An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 12.3

Development of Public Services After 1857

Modern History › Administrative Changes After 1857 · Topic 12.3

The civil service began as the East India Company's commercial service, and Cornwallis (Governor-General 1786-93) first organised it, raising salaries, banning private trade and presents, and enforcing promotion by seniority. Wellesley set up Fort William College in 1800, replaced in 1806 by the East India College at Haileybury. The Charter Act of 1853 ended Company patronage and opened recruitment to competition, though Indians were excluded from high posts.

Share:
Development of Public Services After 1857 - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Organiser Cornwallis, Governor-General 1786-93
  • Training Fort William College 1800; East India College at Haileybury 1806
  • Open competition Charter Act of 1853
  • Indians Barred from high posts; 1833 promise not implemented
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Administrative Changes After 1857

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 12.3 of the category “Administrative Changes After 1857”. Previous topic: Changes in the Army After 1857.

What Did the Charter Act of 1853 Change?

The Charter Act of 1853 ended the Company’s patronage over the services and required that recruitment henceforth be through open competition. The Charter Act of 1853 is also covered in Constitutional Development 1773-1858: Regulating Act to the Act of 1858.

Why Were Indians Excluded?

Indians were barred from high posts from the very beginning. Cornwallis thought that every native of Hindustan was corrupt, and the Charter Act of 1793 had reserved all posts worth 500 pounds a year or more for the Company’s covenanted servants. The reasons for excluding Indians were as follows.

Reason Detail
Belief 1 Only the English could establish administrative services serving British interests
Belief 2 Indians were incapable, untrustworthy and insensitive to British interests
Competition There was high competition among Europeans themselves for lucrative posts, so there was no reason to offer them to Indians

The Charter Act of 1833 theoretically threw open the services to Indians, but the relevant provisions were never really implemented. After 1857, when Indians claimed a share in the higher services, the Proclamation of 1858 declared the British intention of including Indians freely and impartially in offices under the civil service. As an analytical point, the promise of 1833 and the declaration of 1858 show a pattern: the principle of equal admission was announced by Parliament and the Crown while the working rules, of cost, place of examination and age limit, kept the benefit away from Indians, which is the subject of Indian Civil Service Act, 1861, Statutory Civil Service and the Aitchison Committee.

Why Did the Age Limit Matter?

Lowering the maximum age from 23 to 19 made it hard for Indian candidates, who had to learn the English language and classical subjects and then travel to London for the examination, to compete with British candidates who had trained for it at school. A young Indian candidate had also to bear the cost of travel and stay abroad. The age was thus a barrier even though the examination was in principle open to all British subjects, which is why the Congress made its reduction one of its first demands.

How Should the Civil Services Under British Rule Be Evaluated?

Just as Indians were systematically excluded from law-making and policy-making bodies, they were mostly kept out of the institutions responsible for implementing policy. European supremacy was assured in the civil service as in other spheres of governance in mainly two ways.

  • First, although Indians had been entering the Indian Civil Service since 1863, entry remained extremely difficult for them. The examination was held in London, in English only, and the subjects included classical Greek and Latin learning. The maximum age for appearing was lowered from twenty-three in 1859 to nineteen in 1878 under Lytton.
  • Second, all key positions of power and authority, and those which were well paid, were held by Europeans.

Though a slow process of Indianisation took place after 1918 under nationalist pressure, important and senior positions continued to be held by Europeans. Gradually Indians came to realise that Indianisation had not transferred effective power into Indian hands, and that Indian civil servants continued to serve the imperialist interests of their British masters. The earlier barriers are in Indian Civil Service Act, 1861, Statutory Civil Service and the Aitchison Committee.

As an analytical point, the evaluation separates the number of Indians in the service from the control of the system: the bureaucracy was becoming more Indian in membership, as a result of Montford and Lee, but policy was set in London and by the Viceroy and the senior Europeans, so nationalists criticised the services as an instrument of the existing order. Whether the same structure of the civil services was then taken over by independent India lies outside the scope of this account. The other instruments of control, the police and the army, are in Evolution of the Police System in Modern India and The Military Under the British.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Origins of the civil service Cornwallis is called the father of the civil services
  • Training institutions Fort William and Haileybury are stock Prelims facts
  • Exclusion of Indians A recurring theme in Mains answers on administration

What Came Next?

Next topic: Relations with Princely States After 1857.

Key People and Terms

  • Covenanted servants Company servants bound by covenants, reserved for high posts
  • Fort William College Training college set up by Wellesley in 1800
  • East India College Haileybury college of 1806
  • Open competition Recruitment by examination from 1853
  • Charter Act of 1793 Reserved posts over 500 pounds a year for covenanted servants
  • Proclamation of 1858 Declared an intention of including Indians in offices

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Cornwallis 1786-93: salaries, no private trade, no presents, promotion by seniority.
  • Fort William College 1800; Haileybury 1806.
  • Charter Act of 1853: open competition.
  • Charter Act of 1793: posts over 500 pounds reserved.
  • Charter Act of 1833 promise not implemented.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Fort William and Haileybury Wellesley’s college in India versus the college in England
  • Charter Act of 1833 and 1853 1833 promised equal admission; 1853 introduced open competition
  • Covenanted and uncovenanted Covenanted servants held the high posts

Memory Hook

Cornwallis paid them well, Wellesley trained them, and 1853 made them compete, but Indians stayed out.

Mains Angle

Questions ask about the origin of the civil services and the exclusion of Indians. These points add depth.

  • Cornwallis Organised the services
  • Training Fort William and Haileybury
  • Exclusion Reasons and later declarations

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Trace the evolution of the civil services up to 1853 and explain why Indians were excluded from high posts.”

How to Answer

  1. Origins Company service.
  2. Reforms Cornwallis and Wellesley.
  3. 1853 Open competition.
  4. Conclude Exclusion and declarations.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Administrative Changes After 1857. GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who organised the civil services in India?

Cornwallis, Governor-General from 1786 to 1793, was the first to bring the civil services into existence and organise them. He raised salaries, enforced rules against private trade, banned presents and bribes, and made promotion depend on seniority.

What was the Fort William College?

Wellesley set up Fort William College in 1800 to train new recruits for the Company's service. In 1806 the Court of Directors disapproved of it and set up the East India College at Haileybury in England with two years of training.

What did the Charter Act of 1853 do for the civil service?

The Charter Act of 1853 ended the Company's patronage over appointments and required that recruitment henceforth be through open competition. It was a major step towards a merit-based civil service, though Indians remained effectively excluded.

Why were Indians excluded from high posts?

The British believed that only the English could create administrative services serving British interests, that Indians were incapable and untrustworthy, and that Europeans themselves competed for lucrative posts. The Charter Act of 1793 had reserved posts over 500 pounds a year for covenanted servants.

What did the Charter Act of 1833 and the Proclamation of 1858 promise?

The Charter Act of 1833 theoretically opened the services to Indians but was never really implemented. After 1857 the Proclamation of 1858 declared an intention of including Indians freely and impartially in offices under the civil service.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 Cornwallis is associated with the organisation of the civil services in India.
True

He raised salaries and banned private trade.

2 The East India College was set up at Haileybury in 1806.
True

Wellesley's Fort William College was disapproved.

3 The Charter Act of 1853 introduced open competition for the services.
True

It ended Company patronage.

4 The Charter Act of 1833 was fully implemented to admit Indians to high posts.
False

Its provisions were never really implemented.

5 Fort William College was founded by Cornwallis in 1786.
False

Wellesley founded it in 1800.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Administrative Changes After 1857. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: