An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 2.10

GDP and Welfare; Green GDP; Green Accounting; Gross National Happiness Index; Alternatives to GDP

Indian Economy › National Income, Economic Growth and Measurement · Topic 2.10

GDP measures the market value of output, but it is not a direct measure of welfare, because it ignores unpaid work, income distribution, leisure, and damage to the environment. Green GDP adjusts GDP by subtracting the depreciation of natural capital, that is resource depletion and environmental degradation, and green accounting is the system of recording these costs, as in the UN System of Environmental-Economic Accounting (SEEA). Bhutan's Gross National Happiness (GNH) index measures well-being using nine domains. Other alternatives to GDP include the Human Development Index, the Genuine Progress Indicator and the Inclusive Wealth Index.

Share:
GDP and Welfare; Green GDP; Green Accounting; Gross National Happiness Index; Alternatives to GDP - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • GDP limit Output, not welfare
  • Green GDP GDP minus natural capital depreciation
  • Green accounting SEEA of the United Nations
  • GNH Bhutan, nine domains
  • Other measures HDI, GPI, Inclusive Wealth Index
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: National Income, Economic Growth and Measurement

Where Does It Fit?

This closing topic of the national income set asks what GDP and its relatives cannot tell us. It builds on Per Capita Income; Purchasing Power Parity (PPP), which also gives only an average. The analytical treatment is in Alternatives to GDP calculation. Previous topic: Per Capita Income; Purchasing Power Parity (PPP). Next topic: Lorenz Curve; Gini Coefficient; Palma Ratio; Kuznets Curve; Phillips Curve (Philip’s Curve); Laffer Curve.

Why Is GDP Not a Measure of Welfare?

Gap in GDP Why it matters Example
Unpaid work is excluded Household work and care work are not sold in markets A homemaker’s work adds nothing to GDP, but hiring a cook does
Distribution ignored The average hides inequality Two countries with the same GDP can have very different shares for the poor
Environmental damage not deducted Depletion of forests, water and minerals is not subtracted Cutting a forest adds to GDP but loses a natural asset
Defensive spending is counted Spending to repair harm adds to GDP Medical costs of air pollution raise GDP
Quality of life excluded Leisure, health, safety and freedom are not priced Longer working hours raise GDP but lower leisure
Informal and illegal activity missed Much of it is not recorded Street vending and domestic production are partly missed
Composition is ignored GDP does not distinguish useful from harmful output Spending on pollution cleanup and on schools both count

What Are the Main Alternatives to GDP?

Measure Idea Key facts
Green GDP / Green NDP GDP less depreciation of produced capital and of natural capital Needs a value for resource depletion and environmental degradation
Gross National Happiness (GNH) Well-being of the people as the goal of policy Bhutan, idea coined in 1972 by King Jigme Singye Wangchuck. Four pillars: good governance, sustainable socio-economic development, cultural preservation and environmental conservation. Nine domains, including psychological well-being, health, education, time use, living standards, cultural diversity, community vitality, good governance and ecological diversity
Human Development Index (HDI) Health, education and income UNDP, started in 1990 by Mahbub ul Haq with Amartya Sen. Uses life expectancy, mean and expected years of schooling, and GNI per capita at PPP
Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI) Adjusts personal consumption for inequality, costs of crime and pollution, and adds value of household work Evolved from the Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare of Daly and Cobb, 1989
Inclusive Wealth Index Wealth of produced, human and natural capital Produced by UNEP with partners, and measures whether wealth per person is sustained
NITI Aayog Method Alkire-Foster, with UNDP and OPHI Indicators 12 across 3 dimensions Baseline (NFHS-4) 25.01 per cent…">Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) Deprivations in health, education and living standards UNDP and OPHI, since 2010, also adapted by NITI Aayog for India
OECD Better Life Index Eleven topics of well-being Launched in 2011, includes housing, jobs, health, life satisfaction and safety
World Happiness Report Life evaluation from surveys Based on the Gallup World Poll, uses the Cantril ladder, published each year since 2012

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Origin of the idea: Simon Kuznets produced the first national income estimates for the United States in the 1930s and warned that national income was not a measure of welfare. The point remains the basis of the Beyond GDP debate
  • Green GDP formula: Green NDP = GDP – depreciation of produced capital – depreciation of natural capital. Natural capital depreciation covers resource depletion and costs of environmental degradation
  • Worked example: Take GDP of Rs 1,000 crore, depreciation of machines and buildings Rs 100 crore, so NDP is Rs 900 crore. If the depletion of forests, minerals and groundwater and the damage from pollution amount to Rs 60 crore, Green NDP = 900 – 60 = Rs 840 crore. Treating natural capital as a cost lowers the measure by 6.7 per cent of NDP
  • Green accounting: Also called environmental accounting or green national accounting. The UN Statistical Commission adopted the System of Environmental-Economic Accounting (SEEA) Central Framework as an international standard in 2012, and the SEEA Ecosystem Accounting in 2021. It records stocks and flows of natural assets such as land, water, forests and minerals next to the economic accounts
  • Indian efforts: An expert group headed by Sir Partha Dasgupta studied green national accounting for India. MoSPI publishes EnviStats India, which includes statistics on environmental and natural resource accounts. India has not made a headline Green GDP figure, as in Economy and Environment; Environment Taxes (Carbon Tax); Green Accounting; Sustainability in the 12th Plan
  • Why green GDP is hard: Valuing a forest, a river or clean air needs assumptions, and different methods give different numbers. Hence most countries publish satellite accounts and not one headline green GDP
  • GNH index method: Bhutan surveys people on domains and finds those with sufficiency in at least a set share of indicators, using the Alkire-Foster method to group people as unhappy, narrowly happy, extensively happy and deeply happy. The counts of indicators vary by survey round, with 33 indicators in the standard index
  • HDI in India: The Human Development Report 2025 places India at 130th among 193 countries with an HDI of 0.685, in the medium human development category. HDI is explained further in Growth Indicators and Developmental Indicators; Physical Quality of Life Index (PQLI); Human Development Index (HDI); Millennium Development Goals (MDGs)
  • Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi Commission: Set up by France in 2008 and reporting in 2009, it recommended shifting emphasis from production to well-being, and to measure household income, consumption, wealth and sustainability
  • UN position: The Pact for the Future adopted in September 2024 called for measures of progress that go beyond GDP, and the 2025 System of National Accounts includes more on well-being and sustainability
  • Defence of GDP: GDP remains the best measure of the size of the market economy. It is timely, comparable across countries and linked to jobs, tax revenue and fiscal ratios, so it is a good measure of output but a poor measure of welfare
  • India data point: In 2025-26 India’s GDP was Rs 346.36 lakh crore and per capita NNI Rs 2,08,090, but these averages say little about distribution, health or environment, which is why India tracks many other indicators beside them

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Green GDP: GDP minus depreciation of natural capital
  2. GNH: Bhutan, based on nine domains and four pillars
  3. SEEA: UN framework for environmental-economic accounting
  4. HDI: Three dimensions: health, education and income
  5. Common errors: Saying that GNH is a measure of income, or that India publishes an official green GDP

As an analytical point, GDP and well-being measures are complements and not rivals. GDP tells how much is produced, while the broader indicators tell whether production is shared, healthy and sustainable, which is the aim of inclusive and sustainable growth.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Limits GDP and welfare gap
  • Green Green GDP and SEEA
  • Alternatives GNH, HDI, GPI

What Came Next?

The next topic covers inequality and trade-off curves such as the Lorenz curve and the Gini coefficient. Next topic: Lorenz Curve; Gini Coefficient; Palma Ratio; Kuznets Curve; Phillips Curve (Philip’s Curve); Laffer Curve.

Key People and Terms

  • Green GDP GDP net of natural capital loss
  • SEEA Environmental-economic accounting
  • GNH Gross National Happiness
  • GPI Genuine Progress Indicator
  • Natural capital Forests, water, minerals
  • Beyond GDP Wider progress measures

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Green NDP = GDP – depreciation of produced and natural capital.
  • GNH: Bhutan, nine domains.
  • SEEA adopted as standard in 2012.
  • HDI started in 1990.
  • GDP excludes unpaid work and environmental loss.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Green GDP and GDP Net of natural capital loss versus gross output
  • GNH and HDI Happiness versus health, education, income
  • Green accounting and green GDP System of accounts versus one headline number

Memory Hook

GDP counts what is made, green GDP counts what is lost, GNH counts how people feel.

Mains Angle

Questions ask why GDP falls short and which alternatives are better. These points give a frame.

  • Limits Welfare gaps in GDP
  • Alternatives Green GDP, GNH, HDI
  • India Data and capacity

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“GDP is not an adequate measure of well-being. Discuss with reference to green accounting and alternative indicators.”

How to Answer

  1. Limits What GDP misses.
  2. Green Natural capital.
  3. Alternatives GNH, HDI, GPI.
  4. India Way forward.

GS Relevance

Prelims: limits of GDP, green GDP, green accounting, SEEA, GNH, HDI. GS Paper 3: Indian economy, inclusive growth, environment and sustainability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is GDP not a good measure of welfare?

GDP counts market output and ignores unpaid household work, income distribution, leisure, health and environmental damage. It also counts spending that repairs harm, such as pollution-related medical costs. So a country can have rising GDP while many people have low welfare or its natural assets are depleted.

What is Green GDP?

Green GDP is GDP adjusted for the cost of environmental degradation and depletion of natural resources. In formula terms, Green NDP = GDP - depreciation of produced capital - depreciation of natural capital. If GDP is Rs 1,000 crore and the two deductions are Rs 100 crore and Rs 60 crore, Green NDP is Rs 840 crore.

What is green accounting?

Green accounting, also called environmental-economic accounting, records the use and depletion of natural assets such as forests, water and minerals alongside the economic accounts. The UN System of Environmental-Economic Accounting (SEEA) is the international standard, adopted as a statistical standard in 2012.

What is the Gross National Happiness index?

Gross National Happiness is Bhutan's approach to measure well-being rather than only income, coined in 1972. It rests on four pillars and nine domains such as psychological well-being, health, education, time use, living standards, community vitality and ecological diversity, measured through household surveys.

What are the alternatives to GDP?

Alternatives include the Human Development Index (health, education, income), the Genuine Progress Indicator, Green GDP, the Inclusive Wealth Index, the Multidimensional Poverty Index, the OECD Better Life Index and Bhutan's Gross National Happiness. They capture inequality, sustainability and quality of life that GDP omits.

Does India publish a Green GDP?

No, India does not publish an official headline Green GDP. An expert group headed by Partha Dasgupta examined green national accounts, and MoSPI publishes EnviStats India with environmental statistics. India's official GDP and per capita figures remain conventional, with 2025-26 GDP of Rs 346.36 lakh crore.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 Green GDP is obtained by adding the cost of environmental degradation to GDP.
False

Environmental costs are subtracted from GDP.

2 The concept of Gross National Happiness was developed in Bhutan.
True

It was coined in 1972.

3 GDP includes the value of unpaid household work.
False

Unpaid household work is not counted in GDP.

4 The Human Development Index uses life expectancy, education and income.
True

These are the three dimensions.

Share: