An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 9.6

Civil Disobedience Movement, Second Phase

Modern History › Indian National Movement – III (1930-1947) · Topic 9.6

The Civil Disobedience Movement was resumed on 3 January 1932 after the failure of the Second Round Table Conference, when Gandhi returned to find the Government taking harsh steps in the provinces. The Government used ordinances, arrests and a system of civil martial law, and the movement faded by April 1934. It was less widespread than the first phase but was carried on for a long period.

Share:
Civil Disobedience Movement, Second Phase - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Third RTC 17 November to 24 December 1932; Congress absent
  • White Paper March 1933; then a Joint Select Committee and the Act of 1935
  • Resumption Working Committee decided on 29 December 1931; Gandhi arrested 4 January 1932
  • Withdrawal April 1934
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Indian National Movement – III (1930-1947)

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 9.6 of the category “Indian National Movement – III (1930-1947)”. This page covers the second phase of the Civil Disobedience Movement and its evaluation as a whole. The first phase, the Dandi March and the Pact are described in the earlier pages of the macro. Previous topic: separate electorates Result No agreement Exam link…">Second Round Table Conference (1931).

What Happened During the Truce Period, March to December 1931?

Some activity during the truce kept alive the spirit of defiance. In the United Provinces the Congress led a movement for rent reduction and against summary evictions. In the North-West Frontier Province, severe repression was used against the Khudai Khidmatgars and the peasants they led who were agitating against brutal tax collection. In Bengal, harsh ordinances and mass detentions were used in the name of fighting terrorism, and in September 1931 there was a firing on political prisoners in Hijli Jail.

How Did the British Attitude Change?

Higher British officials drew their own lessons from the Delhi Pact, which they thought had raised the political prestige of the Congress and the morale of the people and weakened British prestige. After the second conference they were determined to reverse this trend. Their policy had three considerations.

Consideration Detail
1 Gandhi would not be allowed to build up the tempo of a mass movement again
2 The goodwill of the Congress was not needed, but the confidence of those who supported the British against it, such as government functionaries and loyalists, was essential
3 The national movement would not be allowed to consolidate itself in rural areas

The Gandhi-Irwin Pact is in Gandhi-Irwin Pact.

How Was Civil Disobedience Resumed?

After the second conference failed, the Congress Working Committee decided on 29 December 1931 to resume civil disobedience. Viceroy Willingdon refused to meet Gandhi on 31 December, and Gandhi was arrested on 4 January 1932.

The government issued a series of repressive ordinances that produced a virtual martial law under civilian control, called Civil Martial Law. Congress organisations at all levels were banned, activists, leaders and sympathisers arrested, properties confiscated and Gandhi’s ashrams occupied. Repression was particularly harsh on women, the press was gagged and nationalist literature banned.

What Was the People’s Response?

People responded with anger. Though unprepared, the response was massive: in the first four months about 80,000 satyagrahis, mostly the urban and rural poor, were jailed. Forms of protest included picketing of liquor and foreign cloth shops, illegal gatherings, non-violent demonstrations, celebrations of national days, symbolic flag hoistings, non-payment of chowkidara tax, salt satyagraha, forest law violations and a secret radio transmitter near Bombay. This phase coincided with upsurges in two princely states, Kashmir and Alwar.

It could not be sustained for long, because Gandhi and other leaders had no time to build up the tempo and the masses were unprepared. In April 1934 Gandhi decided to withdraw the movement. Though people had been cowed by superior force, they had not lost political faith in the Congress, and they had won freedom in their hearts. As an analytical point, the contrast with 1930 is clear: the first phase gave the Congress time to prepare in 1929 and a leader at liberty, while the second began when the government had taken the initiative, which meant that the movement was defending, not advancing. The overall assessment is in Evaluation of the Civil Disobedience Movement.

Was the Gandhi-Irwin Pact a Retreat?

Gandhi’s decision to suspend the movement as agreed in the Gandhi-Irwin Pact is argued not to have been a retreat. Mass movements are necessarily short-lived. The capacity of the masses to make sacrifices, unlike that of activists, is limited. And there were signs of exhaustion after September 1930, especially among the shopkeepers and merchants who had participated so enthusiastically.

The reception was mixed. The youth were disappointed, having wanted the world to end with a bang and not a whimper. The peasants of Gujarat were disappointed that their lands were not restored at once; they were returned only under the Congress ministry in the province. But many people were jubilant that the government had been made to regard the movement as significant and to treat its leader as an equal and sign a pact with him, and released political prisoners got a hero’s welcome. The pact is in Gandhi-Irwin Pact.

How Did It Differ From the Non-Cooperation Movement?

Aspect Civil Disobedience (1930)
Objective Complete independence, and not just remedying two specific wrongs and a vaguely worded swaraj
Methods Violation of law from the very beginning, and not just non-cooperation with foreign rule
Intelligentsia A decline in forms of protest by the intelligentsia, such as lawyers giving up practice and students leaving government schools for national institutions
Muslims Participation nowhere near that of the Khilafat Committee Congress approval Special session at Calcutta, September 1920 Nagpur session…">Non-Cooperation Movement
Labour No major labour upsurge coincided with the movement
Peasants and business Massive participation of peasants and business groups compensated for the decline of other features
Imprisonment The number of those imprisoned was about three times more
Organisation The Congress was organisationally stronger

The earlier movement is in Evaluation of the Non-Cooperation Khilafat Movement, and the participation in 1930 in Extent of Mass Participation and Impact of the Agitation.

What Did Contemporaries Say?

Gandhi told Lord Irwin that India was one vast prison-house and that he repudiated the law that made it so. Ellen Wilkinson called Gandhi the best policeman the British had in India. The English journalist Brailsford called the Dandi March the kindergarten stage of revolution, based on the notion that the King-Emperor could be unseated by boiling sea water in a kettle. These views run from admiration to sarcasm and are reported here as attributed opinions.

What Was the Overall Result?

The movement reached beyond the middle class and the cities. Peasants in the United Provinces, Bihar and Gujarat, merchants in Tamil Nadu and Punjab, tribals, workers and women all took part, and the Congress moved from a goal of dominion status to a demand for complete independence, which it did not alter afterwards. The government lost revenue, faced a boycott of its Assembly elections, and had to treat the Congress as an equal in the pact. The second phase, in 1932 to 1934, showed the limits: the government’s preparation and repression, and the movement’s lack of time to build, ended it in April 1934, as described in Third Round Table Conference and the Resumption of Civil Disobedience.

As an analytical point, the movement’s weaknesses and strengths were related: it relied on peasants and merchants, who joined in large numbers but could not sustain the effort beyond a year or so, and it moved forward by means of a symbolic act that the government could neither ignore nor easily suppress without a political cost. The balance is that the movement did not win independence or a clear constitutional concession, but it enlarged the mass base and the organisation of the Congress and placed complete independence at the centre of Indian politics. The Karachi programme that followed is in Karachi Congress Session, 1931.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Origin of the Act of 1935 Links the conferences to the White Paper and the Government of India Act
  • Second phase Resumption and withdrawal dates are Prelims facts
  • Change in government policy Shows how repression was planned

What Came Next?

Next topic: Third Round Table Conference (1932).

Key People and Terms

  • White Paper March 1933 publication of the conference recommendations
  • Joint Select Committee A British parliamentary committee that prepared the Bill
  • Civil Martial Law Virtual martial law under civilian control
  • Hijli Jail Site of a firing on prisoners in September 1931
  • Truce period The months from March to December 1931
  • Government of India Act of 1935 The Act that resulted from the conferences

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Third RTC: 17 November to 24 December 1932; Congress absent.
  • White Paper March 1933; draft Bill February 1935; Act 1935.
  • CWC decision 29 December 1931; Gandhi arrested 4 January 1932.
  • About 80,000 jailed in the first four months.
  • Movement withdrawn April 1934.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Third RTC and White Paper The conference gave recommendations; the White Paper published them
  • First phase and second phase 1930-31 versus 1932-34
  • Civil Martial Law and martial law Virtual martial law under civilian control

Memory Hook

A conference without Congress, a Paper in white, and a second struggle fought on the government’s ground.

Mains Angle

Questions ask about the second phase of the movement. These points add depth.

  • Government policy Prevent a rural mass movement
  • Response Large jailings, weak preparation
  • End Withdrawal in 1934

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Why was the second phase of the Civil Disobedience Movement less effective than the first?”

How to Answer

  1. Resumption Failure of the second conference.
  2. Government action Civil Martial Law.
  3. Response Large but unprepared.
  4. Conclude Withdrawal in 1934.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Indian National Movement – III (1930-1947). GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Third Round Table Conference?

The third conference was held from 17 November to 24 December 1932 and was not attended by the Congress or Gandhi. Little was achieved, but its recommendations went into a White Paper of March 1933 and led to the Government of India Act of 1935.

How did the Third Round Table Conference lead to the Government of India Act of 1935?

Its recommendations were published as a White Paper in March 1933 and debated in the British Parliament. A Joint Select Committee examined them and produced a draft Bill in February 1935, which was enacted as the Government of India Act in 1935.

When was civil disobedience resumed?

The Congress Working Committee decided to resume civil disobedience on 29 December 1931 after the second conference failed. Viceroy Willingdon refused to meet Gandhi on 31 December, and Gandhi was arrested on 4 January 1932.

What was Civil Martial Law?

It was the virtual martial law under civilian control created by a series of repressive ordinances in 1932. Congress bodies were banned, leaders arrested, property confiscated, ashrams occupied, the press gagged, and repression was especially harsh on women.

How did the second phase of civil disobedience end?

About 80,000 satyagrahis were jailed in the first four months, but Gandhi and others had no time to build up the tempo and the masses were unprepared. In April 1934 Gandhi withdrew the movement, though people had not lost faith in the Congress.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Third Round Table Conference was attended by Gandhi.
False

Neither the Congress nor Gandhi attended.

2 The White Paper of March 1933 contained the recommendations of the Round Table Conferences.
True

It led to the Government of India Act of 1935.

3 Civil disobedience was resumed after the Working Committee decision of 29 December 1931.
True

Gandhi was arrested on 4 January 1932.

4 Gandhi withdrew the second phase of civil disobedience in April 1934.
True

The masses had been unprepared.

5 The Third Round Table Conference ended in 1931.
False

It was held in November and December 1932.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Indian National Movement – III (1930-1947). UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: