Unconventional Tools: Quantitative Easing, Operation Twist, Forward Guidance, Helicopter Money, Negative Interest Rate Policy, Seigniorage
Indian Economy › Money, Monetary Policy and the RBI · Topic 4.15
Unconventional monetary policy tools are measures that central banks use when the policy interest rate is at or near zero and normal rate cuts cannot stimulate the economy. They include quantitative easing (creating bank reserves to buy long-term bonds), Operation Twist (selling short-term and buying long-term bonds at the same time), forward guidance (publicly committing to a future path of rates), helicopter money (direct money transfers financed by the central bank), and the negative interest rate policy. Seigniorage is the profit a central bank earns from issuing currency. India has used Operation Twist and government securities purchase programmes but has not used negative rates or helicopter money.
7 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Money, Monetary Policy and the RBI
At a Glance
- Used when Policy rate is near zero
- QE Central bank buys long-term bonds with new reserves
- Operation Twist Sell short bonds, buy long bonds
- India example G-SAP 2021 and Operation Twist 2019-20
- Seigniorage Profit from issuing currency
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Money, Monetary Policy and the RBI
Where Does It Fit?
The earlier topics covered the conventional tools of Policy Tools to Control Money Supply: Quantitative Tools (CRR, SLR, Repo, Reverse Repo, Bank Rate, MSF, LAF, OMO) and Qualitative Tools (Selective Credit Control, Moral Suasion). This topic covers what central banks do when those tools run out, and the next topic returns to lending rates in Indian banks. Previous topic: Monetary Policy Stances: Accommodative, Neutral, Hawkish, Dovish, Calibrated Tightening; Policy Corridor. Next topic: Lending Rate Regimes: Benchmark Prime Lending Rate (BPLR), Base Rate, MCLR, External Benchmark Lending Rate; Components of Base Rate System.
How Do Conventional and Unconventional Tools Compare?
| Feature | Conventional tools | Unconventional tools |
|---|---|---|
| Main instrument | Short-term policy rate, CRR, SLR, OMO | Large asset purchases, guidance, negative rates |
| When used | Normal times | Rate near zero, financial crisis, deflation risk |
| Target | Short-term interest rate | Long-term yields, credit spreads, expectations |
| Balance sheet | Little change | Central bank balance sheet expands sharply |
| Risk | Limited | Asset bubbles, exit difficulty, inflation later |
| Examples | Repo rate change in India | US Federal Reserve QE after 2008, ECB QE from 2015, Bank of Japan |
What Does Each Unconventional Tool Do?
| Tool | Meaning | Example | Used in India? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quantitative easing (QE) | Central bank creates reserves and buys long-term government or private bonds to lower long-term yields | US Federal Reserve from 2008, Bank of Japan from 2001, ECB from 2015 | Not called QE, but G-SAP of 2021 was similar in effect |
| Operation Twist | Simultaneous sale of short-term and purchase of long-term bonds, flattening the yield curve without adding net money | US Federal Reserve in 1961 and 2011-12 | Yes, RBI in December 2019 and in 2020-21 |
| Forward guidance | Public statement of the likely future path of the policy rate | Fed and ECB guidance on keeping rates low | Partly, through the stance of the MPC |
| Helicopter money | Money created and given directly to the public or Government | Idea of Milton Friedman, 1969 | No |
| Negative interest rate policy (NIRP) | Policy rate set below zero so banks pay to hold reserves | ECB from 2014, Switzerland, Sweden, Japan from 2016 | No |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Zero lower bound: The zero lower bound is the limit that a policy rate cannot go much below zero, because people could hold cash instead. At that point cutting the rate cannot help, and unconventional tools are tried
- QE steps: The central bank creates bank reserves electronically, buys bonds from banks and others, the bond price rises, the yield falls, and the lower long-term rates encourage borrowing and spending. Large-scale asset purchase is another name for it
- QE tapering: The reverse process is tapering, when purchases are reduced, and quantitative tightening, when the balance sheet shrinks. The taper tantrum of 2013 hit the rupee when the Fed hinted at tapering
- Operation Twist in India: In December 2019 the RBI bought long-term government bonds and sold short-term ones in matched amounts of Rs 10,000 crore, to bring down long-term yields. The idea is that it keeps liquidity unchanged but lowers long rates
- G-SAP: The Government Securities Acquisition Programme, announced in April 2021, was a commitment by the RBI to buy a set amount of government bonds in a period, starting at Rs 1 lakh crore for the first quarter. It gave certainty to bond buyers and kept yields in check. It is a type of large OMO covered in Open Market Operations; Sterilisation of Capital Flows; Market Stabilisation Scheme (MSS)
- Forward guidance: The RBI has used guidance such as saying that it will keep an accommodative stance as long as needed. The stance in Monetary Policy Stances: Accommodative, Neutral, Hawkish, Dovish, Calibrated Tightening; Policy Corridor works as mild guidance
- Helicopter money: Milton Friedman described it in 1969 as money dropped from a helicopter. It differs from QE because the money is not borrowed back and the central bank balance sheet is not matched by an asset. Its fiscal and inflation risks are large
- NIRP: Under negative rates the central bank charges banks for holding excess reserves. The European Central Bank ended it in 2022 and the Bank of Japan ended its negative rate in March 2024. The RBI has never used it
- Seigniorage: Seigniorage is the difference between the face value of money and the cost of making it. If a note costs Rs 4 to print and has a face value of Rs 500, the seigniorage is Rs 496. In India the surplus of the RBI is paid to the Government, for example Rs 2.69 lakh crore for 2024-25, paid in May 2025
- Seigniorage and inflation tax: When a government finances spending by printing money, the cost falls on all holders of money through higher prices. This is called an inflation tax. It is a reason why India ended automatic monetisation of the fiscal deficit
- Monetisation of deficit in India: The system of ad hoc treasury bills ended in 1997. The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2003 barred the RBI from buying government securities in the primary market from 1 April 2006. The RBI can still lend short term through Ways and Means Advances
- Spillovers to India: When the Fed or the ECB expands or shrinks its balance sheet, capital flows to emerging markets change, moving the rupee and bond yields. The RBI uses forex reserves and sterilisation to manage these flows
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Definitions: Match the tool to its description: QE, Operation Twist, forward guidance, helicopter money
- Operation Twist: Remember the simultaneous sale of short-term and purchase of long-term bonds
- India examples: Operation Twist and G-SAP were used, NIRP and helicopter money were not
- Seigniorage: Face value minus cost of production
- Common errors: Saying QE is an increase in the repo rate, or that Operation Twist raises money supply
As an analytical point, unconventional tools carry the risk of asset bubbles and of a hard exit. India, with its positive real rates and a managed inflation target, has used them only in a limited way, and its fiscal rule on monetisation guards against the worst misuse.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Terms One-line Prelims definitions
- India link Operation Twist and G-SAP
- Seigniorage Currency and dividend
What Came Next?
The next topic explains the lending rate regimes of Indian banks. Next topic: Lending Rate Regimes: Benchmark Prime Lending Rate (BPLR), Base Rate, MCLR, External Benchmark Lending Rate; Components of Base Rate System.
Key People and Terms
- QE Bond buying with new reserves
- Operation Twist Sell short, buy long
- Forward guidance Signalling future rates
- Helicopter money Direct money transfer
- NIRP Rates below zero
- Seigniorage Profit from issuing money
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- QE: buy long-term bonds.
- Operation Twist: sell short, buy long.
- Helicopter money: idea of Milton Friedman.
- RBI Operation Twist: December 2019.
- Seigniorage = face value minus cost.
Do Not Confuse With
- QE and Operation Twist New reserves versus a swap of maturities
- QE and helicopter money Asset purchase versus direct transfer
- Seigniorage and inflation tax Profit of the issuer versus cost to money holders
Memory Hook
QE buys long bonds, Twist swaps maturities, the helicopter gives, negative rates charge.
Mains Angle
Questions ask about the use of such tools and their risks. These points give a frame.
- Why Zero lower bound
- Risks Bubbles and spillovers
- India Limited use
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“What are unconventional monetary policy tools? Discuss their risks and their relevance for India.”
How to Answer
- Define Zero lower bound tools.
- Types QE, Twist, NIRP.
- Risks Bubbles, spillovers.
- India Limited use, G-SAP.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is quantitative easing?
Quantitative easing is a policy in which a central bank creates bank reserves electronically and uses them to buy long-term government or other bonds, which raises bond prices, lowers long-term yields and eases credit. It is used when the policy interest rate is near zero, as the US Federal Reserve did after 2008.
What is Operation Twist?
Operation Twist is a central bank operation in which it sells short-term government securities and buys long-term ones in equal amounts. It lowers long-term yields without changing the total money supply. The US Federal Reserve used it in 1961 and 2011-12, and the RBI used it in December 2019.
What is forward guidance?
Forward guidance is a central bank communicating how it expects the policy rate to move in future, such as promising to keep rates low until inflation or jobs data change. It shapes market expectations and long-term rates without any immediate action.
What is helicopter money?
Helicopter money is the idea, from Milton Friedman in 1969, that a central bank creates money and gives it directly to citizens or the Government, instead of lending it through banks. It aims to lift spending in a deep slump but carries high inflation and credibility risks. India has not used it.
What is negative interest rate policy?
Negative interest rate policy sets the central bank rate below zero so that commercial banks pay to hold reserves, which pushes them to lend. The ECB and Bank of Japan used it, with Japan ending it in March 2024. The RBI has never used it.
What is seigniorage?
Seigniorage is the profit that a government or central bank makes by issuing currency, equal to the face value of notes minus the cost of printing them. In India the RBI transfers its surplus to the Government each year, which was Rs 2.69 lakh crore for 2024-25.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 In Operation Twist the central bank sells short-term bonds and buys long-term bonds.
This flattens the yield curve.
2 Helicopter money was first suggested by Keynes.
It is associated with Milton Friedman, 1969.
3 The RBI has adopted negative interest rates.
India has never used negative rates.
4 Quantitative easing involves the central bank buying bonds with newly created reserves.
This lowers long-term yields.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index