Achievements of Land Reforms in Post-Independent India
Indian Economy › Land Reforms and Agrarian Structure · Topic 13.2
The achievements of land reforms in post-independent India are the abolition of intermediaries, which brought about 2 crore tenants into direct relation with the State, and the redistribution of ceiling-surplus land. As per a Lok Sabha reply of 2015, States had declared 68.45 lakh acres surplus, taken possession of 61.48 lakh acres and distributed 50.94 lakh acres to 57.25 lakh beneficiaries. Tenancy reform worked best in West Bengal and Kerala, and consolidation worked best in Punjab and Haryana. Ceilings and tenancy reform achieved far less than intermediary abolition.
6 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Land Reforms and Agrarian Structure
At a Glance
- Tenants reaching the State About 2 crore after abolition of intermediaries
- Declared surplus 68.45 lakh acres (Lok Sabha, 2015)
- Taken possession 61.48 lakh acres
- Distributed 50.94 lakh acres to 57.25 lakh beneficiaries
- Distributed as share of declared About 74.4 per cent
- Best tenancy record West Bengal and Kerala
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Land Reforms and Agrarian Structure
Where Does It Fit?
This topic scores the measures introduced in Land Reforms: Abolition of Zamindari System, Tenancy Reforms, Fixing Ceiling on Landholdings, Land Consolidation; Bhoodan and Gramdan Movements. Committees on Land Reforms: Dantwala (1970), Bhargava (1974), Hanumantha Rao (1979), National Commission on Agriculture (1976), Swaminathan, Abhijit Sen covers the committees that reviewed the results, and Land reforms: introduction and achievements and Success of land reforms and factors responsible turn the scorecard into Mains analysis. Previous topic: Land Reforms: Abolition of Zamindari System, Tenancy Reforms, Fixing Ceiling on Landholdings, Land Consolidation; Bhoodan and Gramdan Movements. Next topic: Land Titling Systems in India; Land Records Digitisation: DILRMP, Bhu-Aadhaar (ULPIN), SVAMITVA Scheme.
What Are the Achievements of Land Reforms, Component by Component?
| Component | Achievement | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Abolition of intermediaries | Zamindari, jagirdari and inamdari tenures were abolished by State laws. About 2 crore tenants came into direct relation with the State or gained ownership | The most successful component |
| Tenancy reform | Rent regulation, security of tenure and ownership rights in law. West Bengal’s Operation Barga, launched in 1978, recorded more than a million sharecroppers | Strong in West Bengal and Kerala, patchy elsewhere |
| Ceiling and surplus land | 68.45 lakh acres declared surplus, 61.48 lakh acres taken, 50.94 lakh acres distributed to 57.25 lakh beneficiaries (Lok Sabha reply, 2015) | Modest against the need, with a large gap between declared and distributed land |
| Consolidation of holdings | Compulsory consolidation in Punjab and Haryana gave compact plots and helped irrigation and mechanisation | Good in a few States, partial elsewhere |
| Bhoodan and Gramdan | Voluntary land gifts after 1951 and village gifts after 1952 | Limited and often disputed in records |
How Much of the Ceiling-Surplus Land Reached the Poor?
| Stage | Figure and calculation |
|---|---|
| Declared surplus | 68.45 lakh acres, about 27.7 lakh hectares |
| Taken possession | 61.48 lakh acres, which is 61.48 / 68.45 = 89.8 per cent of declared land. The remaining 6.97 lakh acres was declared but not taken |
| Distributed | 50.94 lakh acres, which is 50.94 / 61.48 = 82.9 per cent of the land taken and 50.94 / 68.45 = 74.4 per cent of the land declared |
| Gap between declared and distributed | 68.45 minus 50.94 = 17.51 lakh acres, one quarter of the declared surplus |
| Average per beneficiary | 50.94 lakh acres divided by 57.25 lakh beneficiaries = about 0.89 acre each, which is a small plot and explains why such grants seldom lifted families out of poverty on their own |
| Share of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes | Of the distributed land 19.04 lakh acres went to Scheduled Castes and 7.83 lakh acres to Scheduled Tribes, together 26.87 lakh acres or about 52.7 per cent of the land distributed |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Source of the figures: The figures above are from a reply of the Ministry of Rural Development in the Lok Sabha in February 2015. Earlier replies gave similar totals, for example 68.48 lakh acres declared surplus and 50.93 lakh acres distributed to 57.38 lakh beneficiaries as of 30 September 2013
- Why distribution lags: Land is held up by litigation, is reserved for public purposes, or is unfit for cultivation. A Rajya Sabha reply of 1986 noted 14.88 lakh acres in litigation at that time
- Ceiling levels: The July 1972 guidelines set 10 to 18 acres for irrigated double-cropped land, 27 acres for single-cropped land and 54 acres for inferior dry land. The ceiling unit was the family
- Operation Barga: Launched in West Bengal in 1978 and given legal backing in 1979 and 1980. It registered sharecroppers and secured their tenure. Studies of its effect on productivity are mixed, and some find a positive effect
- Kerala: Kerala is regarded as having carried out one of the most extensive programmes of land, tenancy and agrarian wage reform in the country
- Farm size outcome: Average operational holding fell from 1.15 hectares in 2010-11 to 1.08 hectares in 2015-16, a fall of 6.1 per cent, and there were about 14.6 crore operational holdings. Small and marginal holdings together were about 86 per cent of the total, as measured in Agriculture Census; Operational Holding, Operated Area, Size Classes and Size Groups of Holdings (Marginal, Small, Semi-Medium, Medium, Large)
- Landlessness: The 77th round of the National Sample Survey found 8.2 per cent of rural households landless in 2019, against 7.4 per cent in 2013, using a threshold of less than 0.002 hectare
- Land tenancy today: Informal and oral leases persist because many State laws restrict leasing. Models for legal leasing are discussed in Land reforms and agricultural productivity; land ceiling policy; land titling systems
- Research evidence: A study by Timothy Besley and Robin Burgess (Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2000) using data for 16 main States from 1958 to 1992 found that land reforms were associated with poverty reduction
- What was not achieved: Rights of women over land, recognition of sharecroppers outside a few States and complete land records. Records are the subject of Land Titling Systems in India; Land Records Digitisation: DILRMP, Bhu-Aadhaar (ULPIN), SVAMITVA Scheme
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Figures asked: 68.45 lakh acres declared, 61.48 lakh acres taken, 50.94 lakh acres distributed to 57.25 lakh beneficiaries
- Most successful measure: abolition of intermediaries
- Region-wise: Operation Barga in West Bengal, extensive reform in Kerala, compulsory consolidation in Punjab and Haryana
- Percent calculations: distributed over declared is about 74 per cent, and over taken is about 83 per cent
- Common error: saying that all the declared surplus land was distributed
As an analytical point, the scorecard shows that the reforms that needed only a change in law succeeded, and those that needed local enforcement against powerful landowners fell short. The numbers show reach, not depth, since average grants were under one acre.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Intermediaries About 2 crore tenants
- Surplus land 50.94 lakh acres distributed
- Regions West Bengal, Kerala, Punjab
What Came Next?
The next topic covers land titling systems and the digitisation of land records. Next topic: Land Titling Systems in India; Land Records Digitisation: DILRMP, Bhu-Aadhaar (ULPIN), SVAMITVA Scheme.
Key People and Terms
- Declared surplus Land found above the ceiling
- Taken possession Land the State actually took
- Distributed Land allotted to beneficiaries
- Bargadar Sharecropper in West Bengal
- Operation Barga Sharecropper registration drive
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Declared surplus: 68.45 lakh acres.
- Distributed: 50.94 lakh acres to 57.25 lakh beneficiaries.
- Distributed over declared: 74.4 per cent.
- Operation Barga: 1978, West Bengal.
- Average holding 1.08 hectares (2015-16).
Do Not Confuse With
- Declared surplus and distributed land Land found above the ceiling versus land actually given out
- Operation Barga and Bhoodan State registration of sharecroppers versus voluntary gifts of land
- Achievements and outcomes Acres moved versus change in poverty and productivity
Memory Hook
Declare, take, give: 68, 61 and 51 lakh acres.
Mains Angle
Questions ask for an assessment of results. Lead with the funnel from declared to distributed land.
- Reach 2 crore tenants, 57 lakh beneficiaries
- Gap 17.51 lakh acres undistributed
- Region Uneven by State
- Depth Small grants
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Evaluate the achievements of land reforms in India since independence and explain why the results were uneven.”
How to Answer
- Intro Four components and their aim.
- Achievements Intermediaries, surplus land, Barga, consolidation.
- Gap Declared versus distributed, with percentages.
- Conclusion Reach without depth.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main achievements of land reforms in India?
The main achievements are the abolition of intermediaries, which brought about 2 crore tenants into direct relation with the State, and the redistribution of ceiling-surplus land to 57.25 lakh beneficiaries. West Bengal's Operation Barga and Kerala's reforms are cited for tenancy reform, and Punjab and Haryana for consolidation.
How much surplus land has been distributed in India?
As per a Lok Sabha reply of February 2015, States declared 68.45 lakh acres surplus, took possession of 61.48 lakh acres and distributed 50.94 lakh acres to 57.25 lakh beneficiaries. That is about 74.4 per cent of the declared land and an average of 0.89 acre per beneficiary.
Which land reform measure was most successful in India?
Abolition of intermediaries was the most successful measure, because it needed only State legislation and removed the zamindari and similar tenures across the country. Tenancy reform and ceilings were far less effective, since they needed enforcement against local landholders and faced exemptions, litigation and weak records.
What was Operation Barga?
Operation Barga was a programme launched in West Bengal in 1978 by the Left Front government to record the names of sharecroppers, called bargadars, and give them secure, heritable tenure. It recorded more than a million sharecroppers and is regarded as the most prominent administrative tenancy reform in India.
Why was surplus land not fully distributed?
Of 68.45 lakh acres declared surplus, 17.51 lakh acres were not distributed as of the 2015 Lok Sabha reply. Reasons include litigation, land reserved for public purposes, land unfit for cultivation, and 6.97 lakh acres that were declared but never taken into possession.
What is the average landholding size in India?
The average operational holding was 1.08 hectares in 2015-16, down 6.1 per cent from 1.15 hectares in 2010-11, in the Agriculture Census, which counted about 14.6 crore holdings. Small and marginal holdings below 2 hectares made up about 86 per cent of all holdings.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 Abolition of intermediaries was the most widely implemented component of land reform.
About 2 crore tenants came into direct relation with the State.
2 All ceiling-surplus land declared by States has been distributed.
About 17.51 lakh acres of declared land had not been distributed as of 2015.
3 Operation Barga was launched in Kerala.
It was launched in West Bengal in 1978.
4 Consolidation of holdings was compulsory in Punjab and Haryana.
Other States mostly used voluntary consolidation.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index