Reform committees: Banking, Tax, PPP, Land
Indian Economy › Committees, Reports and Indices · Topic 23.10
Reform committees are expert panels whose reports set the direction for policy in banking, tax, infrastructure and land. A Mains answer evaluates their ideas, what was implemented and what remains. In banking, Narasimham (1991, 1998) led to lower SLR and CRR and capital adequacy norms, while Nachiket Mor produced payments banks in 2015 and Nayak the Bank Boards Bureau in 2016. In tax, the Chelliah Committee's VAT idea led to GST from 1 July 2017, and the Easwar report fed into the Income-tax Act, 2025 in force from 1 April 2026. In infrastructure, the Kelkar Committee (2015) sought to fix PPP and the Atanu Chakraborty Task Force listed projects worth Rs 111 lakh crore. In land, committees moved from ceilings (1971 guidelines) to leasing (Haque, 2016).
5 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Committees, Reports and Indices
At a Glance
- Banking Narasimham to Nayak
- Tax Chelliah to GST in 2017
- PPP Kelkar 2015, PPPs 3.0
- Land Ceilings to leasing
- GST 1 July 2017
- Income-tax Act, 2025 In force from 1 April 2026
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Committees, Reports and Indices
Where Does It Fit?
This is the Mains synthesis of Banking and Finance Committees: Narasimham (1991, 1998), Verma, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Ratan P. Watal (Digital Payments), Committee for MII, Deepak Mohanty (Financial Inclusion), Uday Kotak (Corporate Governance), Usha Thorat, B. Sivaraman, Dinesh Sharma, Naresh Chandra, Sahoo Committee, GAAR deferred three years…">Tax Committees: Kelkar, Chelliah, Shome, Easwar; FSLRC (Srikrishna); N.K. Singh (FRBM Review), Land Reform Committees: Dantwala, Bhargava, Hanumantha Rao, Swaminathan, Abhijit Sen and Infrastructure: Atanu Chakraborty (NIP); Vijay Kelkar (PPP). See Committee recommendations on MSP (e.g., Shanta Kumar, Swaminathan) for MSP committees. Previous topic: Committee recommendations on MSP (e.g., Shanta Kumar, Swaminathan). Next topic: plfs-annual-report-2025-rbi-report-on-state-finances-2025-26/" class="maargx-auto-link" data-preview="At a Glance Fiscal Health Index 2026 Released 11 March 2026, covers 2023-24 Top major State Odisha HDI loss to inequality 30.7…">Index and Report-based analytical use: Fiscal Health Index, HDI vs IHDI, PLFS Annual Report 2025, RBI Report on State Finances 2025-26.
What Was Recommended and What Was Done?
| Area | Committee and idea | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Banking | Narasimham 1991: cut SLR and CRR, 8 per cent capital adequacy, freer interest rates | Adopted, and norms are now standard |
| Banking | Narasimham 1998: 10 per cent capital adequacy by 2002, fewer and stronger banks, narrow banking | Capital norms and mergers followed, narrow banking was not adopted |
| Banking | Nachiket Mor 2014: payments banks, wholesale banks and universal account | Payments banks were licensed in 2015 |
| Banking | P.J. Nayak 2014: Bank Investment Company, Bank Boards Bureau | The Bureau was set up in 2016, but the investment company was not adopted |
| Tax | Chelliah 1991 to 1993: move towards VAT and lower rates | Led to state VAT in 2005 and GST from 1 July 2017 |
| Tax | Easwar 2015: simplify the 1961 Act and TDS | The Income-tax Act, 2025 replaced the 1961 Act from 1 April 2026 |
| PPP and land | Kelkar 2015: PPPs 3.0. Central Land Reforms Committee 1971: ceilings. Haque 2016: leasing | 1972 guidelines for ceilings, with a model leasing law offered to States |
How Should the Record Be Evaluated?
| Aspect | Analysis |
|---|---|
| Implementation gap | Technical reforms such as capital norms and GST were adopted, while politically harder ones such as the Bank Investment Company and narrow banking were not |
| Federal limits | Land is a State subject, so central committees give guidelines that States adopt unevenly, as in Committees on Land Reforms: Dantwala (1970), Bhargava (1974), Hanumantha Rao (1979), National Commission on Agriculture (1976), Swaminathan, Abhijit Sen |
| Time lag | Ideas can take decades to become law, as with the VAT idea of the 1990s and GST in 2017 |
| Evidence base | Committees rely on available data, so their ideas must be updated as conditions change |
| Governance | Consultation and public comment, as with the Kotak report, improve acceptance |
| Current reviews | The High-Level Committee on Banking for Viksit Bharat has a six-month tenure and is consulting stakeholders, as in Banking and Finance Committees: Narasimham (1991, 1998), Verma, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Ratan P. Watal (Digital Payments), Committee for MII, Deepak Mohanty (Financial Inclusion), Uday Kotak (Corporate Governance), Usha Thorat, B. Sivaraman, Dinesh Sharma, Naresh Chandra, Sahoo Committee |
| Way forward | Publish action-taken reports, set timelines and review implementation of past committees |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Also called: Reform committees are also called expert committees or task forces. An action-taken report states what was done on each recommendation
- Banking detail: The banking record is in Banking Sector Reforms: Narasimham Committees (1991, 1998), Verma Committee, Nachiket Mor, P.J. Nayak, Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act 2020; Mission Indradhanush
- Tax detail: The tax record is in Committees on Tax Reforms: Kelkar Task Force, Chelliah, Parthasarathi Shome, Easwar, Rangachary, Sahoo Committee (Participatory Notes / Black Money)
- PPP detail: The PPP record is in PPP: advantages; concession agreement; types; problems with PPP projects; Vijay Kelkar Committee on revisiting PPP; PPP and intergenerational equity; FDI and FII in investment model
- Land detail: The land record is in Committees on Land Reforms: Dantwala (1970), Bhargava (1974), Hanumantha Rao (1979), National Commission on Agriculture (1976), Swaminathan, Abhijit Sen
- Poverty groups: Poverty estimation groups are in Poverty Estimation Groups: Alagh, Lakdawala, Tendulkar, Rangarajan
- Answer structure: Pick two or three committees per area, say what was adopted, and end with a way forward
- Exam hint: Use the adopted versus not adopted split to show balance
- Common errors: Listing committees without saying what was implemented
- Another common error: Writing that the Chelliah Committee created GST
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Adopted: Capital norms, payments banks, GST
- Not adopted: Narrow banking, Bank Investment Company
- Land: Ceilings to leasing
- Gap: Politics and States
- Fix: Action-taken reports
As an analytical point, committees are good at setting direction but implementation depends on political will, federal coordination and legal change. A tracking system for recommendations would raise their value.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Ideas Direction
- Gap Implementation
- Fix Tracking
What Came Next?
The next Mains topic uses indices and reports analytically: Fiscal Health Index, HDI against IHDI, PLFS and RBI State Finances. Next topic: Index and Report-based analytical use: Fiscal Health Index, HDI vs IHDI, PLFS Annual Report 2025, RBI Report on State Finances 2025-26.
Key People and Terms
- Task force Short-term expert group
- Action-taken report Report on follow-up
- GST Goods and Services Tax
- PPP Public Private Partnership
- Narrow banking Safe-assets-only banking
- Ceiling Land holding limit
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- GST: 1 July 2017.
- Income-tax Act 2025: 1 April 2026.
- Payments banks: 2015.
- Bank Boards Bureau: 2016.
- Kelkar PPP: 2015.
Do Not Confuse With
- Recommended and adopted Idea in a report versus action by government
- Task force and commission Short-term panel versus broader body
- Guideline and law Central advice versus State legislation
Memory Hook
Reports point the way, Parliament and States must walk it.
Mains Angle
Mains rewards evaluation of outcomes, not only a list of committees.
- Record Adopted or not
- Reasons Politics and States
- Fix Tracking
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Evaluate the role of expert committees in economic reforms in India with examples from banking, tax, infrastructure and land.”
How to Answer
- Intro Role of committees.
- Examples Four areas.
- Evaluation Adopted and gaps.
- Conclude Tracking.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What role do expert committees play in economic reforms?
Expert committees study a problem, consult stakeholders and recommend policy changes, as the Narasimham Committees did for banking and the Chelliah Committee did for tax, giving governments a technical base for reforms that are then implemented through laws, rules and executive decisions.
Which committee recommendations were implemented in banking?
Narasimham's capital adequacy and reserve ratio cuts were adopted, the Nachiket Mor idea of payments banks led to licences in 2015 and the Nayak idea of a Bank Boards Bureau was set up in 2016, while narrow banking and the Bank Investment Company were not adopted.
How did tax committee ideas lead to GST?
The Chelliah Committee of 1991 to 1993 suggested moving excise towards a Value Added Tax, which led to state VAT in 2005 and then to the Goods and Services Tax from 1 July 2017, showing a long gap between the recommendation and the final reform.
What did the Kelkar Committee recommend on PPP?
The Kelkar Committee, reporting on 19 November 2015, recommended reviewing the Model Concession Agreement, faster dispute resolution, a project review committee for stressed projects and clearer risk sharing, under a vision called PPPs 3.0, to fix problems in public private partnership projects.
How have land reform ideas changed over time?
Early committees such as the Kumarappa Committee in 1949 and the Central Land Reforms Committee in 1971 focused on ceilings and redistribution, while later work such as the Haque Committee in 2016 focused on legalising land leasing and titles to improve security and productivity.
Why are many committee recommendations not implemented?
Recommendations may not be implemented because they need legal change, face political or institutional resistance, depend on State action in subjects like land, or become outdated, which is why tracking follow-up through action-taken reports is suggested.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 GST began on 1 July 2017.
The VAT idea came from the Chelliah Committee.
2 The Bank Investment Company was set up on the Nayak Committee's advice.
The Bank Boards Bureau was set up, but the investment company was not.
3 Payments banks were recommended by the Nachiket Mor Committee.
They were licensed in 2015.
4 The Kelkar Committee on PPP described a vision called PPPs 3.0.
It reported in 2015.
5 Land reform committees are binding on States.
Land is a State subject, so guidelines are adopted by States.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index