Communists and Independence
Modern History › Independence and the New-Born Nation · Topic 30.6
In December 1947 the Communist Party of India called independence fake and in 1948 its Second Congress at Calcutta adopted the Ranadive line of revolution against the Nehru government. The insurgency stayed local to Hyderabad and West Bengal, the party was banned in West Bengal, and at the Third Party Congress in October 1951 it withdrew the Telangana struggle and entered the general election.
6 min read · UPSC Prelims · History · Independence and the New-Born Nation
At a Glance
- Slogan “Ye azadi jhooti hai” (December 1947)
- Second Congress Calcutta, February-March 1948; Political Thesis
- General secretary B.T. Ranadive
- Shift Third Party Congress, Calcutta, October 1951
- Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Independence and the New-Born Nation
Where Does It Fit?
This is the sixth topic of the category on independence and the new-born nation. The previous topic covered refugee rehabilitation and the Delhi Pact. This topic covers the Communist Party’s attitude to independence and its change of line. The next topic opens the story of the Indian states. Previous topic: Rehabilitation of Refugees and the Delhi Pact on Minorities.
What Was the Communist Position in 1947-48?
In September 1948 the Indian Army took control of Hyderabad with little resistance from the Nizam, but the internal politics of the state had become complicated by the Telangana movement led by the communists, described in All India Kisan Sabha and Peasant Activity in the 1930s and 1940s. The alliance between the Congress and the communists had broken before the accession of Hyderabad.
In December 1947 the Communist Party of India (CPI) denounced Indian independence as fake, with the slogan “ye azadi jhooti hai”, and called the Congress government under Nehru the stooge of Anglo-American imperialism and of feudal forces within the country. In February-March 1948 the party’s Second Congress at Calcutta adopted the Political Thesis, which declared that the national government of 15 August 1947 was the major enemy of the Indian people and had to be changed by a general revolution. The line was named after the general secretary B.T. Ranadive. The party declared that the present state would be replaced by a people’s democratic republic, a republic of workers, peasants and oppressed middle classes. The insurgency spread to other parts of the country, especially West Bengal, where the Tebhaga movement revived and an urban insurgency began in Calcutta.
Why Were the Communists Sceptical About Independence?
Three reasons are usually given.
| Reason | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Class struggle | They believed that class struggle and armed insurgency against a state run by the Congress, alleged to be a collaborationist bourgeoisie, were necessary to turn the masses away from the communal hatred that clouded the country after partition |
| International example | The late 1940s and early 1950s saw communist successes in China, Malaya, Indonesia, the Philippines and Burma, and in September 1947 the Soviet Union announced the Zhdanov thesis as an answer to the Marshall Plan, which encouraged activism by communist parties |
| Misreading at home | According to Ramachandra Guha, the CPI leadership, encouraged by the early success in Telangana, mistook scattered disillusionment with the Congress for revolutionary potential and thought it the beginning of Red India |
What Was the Government’s Response?
The communist movement stayed local to Hyderabad and West Bengal. Mass support was sporadic and conditional, because people were not ready to reject the Congress so soon after independence. The government acted firmly. In the Hyderabad region the Indian forces continued their police action; in West Bengal the CPI was banned in March 1948, and a security act was passed to imprison communist leaders without trial. The internal differences on the Chinese line and the Russian line widened after the failure of a proposed railway strike on 9 May 1949. The army action on the state is in Integration of the Indian States, 1947-49.
How Did the Party Return to Constitutional Politics?
In September 1950 leaders such as Ajoy Ghosh, S.A. Dange and S.V. Ghate criticised the party for its faulty strategy and its failure to notice the true picture of independent India. In October 1951 the Third Party Congress at Calcutta endorsed a significant change: it decided to withdraw the Telangana struggle and to build an inclusive front of peasants, workers and the middle classes. The ban was lifted, and the communists took part in the general election of 1951-52, moving from the insurrectionary path to constitutional democracy. The result of that election is in First General Elections, 1951-52.
As an analytical point, the episode shows that the party had read the end of British rule as a change of master and not of the system, and that the reading failed to match the support the Congress still had in 1947-48. The correction in 1951 came from the party’s own senior leaders and from the facts of the countryside, and it made the party the largest opposition group in the first Lok Sabha. The earlier history of the party is in Spread of Socialist and Marxist Ideas, Youth Activism and Trade Unionism and the later parties are in Growth of Other Political Parties.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Ranadive line Names, dates and slogans are standard Prelims facts
- Shift of 1951 Insurrection to elections is a common GS Paper 1 theme
- Early challenges to the state A part of the immediate challenges after independence
What Came Next?
The next topic traces the evolution of British policy towards the Indian states from 1740 to 1935. Next topic: subordinate union, equal federation Chamber of Princes…">Evolution of British Policy Towards the Indian States, 1740-1935.
Key People and Terms
- B.T. Ranadive General secretary behind the 1948 line
- Political Thesis Adopted at the Second Congress, 1948
- Zhdanov thesis Soviet answer to the Marshall Plan
- People’s democratic republic The CPI’s declared aim in 1948
- Telangana movement Peasant guerrilla war in Hyderabad
- Third Party Congress October 1951 meeting that changed the line
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- December 1947: “ye azadi jhooti hai”.
- Second Congress: Calcutta, February-March 1948; Ranadive.
- CPI banned in West Bengal in March 1948.
- Railway strike failed on 9 May 1949.
- Third Congress: October 1951; Telangana struggle withdrawn.
Do Not Confuse With
- Ranadive line and the 1951 line Revolution against the state versus an inclusive front and elections
- Telangana and Tebhaga Hyderabad guerrilla war versus Bengal sharecroppers’ movement
- Second Congress and Third Congress 1948 revolution versus 1951 shift
Memory Hook
A fake freedom in 1947, a revolution line in 1948, ballots in 1951.
Mains Angle
Questions ask about the early stance of the left. These points add depth.
- Line Independence called fake
- Reasons Class struggle, foreign example, misreading
- Outcome Local failure and a turn to elections
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Why did the Communist Party take a hostile line on independence in 1948, and why did it change in 1951?”
How to Answer
- Position Slogan and thesis.
- Reasons Three causes.
- Response Ban and local limits.
- Conclude Constitutional path.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the CPI mean by "ye azadi jhooti hai"?
In December 1947 the party called Indian independence fake, saying the Nehru government served Anglo-American imperialism and feudal forces, a view that the Second Congress in 1948 turned into a programme of general revolution under the Ranadive line.
What was the Ranadive line?
It was the policy adopted at the party's Second Congress in Calcutta in February-March 1948 under general secretary B.T. Ranadive, which treated the national government as the main enemy and aimed at a people's democratic republic through revolution and armed insurgency.
Why did the communist insurgency fail?
It stayed local to Hyderabad and West Bengal, mass support was sporadic and conditional because people were not ready to reject the Congress so soon after independence, and the government acted with police action, a ban in Bengal and a security act for detention without trial.
When did the CPI change its strategy?
After criticism by Ajoy Ghosh, S.A. Dange and S.V. Ghate in September 1950, the Third Party Congress at Calcutta in October 1951 withdrew the Telangana struggle, formed an inclusive front, and had the party contest the general election of 1951-52.
How did the Zhdanov thesis influence Indian communists?
In September 1947 the Soviet Union announced the Zhdanov thesis as an answer to the Marshall Plan, encouraging more activism by communist parties, and with communist successes in China and South-East Asia it pushed the Indian party toward armed insurgency.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The CPI declared independence "fake" in December 1947.
The slogan was "ye azadi jhooti hai".
2 B.T. Ranadive was the general secretary associated with the 1948 line.
The line was adopted at the Second Congress in Calcutta.
3 The CPI joined the first general election after the Third Party Congress of 1951.
It withdrew the Telangana struggle.
4 The communist insurgency of 1948 spread to every part of India.
It stayed localised in Hyderabad and West Bengal.
5 The Zhdanov thesis was a plan of the United States.
It was a Soviet statement of September 1947.
Related Topics
Browse the full Modern History index