the Extremists took charge
  • Congress 1905 Gokhale presided; condemned the partition and supported Bengal’s movement
  • Congress 1906 Naoroji presided; goal declared self-government or swaraj
  • Extremist programme Passive resistance plus boycott of schools, services, courts, councils
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 6.17 of the category “Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements”. The Extremist phase follows the Moderate phase and precedes the Gandhian phase of the Congress. It begins with the partition of Bengal in 1905 and ends with the first of Gandhi’s campaigns in 1919-20. Previous topic: Differences Between the Moderates and the Extremists.

What Was the Congress Position in 1905?

The Indian National Congress, meeting in 1905 under the presidentship of Gokhale, resolved to (i) condemn the partition of Bengal and the reactionary policies of Curzon, and (ii) support the anti-partition and Swadeshi Movement of Bengal.

The militant nationalists led by Tilak, Lajpat Rai, Bipin Chandra Pal and Aurobindo Ghosh wanted the movement taken outside Bengal and extended beyond the boycott of foreign goods into a full-fledged political mass struggle with swaraj as its goal. But the Moderates, who dominated the Congress at the time, were not willing to go that far. At the Benaras session, a relatively mild resolution was passed as a compromise, which averted a split for the moment, as told in Surat Split, 1907.

What Happened at the Calcutta Session of 1906?

A big step forward was taken at the Congress session at Calcutta in 1906, under the presidentship of Dadabhai Naoroji, where it was declared that the goal of the Indian National Congress was self-government or swaraj like the United Kingdom or the colonies of Australia and Canada. The Moderate-Extremist dispute over the pace of the movement and the techniques of struggle reached a deadlock at the Surat session of 1907, where the party split with serious consequences for the Swadeshi Movement.

Why Did the Extremists Take Over the Movement?

After 1905 the Extremists acquired a dominant influence over the Swadeshi Movement in Bengal, for three reasons: (i) the Moderate-led movement had failed to yield results; (ii) the divisive tactics of the governments of both Bengals had embittered nationalists; and (iii) the government had resorted to suppressive measures.

Suppressive measure Detail
Students Atrocities on students, many given corporal punishment
Songs Ban on the public singing of Vande Mataram
Meetings Restrictions on public meetings
Prosecution Prosecution and long imprisonment of swadeshi workers
Clashes Clashes between the police and the people in many towns
Leaders and press Arrests and deportation of leaders; suppression of the freedom of the press

What Was the Extremist Programme?

Emboldened by Dadabhai Naoroji’s declaration at the Calcutta session in 1906 that self-government or swaraj was to be the goal of the Congress, the Extremists called for passive resistance in addition to swadeshi and boycott. This included the boycott of government schools and colleges, government service, courts, legislative councils, municipalities and government titles. The purpose, as Aurobindo put it, was to make the administration impossible under present conditions by an organised refusal to do anything that would help either British commerce in exploiting the country or British officialdom in administering it.

The militant nationalists tried to turn the anti-partition and Swadeshi Movement into a mass struggle and gave the slogan of India’s independence from foreign rule. Political freedom, Aurobindo declared, is the lifebreath of a nation. Thus the Extremists gave the idea of India’s independence the central place in India’s politics, to be achieved through self-sacrifice.

Programme item Meaning
Passive resistance Organised refusal to help British commerce or officialdom
Boycott of schools and colleges Government educational institutions
Boycott of services, courts, councils, municipalities, titles Government institutions and honours
Goal Swaraj and, for some leaders, independence
Spirit Self-sacrifice

As an analytical point, the word swaraj was used for the first time at Calcutta in 1906, but its meaning was not spelt out. Tilak took it to mean some kind of self-government, while Aurobindo took it to mean complete independence, as noted in Moderates and Extremists: A Comparison. This ambiguity let both Moderates and Extremists accept the Calcutta resolution while understanding it differently.

Who Were the Militant Thinkers and What Did They Believe?

By the dawn of the twentieth century a band of nationalist thinkers had emerged who advocated a more militant approach. They included Raj Narain Bose, Ashwini Kumar Datta, Aurobindo Ghosh and Bipin Chandra Pal in Bengal, Vishnu Shastri Chiplunkar and Bal Gangadhar Tilak in Maharashtra, and Lala Lajpat Rai in Punjab. Tilak emerged as the most outstanding representative of this school.

Tenet of the militant school Detail
Hatred of foreign rule No hope could be derived from it, so Indians should work out their own salvation
Goal Swaraj
Method Direct political action
Faith in the masses Belief in the capacity of the masses to challenge authority
Sacrifice Personal sacrifices required; a true nationalist always ready for them

The new leadership could channel the immense potential for political struggle that the masses possessed. This energy got release in the movement against the partition of Bengal, which took the form of the swadeshi agitation.

As an analytical point, the causes fall into three groups: experience (repression, famine, Curzon), ideas (self-reliance, Indian thinkers, world examples) and the failure of the older method. No single cause explains the shift, and the militant trend grew in the 1890s before the partition gave it a mass opportunity.

What Were the Main Events of the Extremist Phase?

Year Event
1905 Partition of Bengal and the start of the Swadeshi and Boycott movement
1906 Calcutta Congress under Dadabhai Naoroji declares swaraj as the goal
1907 Surat split
1908 Tilak is tried for sedition and sent to Mandalay for six years
1909 Morley-Minto Reforms try to win the Moderates
1916 Lucknow session reunites the Congress; Home Rule Leagues begin

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Key Congress sessions Benaras 1905 and Calcutta 1906 are standard Prelims facts
  • Programme The Extremist programme of boycott and passive resistance is a Mains point
  • Link to Surat The dispute over this programme led to the split

What Came Next?

Next topic: Revolutionary Terrorist Movements in India – Reasons for Their Emergence and Failure.

Key People and Terms

  • Passive resistance Refusal to cooperate with the government without violence
  • Swaraj Self-government, the Congress goal from 1906
  • Extremists The militant nationalists led by Tilak, Pal, Lajpat Rai and Aurobindo
  • Vande Mataram ban A ban on public singing of the song
  • Boycott Refusal to use or deal in British goods and institutions
  • Self-sacrifice The means to independence, in the Extremist view

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • 1905 Benaras: Gokhale; mild compromise resolution.
  • 1906 Calcutta: Naoroji; goal swaraj like Canada or Australia.
  • Extremist programme: passive resistance and boycott of schools, services, courts, councils, titles.
  • Aurobindo: political freedom is the lifebreath of a nation.
  • Extremists took over because Moderates failed to yield results.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Congress 1905 and 1906 1905 Gokhale (Benaras); 1906 Naoroji (Calcutta)
  • Swaraj of 1906 and independence The 1906 swaraj meant self-government; Aurobindo meant complete independence
  • Swadeshi and boycott Swadeshi: use own goods; boycott: refuse foreign goods and institutions

Memory Hook

Naoroji named swaraj; the Extremists named independence.

Mains Angle

Questions ask about the Extremist programme. These points add depth.

  • Wider boycott Beyond goods to institutions
  • Independence as an aim Aurobindo and others put independence at the centre
  • Repression The government’s measures pushed nationalists to the Extremist side

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Examine the role of the Extremists in the Swadeshi and Boycott Movement.”

How to Answer

  1. Takeover Three reasons.
  2. Programme Passive resistance and wider boycott.
  3. Goal Swaraj and independence.
  4. Conclude The deadlock leading to Surat.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements. GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the Extremists dominate the Swadeshi Movement after 1905?

The Moderate-led movement had failed to yield results, the divisive tactics of the governments of both Bengals embittered nationalists, and the government's suppressive measures against students, meetings, songs, workers and the press pushed the movement towards the Extremists.

What was the Extremist programme?

The Extremists called for passive resistance in addition to swadeshi and boycott, including boycott of government schools and colleges, services, courts, legislative councils, municipalities and titles. They aimed to make administration impossible and to turn the movement into a mass struggle.

What did the Calcutta session of 1906 declare?

The Calcutta session of 1906, under Dadabhai Naoroji, declared that the goal of the Congress was self-government or swaraj like the United Kingdom or the colonies of Australia and Canada. It also supported swadeshi, boycott and national education.

What was the Congress position in 1905?

In 1905 the Congress, under Gokhale at Benaras, condemned the partition of Bengal and Curzon's reactionary policies and supported the anti-partition and Swadeshi Movement of Bengal, but would not extend it beyond Bengal as the Extremists wanted.

How did the government try to suppress the Swadeshi Movement?

It punished students, banned the public singing of Vande Mataram, restricted public meetings, prosecuted and imprisoned swadeshi workers, arrested and deported leaders, suppressed the press, and the police clashed with the people in many towns.

What did Aurobindo say about the purpose of passive resistance?

Aurobindo said the purpose was to make the administration impossible under present conditions by an organised refusal to do anything that would help British commerce exploit the country or British officialdom administer it, so that the government would be forced to give way.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Congress session of 1906 at Calcutta was presided over by Dadabhai Naoroji.
True

It declared swaraj the goal.

2 The 1905 Benaras session was presided over by Gokhale.
True

It supported the Swadeshi Movement in Bengal.

3 The Extremists limited the boycott to foreign goods only.
False

They extended it to schools, services, courts and councils.

4 The word swaraj was first mentioned in a Congress resolution in 1906.
True

Its meaning was not spelt out.

5 The Moderates wanted to extend the boycott to government services and councils in 1905.
False

They opposed it.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Peasant, Tribal and Revolutionary Movements. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: