Land as a State Subject: Union, State, Concurrent Lists (Seventh Schedule); Model Contract Farming Act 2018
Indian Economy › Land Reforms and Agrarian Structure · Topic 13.7
Land is a State subject in India. Under the Seventh Schedule, Entry 18 of the State List covers land, land tenures and the landlord and tenant relation, Entry 45 covers land revenue and land records, and Entry 14 covers agriculture. Transfer of property other than agricultural land, registration of deeds and acquisition of property are in the Concurrent List (Entries 6 and 42). Parliament therefore cannot enact a national ceiling or tenancy law, so the Centre issues model laws, such as the Model Agricultural Produce and Livestock Contract Farming and Services (Promotion and Facilitation) Act, 2018, released on 22 May 2018, for States to adopt.
7 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Land Reforms and Agrarian Structure
At a Glance
- State List Entry 18 land and tenures, Entry 45 land revenue, Entry 14 agriculture
- Concurrent List Entry 6 transfer of non-agricultural property and registration, Entry 42 acquisition
- Model Act released 22 May 2018
- Draft committee Under Ashok Dalwai, set up February 2017
- Land rule in the Model Act No title or possession passes to the sponsor
- Legal force Only when a State adopts it
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Land Reforms and Agrarian Structure
Where Does It Fit?
This topic gives the constitutional reason behind the State-wise variation described in Land Reforms: Abolition of Zamindari System, Tenancy Reforms, Fixing Ceiling on Landholdings, Land Consolidation; Bhoodan and Gramdan Movements and Achievements of Land Reforms in Post-Independent India. Land use policies are in National Land Use Policy (1988); Urban Land Policy (2007); Land Pooling Policy; National Land Monetisation Corporation, and the Mains discussion of hurdles, where State control matters, is in Hurdles in land reforms in India; way forward. Contract farming is also compared in Farming Systems: Wetland Farming, Dry Land Farming, Rain-Fed Farming, Mixed Farming, Integrated Farming System; ZBNF; PKVY Launched 2015 First organic state Sikkim, 2016…">Organic Farming; Cluster Farming / Synchronised Operations; Contract Farming and Essential Commodities Act; Contract Farming; Agricultural Produce and Livestock Marketing Acts (APLM Act 2017). Previous topic: National Land Use Policy (1988); Urban Land Policy (2007); Land Pooling Policy; National Land Monetisation Corporation. Next topic: Land reforms: introduction and achievements.
Which Entries of the Seventh Schedule Deal With Land?
| List and entry | Subject | Why it matters for land |
|---|---|---|
| State List, Entry 14 | Agriculture, including agricultural education and research; protection against pests and prevention of plant diseases | Gives States the main power over farming |
| State List, Entry 18 | Land, rights in or over land, land tenures including the relation of landlord and tenant, collection of rents, transfer and alienation of agricultural land, land improvement and agricultural loans, colonization | The base for zamindari abolition, tenancy, ceiling and consolidation laws |
| State List, Entry 45 | Land revenue, including assessment and collection, the maintenance of land records, survey for revenue purposes and records of rights, and alienation of revenues | Gives States control of land records |
| State List, Entry 46 and Entry 48 | Taxes on agricultural income, and estate duty in respect of agricultural land | Tax on farm income and land inheritance is a State power |
| Concurrent List, Entry 6 | Transfer of property other than agricultural land; registration of deeds and documents | Covers the Registration Act, 1908 for deeds, with agricultural land transfers in Entry 18 |
| Concurrent List, Entry 7 | Contracts, including partnership, agency and special forms, but not contracts relating to agricultural land | Contracts about agricultural land are therefore left to States |
| Concurrent List, Entry 20 | Economic and social planning | Allows central schemes on land records and watersheds |
| Concurrent List, Entry 42 | Acquisition and requisitioning of property | Basis for the central land acquisition law, the 2013 Act that replaced the Act of 1894 |
What Does the Model Contract Farming Act, 2018 Provide?
| Feature | Provision |
|---|---|
| Full title | The Model Agricultural Produce and Livestock Contract Farming and Services (Promotion and Facilitation) Act, 2018, released as a model for States and Union Territories |
| Origin | A committee under Ashok Dalwai was constituted in February 2017. A first draft was published in December 2017, a revised draft in February 2018, and the final model on 22 May 2018 |
| Land rule | No right, title, ownership or possession of land is transferred or vested in the contract farming sponsor |
| Scope | Crops, livestock, dairy and poultry, and services contracts from pre-production to post-harvest marketing |
| Market link | Contract farming and service contracts are taken out of the State APMC Acts |
| Dispute settlement | A dispute settlement authority at the lowest possible level, and a contract farming facilitation group at village or panchayat level |
| Insurance | Contracted produce is covered under crop and livestock insurance schemes |
| Buyer duty | The buyer must purchase the entire pre-agreed quantity |
| Character | Promotional and facilitative, not regulatory |
| Adoption | States must pass it through their legislatures and may modify any provision. At a May 2018 meeting State Agriculture Marketing Ministers agreed to adopt it |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Also called: The Model Contract Farming Act is also called the State and Union Territory Agricultural Produce and Livestock Contract Farming and Services Act, 2018, or the Model Contract Farming Act. The Seventh Schedule has three lists: Union List, State List and Concurrent List
- Why land is a State matter: The Constitution places land tenures, land revenue and agriculture in the State List, so ceilings, tenancy and records are decided by each State legislature. The Centre uses funding, model laws and the Concurrent List to guide them
- Model Act versus law: A model Act has no force until a State enacts it. The 2018 model was a draft Bill prepared by the Centre
- Land stays with the farmer: The key land safeguard is that the sponsor gets no title or possession. The sponsor buys produce or provides services, and the farmer remains the owner
- Link to APMC: The model brought contract farming outside APMC regulation, with an estimated 5 to 10 per cent saving in buyer transaction costs reported at its release
- 2020 central law: The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Act, 2020 was a central law on the same theme. The three farm laws were repealed in 2021, so the 2018 model remains the template for States
- Acquisition law: Land acquisition is on the Concurrent List. The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 replaced the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
- Registration: Registration of deeds is a Concurrent List matter, which is why the Registration Act, 1908 is a central law that States amend
- Why a common national land law is hard: Ceilings, tenures and soil types differ by State. A parliamentary law on tenancy would need either a constitutional amendment or a resolution of States under Article 252
- Practical effect: The States with strong reform records, such as West Bengal and Kerala, did so through their own Acts, and this is why outcomes in Success of land reforms and factors responsible vary so widely by State
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Entry numbers: Entry 18 and Entry 45 of the State List, Entry 6, 7 and 42 of the Concurrent List
- List type: land is in the State List, acquisition in the Concurrent List
- Model Act date: released on 22 May 2018
- Land safeguard: no title or possession passes to the sponsor
- Common error: saying that Parliament made the Model Contract Farming Act binding on all States
As an analytical point, State control lets reforms fit local conditions, but it also means uneven progress and weak national coordination. Model laws are a soft tool that works only where States choose to adopt them.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Lists Entries 18, 45 and 42
- Federalism State legislation
- Model Act No land transfer
What Came Next?
The next topic begins the Mains section with the introduction and achievements of land reforms. Next topic: Land reforms: introduction and achievements.
Key People and Terms
- State List Subjects for States
- Concurrent List Shared subjects
- Land revenue Tax and records on land
- Sponsor Buyer in contract farming
- Model Act Template for States
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Land: Entry 18, State List.
- Land revenue and records: Entry 45, State List.
- Acquisition: Entry 42, Concurrent List.
- Model Contract Farming Act released: 22 May 2018.
- Sponsor gets no title or possession.
Do Not Confuse With
- Entry 18 and Entry 45 Land and tenures versus land revenue and records
- State List and Concurrent List Land tenures versus acquisition and non-agricultural property transfer
- Model Contract Farming Act 2018 and the 2020 central Act Model for States versus a central statute that was later repealed
Memory Hook
Eighteen for land, forty-five for records, forty-two for acquisition, and contracts leave the title with the farmer.
Mains Angle
Questions on federalism and land need entry numbers and the logic of model laws.
- Constitution Entries 14, 18, 45
- Concurrent Entries 6 and 42
- Model laws Adoption by States
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Why is land a State subject and what are the implications for national land reform? Discuss the role of model laws such as the Model Contract Farming Act, 2018.”
How to Answer
- Define Seventh Schedule entries on land.
- Implications State variation and slow reform.
- Model laws Contract farming and leasing models.
- Conclusion Co-operative federalism with incentives.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
Is land a State subject or a Union subject in India?
Land is a State subject. Entry 18 of the State List covers land, rights in land, land tenures and the relation of landlord and tenant, and Entry 45 covers land revenue and land records. Acquisition of property and registration of deeds are on the Concurrent List, so both levels can legislate there.
Which entry of the Seventh Schedule deals with land acquisition?
Entry 42 of the Concurrent List covers acquisition and requisitioning of property. The central Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 was made under this field and replaced the Land Acquisition Act of 1894. States may also legislate on acquisition within this list.
What is the Model Contract Farming Act, 2018?
It is the Model Agricultural Produce and Livestock Contract Farming and Services (Promotion and Facilitation) Act, 2018, released by the Centre on 22 May 2018 as a template for States. It supports written contracts between farmers and sponsors and takes contract farming outside the APMC Acts. A State must enact it for it to apply.
Does contract farming transfer land ownership to the buyer?
No. Under the Model Contract Farming Act, 2018, no right, title, ownership or possession of land is transferred or vested in the contract farming sponsor. The sponsor buys the agreed produce or provides services, and the farmer remains the owner. The Act also requires the buyer to purchase the whole agreed quantity.
Why can Parliament not pass a single land reform law for India?
Land tenures, land revenue and agriculture fall in the State List, so only State legislatures can make laws on ceilings, tenancy and land records. The Centre can advise through model laws and fund programmes under the Concurrent List planning entry, but adoption is a State decision.
Who drafted the Model Contract Farming Act?
A committee under Ashok Dalwai, constituted in February 2017 by the Union Agriculture Minister, drafted it. A first draft was published for comment in December 2017 and a revised draft in February 2018. The final model was released on 22 May 2018 and State agriculture marketing ministers agreed to adopt it.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 Entry 18 of the State List deals with land and land tenures.
Entry 45 deals with land revenue and records.
2 Acquisition and requisitioning of property is in the Union List.
It is Entry 42 of the Concurrent List.
3 Under the Model Contract Farming Act, 2018 the sponsor acquires possession of the land.
No title, ownership or possession is transferred.
4 The Model Contract Farming Act applies automatically in all States.
States must adopt it through their legislatures.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index