An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 2.19

Economy and Environment; Environment Taxes (Carbon Tax); Green Accounting; Sustainability in the 12th Plan

Indian Economy › National Income, Economic Growth and Measurement · Topic 2.19

The economy and the environment are linked because the environment supplies resources and absorbs waste, while economic activity depletes resources and causes pollution. Environment taxes, such as a carbon tax, make the polluter pay by putting a price on emissions, following the Pigouvian idea that a tax equal to the external cost corrects the market failure. Green accounting adjusts national accounts for resource depletion and degradation, giving a Green GDP. India has no economy-wide carbon tax, but its coal cess, the Carbon Credit Trading Scheme and a 2070 net zero goal act as carbon pricing and sustainability tools, and the 12th Plan made growth sustainable.

Share:
Economy and Environment; Environment Taxes (Carbon Tax); Green Accounting; Sustainability in the 12th Plan - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Link Environment supplies resources and absorbs waste
  • Environment tax Tax on pollution or resource use, polluter pays
  • Carbon tax Price per tonne of carbon dioxide
  • Green accounting National accounts adjusted for environmental cost
  • 12th Plan Faster, more inclusive and sustainable growth
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: National Income, Economic Growth and Measurement

Where Does It Fit?

This topic closes the Prelims block of the macro on national income and development by asking what GDP leaves out about nature. It continues the argument in GDP and Welfare; Green GDP; Green Accounting; Gross National Happiness Index; Alternatives to GDP. Previous topic: HDI vs IHDI (Inequality-Adjusted HDI); Gender Development Index; Gender Social Norms Index (GSNI). Next topic: GDP calculation in India; Panel to revise the GDP base year; India’s new GDP series (Base 2022-23): core adjustments, informal sector correction, agriculture, manufacturing, services.

How Are the Economy and the Environment Linked?

Link What it means Example
Resource supply The environment provides inputs such as land, water, minerals and energy Coal for power, groundwater for irrigation
Waste assimilation The environment absorbs emissions and waste up to a limit Air and water pollution from industry
Life support and amenity Climate, biodiversity and landscapes support life and well-being Forests, wetlands, tourism
Negative externality Pollution imposes cost on others that the polluter does not pay Smog from burning crop residue
Scarcity and depletion Non-renewable resources run down, renewable ones can be overused Falling groundwater tables
Feedback to the economy Environmental damage cuts health, farm yields and output Heat stress reducing labour hours

What Are the Main Environmental Policy Instruments?

Instrument Principle Example
Environment tax or Pigouvian tax Tax equal to the marginal external cost, so that the polluter pays Carbon tax, tax on plastic bags, pollution cess
Carbon tax Fixed price per tonne of carbon dioxide emitted or carbon content of fuels Finland from 1990, Sweden from 1991
Cap and trade Total emissions capped, permits traded, so price is set by the market European Union Emissions Trading System
Subsidy for clean activity Support for cleaner options Solar and electric vehicle incentives
Command and control Standards and bans Emission norms, ban on certain plastics
Green accounting Value environmental damage in national accounts Environmentally adjusted net domestic product

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Pigouvian tax: Named after A. C. Pigou. A tax equal to the marginal external cost makes private cost equal to social cost. This is the polluter pays principle, which is also stated in Principle 16 of the Rio Declaration, 1992
  • Carbon tax worked example: Illustration only. If burning one tonne of coal releases about 2 tonnes of carbon dioxide and the carbon tax is Rs 1,500 per tonne of carbon dioxide, the tax is 2 x 1,500 = Rs 3,000 per tonne of coal. A higher price on carbon pushes firms and users towards cleaner fuel
  • Carbon tax versus cap and trade: A carbon tax fixes the price and lets quantity vary. Cap and trade fixes the quantity and lets the price vary
  • India’s coal cess: India has no general carbon tax. A Clean Energy Cess of Rs 50 per tonne of coal began in 2010 and was raised in stages to Rs 400 per tonne. In 2017 it was subsumed into the GST Compensation Cess. It acted as an implicit carbon price and funded clean energy work, as in Environment Taxes: Carbon Tax
  • Carbon market: India notified the Carbon Credit Trading Scheme under the Energy Conservation (Amendment) Act, 2022. It is a compliance market for large emitters, with the Bureau of Energy Efficiency as the administrator, built around emission intensity targets
  • EU carbon border adjustment mechanism: The European Union carbon border adjustment mechanism put a carbon price on imports of steel, aluminium, cement, fertiliser, electricity and hydrogen, with the full payment phase beginning on 1 January 2026. Indian exporters of steel and aluminium are affected, which is why India raised concerns about the measure
  • India’s climate goals: India has a net zero target for 2070. Its updated nationally determined contribution for 2030 targets a 45 per cent cut in emission intensity of GDP from the 2005 level and 50 per cent of installed electric capacity from non-fossil sources
  • Green accounting and Green GDP: Green GDP = GDP – depreciation of produced capital – cost of depletion and degradation of natural capital. Equivalently, Environmentally adjusted NDP = NDP – environmental cost. The United Nations System of Environmental-Economic Accounting is the standard framework. A numeric example: if NDP is 100, depletion of forests and minerals is 4 and cost of air and water damage is 3, then environmentally adjusted NDP is 93
  • Indian practice: The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation publishes EnviStats India, with environment accounts for energy, land, water and others. A full Green GDP series is not part of official national accounts
  • 12th Plan sustainability: The 12th Five Year Plan (2012 to 2017) had the theme Faster, More Inclusive and Sustainable Growth. It stressed lowering the emission intensity of GDP, raising forest and tree cover, expanding renewable energy, energy efficiency and better water management, as in 12th Five Year Plan (2012-17): theme ‘Faster, More Inclusive and Sustainable Growth’; Alternative Scenarios; Sustainability
  • Kuznets idea for the environment: The Environmental Kuznets Curve suggested pollution falls after a certain income. Evidence is weak for carbon dioxide, and policy action is needed. See Lorenz Curve; Gini Coefficient; Palma Ratio; Kuznets Curve; Phillips Curve (Philip’s Curve); Laffer Curve
  • Sustainable development: The Brundtland concept of 1987 is development that meets present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet theirs. See Sustainable Development: Brundtland Concept; SDG 2030; SDSN; India and SDGs; National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC)
  • Mains link: A fuller analytical treatment is in Environment and development linkage: developmental factors affecting environmental sustainability

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Polluter pays: Environment taxes apply the polluter pays principle, in the Pigouvian way
  2. Carbon tax: Price per tonne of carbon dioxide. India has no economy-wide carbon tax
  3. Green accounting: Adjusts GDP or NDP for depletion and degradation of natural capital
  4. 12th Plan: Theme of faster, more inclusive and sustainable growth
  5. Common errors: Saying India has a carbon tax, or confusing a carbon tax with a cap and trade scheme

As an analytical point, carbon pricing and green accounts both correct the blind spot of GDP. For India the challenge is to price carbon without hurting low-income users, so revenue recycling and a clean energy push must go together.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Environment taxes Polluter pays, carbon tax
  • Green accounting Green GDP formula
  • 12th Plan Sustainability theme

What Came Next?

The next topic is the first of the Mains dimensions on national income, covering GDP calculation in India. Next topic: GDP calculation in India; Panel to revise the GDP base year; India’s new GDP series (Base 2022-23): core adjustments, informal sector correction, agriculture, manufacturing, services.

Key People and Terms

  • Pigouvian tax Tax equal to external cost
  • Carbon tax Tax per tonne of carbon dioxide
  • Green GDP GDP net of environmental cost
  • Cap and trade Tradable emission permits
  • CBAM Carbon border adjustment mechanism
  • CCTS Carbon Credit Trading Scheme

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Environment tax: polluter pays, Pigouvian.
  • Carbon tax fixes price; cap and trade fixes quantity.
  • Green GDP = GDP – depreciation – environmental cost.
  • 12th Plan: 2012 to 2017, sustainable growth.
  • India net zero: 2070.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Carbon tax and cap and trade Fixed price versus fixed quantity
  • Green GDP and GDP With environmental cost versus without
  • Polluter pays principle and precautionary principle Cost on emitter versus caution under uncertainty

Memory Hook

Price the pollution, count the damage, plan for the future.

Mains Angle

Questions ask how to balance growth and the environment. These points give a frame.

  • Link Resources and waste
  • Tools Taxes, markets, accounts
  • India CCTS, 2070, CBAM

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Discuss how environment taxes and green accounting can help reconcile economic growth with environmental sustainability in India.”

How to Answer

  1. Link Economy and environment.
  2. Tools Carbon tax, green accounts.
  3. India Coal cess, CCTS, NDC.
  4. Way Price carbon with fairness.

GS Relevance

Prelims: environment taxes, carbon tax, green accounting, sustainability goals of the 12th Plan. GS Paper 3: environment, conservation, sustainable development, economy and environment.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an environment tax?

An environment tax is a tax on pollution or on the use of natural resources that makes the polluter bear the external cost of damage, following the polluter pays principle and the Pigouvian idea. Examples are a carbon tax, a pollution cess and a tax on plastic bags.

What is a carbon tax?

A carbon tax is a charge on each tonne of carbon dioxide emitted, or on the carbon content of fuels, to raise the cost of emissions and push firms and consumers towards cleaner options. Finland introduced one in 1990 and Sweden in 1991. India does not have an economy-wide carbon tax.

What is the difference between a carbon tax and cap and trade?

A carbon tax fixes the price of carbon and lets emission levels vary, while cap and trade fixes the total amount of emissions and lets the market determine the permit price. India's Carbon Credit Trading Scheme is a market-based, trading approach.

What is Green GDP and green accounting?

Green accounting adjusts national accounts for the depletion and degradation of natural resources. Green GDP is GDP minus depreciation of produced capital and the cost of environmental damage. It shows the sustainable level of income and is based on the UN System of Environmental-Economic Accounting.

What was the sustainability agenda of India's 12th Five Year Plan?

The 12th Five Year Plan, 2012 to 2017, had the theme Faster, More Inclusive and Sustainable Growth. It aimed to cut the emission intensity of GDP, raise forest and tree cover, expand renewable energy, improve efficiency and manage water better, balancing growth with the environment.

How does the EU carbon border adjustment mechanism affect India?

The European Union carbon border adjustment mechanism charges importers for the carbon embedded in steel, aluminium, cement, fertiliser, electricity and hydrogen, with full payment starting on 1 January 2026. Indian exporters of steel and aluminium face higher costs, so India pushes domestic carbon pricing and negotiates exemptions.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 India imposes an economy-wide carbon tax on all fossil fuels.
False

India has coal cess history and a carbon market scheme, but no economy-wide carbon tax.

2 Green GDP deducts the cost of environmental depletion and degradation from GDP.
True

It also nets out depreciation of produced capital.

3 The polluter pays principle underlies environment taxes.
True

The polluter bears the external cost.

4 The 12th Five Year Plan was titled Faster, More Inclusive and Sustainable Growth.
True

The plan period was 2012 to 2017.

Share: