Financial Models: Types of Models (Annuity, BOT, HAM) for Industry and Infrastructure
Indian Economy › Industry, MSMEs and Industrial Policy · Topic 15.13
Annuity, Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) and Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM) are public-private partnership models for financing roads and other infrastructure. In BOT (toll), the private developer funds construction, collects tolls and bears traffic risk. In BOT (annuity), the authority pays the developer fixed periodic annuities instead of tolls. In HAM, which the National Highways Authority of India started awarding in January 2016, the authority pays 40 per cent of the project cost during construction in five equal instalments linked to progress, and the balance 60 per cent is repaid as semi-annual annuity with interest, while the authority collects the toll.
7 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Industry, MSMEs and Industrial Policy
At a Glance
- BOT (toll) Developer funds, collects toll, bears traffic risk
- BOT (annuity) Developer funds, authority pays fixed annuity
- HAM 40 per cent construction support, 60 per cent as annuity
- HAM start Awarded by NHAI from January 2016
- HAM interest Bank rate plus 3 per cent on reducing balance
- HAM operations period 15 years
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Industry, MSMEs and Industrial Policy
Where Does It Fit?
This topic applies the PPP ideas of Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Definition, Need, Prerequisites, Advantages to payment design. The full list of models is in PPP Models: Contracting, Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT), DBFO, Concessions, EPC, Swiss Challenge, Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM), Annuity, and the Mains view of problems is in PPP: advantages; concession agreement; types; problems with PPP projects; Vijay Kelkar Committee on revisiting PPP; PPP and intergenerational equity; FDI and FII in investment model. Corridors and roads that use these models appear in Special Economic Zones (SEZs); Industrial Corridors: Delhi-Mumbai, Amritsar-Kolkata (AKIC), Vizag-Chennai (VCIC); DMICDC. Previous topic: Labour Laws: Four Labour Codes; Coverage under Factories Act, Establishments Acts. Next topic: Industrial Development Report (UNIDO); Global Innovation Index; Global IP Index.
How Do BOT Toll, BOT Annuity and HAM Differ?
| Feature | BOT (toll) | BOT (annuity) | Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who funds construction | Private developer, fully | Private developer, fully | Authority 40 per cent as construction support, developer 60 per cent |
| Who collects toll | Developer | Authority | Authority. Toll is the responsibility and revenue of the authority |
| How the developer is paid | From toll collections | Fixed periodic annuity from the authority | Construction support in five equal instalments linked to physical progress, then semi-annual annuity for the balance 60 per cent with interest, plus operation and maintenance payments |
| Traffic (revenue) risk | Developer | Authority. The developer is exposed to the risk that the authority may delay payment | Authority. The developer has stable annuity cash flow |
| Funding burden on the developer | Highest | High | Lower, because 40 per cent is provided during construction |
| Typical use | Roads with high and predictable traffic | Roads where tolls are weak | National highways awarded by NHAI since January 2016 |
What Other Models Are Used and How Do They Compare?
| Model | Meaning | Who bears most risk |
|---|---|---|
| EPC (engineering, procurement, construction) | The authority funds the project and pays a contractor to build it | The government keeps most project and traffic risk |
| Toll-Operate-Transfer (TOT) | A built highway is handed to a concessionaire for a fixed period. The concessionaire pays an upfront fee and collects tolls | The concessionaire bears traffic risk |
| BOT (toll) | Build, operate for the concession period and transfer back to the authority, recovering cost from tolls | Developer |
| BOT (annuity) | Build, operate and transfer, with fixed annuities replacing tolls | Authority carries traffic risk, developer carries payment-delay risk |
| HAM | A hybrid of EPC and annuity: part public funding during construction, part annuity afterward | Authority carries traffic risk, developer carries construction and operation risk |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Also called: BOT is also written as Build-Operate-Transfer, and HAM as the hybrid annuity model. The pure form of BOT with fixed payments is also called BOT-annuity or annuity model. The party that builds is called the concessionaire or developer, and the public body is the authority, as with the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI)
- HAM mechanics: Under the model concession agreement for HAM, 40 per cent of the project cost is given as construction support in five equal instalments of 8 per cent each, tied to physical progress. The balance 60 per cent is paid after completion as semi-annual annuity payments along with interest on the reducing balance at Bank rate plus 3 per cent. Operation and maintenance payments are made along with the annuity, and the operations period is 15 years
- Worked example: HAM payments: Take a bid project cost of Rs 1,000 crore. Construction support is 40 per cent, or Rs 400 crore, paid in five instalments of Rs 80 crore. The balance is Rs 600 crore, repaid over 15 years of semi-annual payments, which is 30 instalments, with principal of Rs 20 crore each. Assume for illustration an interest rate of 10 per cent a year, or 5 per cent per half-year. The first instalment is 20 + 5 per cent of 600 = 20 + 30 = Rs 50 crore, and the last is 20 + 5 per cent of 20 = 20 + 1 = Rs 21 crore. Total interest is 5 per cent of 20 x (30 + 29 + … + 1) = 5 per cent of 9,300 = Rs 465 crore, so total annuities are 600 + 465 = Rs 1,065 crore, and the authority pays 400 + 1,065 = Rs 1,465 crore, excluding operation and maintenance payments. The real rate is Bank rate plus 3 per cent, so it changes with the Bank rate
- Worked example: annuity formula: For a pure annuity with equal instalments, instalment = P x r / (1 – (1 + r) to the power of minus n). For Rs 1,000 crore, 30 half-yearly instalments and 5 per cent per half-year, the instalment is about Rs 65.05 crore and total payment is about Rs 1,951.5 crore. This is an illustration of the formula and not a statement of any contract term
- Why HAM was introduced: Conventional toll and annuity designs left developers and lenders with funding and revenue risks. HAM reduces the funding burden through 40 per cent construction support, and annuity from the authority gives stable cash flow. The authority keeps the toll revenue
- Risk points in HAM: The annuity depends on the authority paying on time, performance obligations can lead to deductions in annuity, and interest at Bank rate plus 3 per cent makes the annuity vary with the Bank rate
- Choosing a model: Where traffic is high and predictable, BOT (toll) can attract private capital. Where traffic is uncertain, HAM or annuity shifts revenue risk to the authority
- Link to industry: The same models apply to industrial infrastructure such as logistics hubs and corridor roads, as in NICDP Nodal ministry Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) Implementing agency…">Industrial Corridors and Dedicated Freight Corridors (DFC); Corridor Development and Implementation Trust; Nodal Ministry (DPIIT) and Implementing Agency
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Split: HAM is 40 per cent public and 60 per cent private, with annuity for the 60 per cent
- Toll: In HAM and BOT-annuity the authority collects toll. In BOT-toll the developer does
- Start: NHAI started awarding HAM projects in January 2016
- Risk: Traffic risk with the developer in BOT-toll, with the authority in HAM
- Common error: Saying that the developer collects toll in HAM
As an analytical point, HAM balanced the burden after pure BOT projects strained developers and lenders, but it raises the fiscal commitment of the authority. The choice of model should follow traffic certainty and the capacity of the authority to pay.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Models BOT, annuity, HAM
- Split 40 and 60 per cent
- Risk Who bears traffic risk
What Came Next?
The next topic covers three global reports used in exam questions: the UNIDO Industrial Development Report, the Global Innovation Index and the Global IP Index. Next topic: Industrial Development Report (UNIDO); Global Innovation Index; Global IP Index.
Key People and Terms
- BOT Build-Operate-Transfer
- HAM Hybrid annuity model
- Annuity Fixed periodic payment
- EPC Government-funded construction contract
- TOT Toll-Operate-Transfer
- Concessionaire Private developer
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- HAM: 40:60; support in five equal instalments.
- HAM interest: Bank rate + 3 per cent.
- Toll in HAM: collected by authority.
- HAM awards started January 2016.
- Operations period in HAM: 15 years.
Do Not Confuse With
- BOT toll and BOT annuity Developer collects toll versus authority pays annuity
- HAM and EPC Part funding plus annuity versus full government funding
- Annuity and toll Fixed payment versus traffic-linked revenue
Memory Hook
Toll risk with BOT, payment risk with annuity, 40 now and 60 later with HAM.
Mains Angle
Questions compare models and ask about risk and cost. These points give a frame.
- Models Features and risks
- HAM Why it was used
- Way Match model to traffic
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Compare BOT, annuity and hybrid annuity models for highway financing and examine why HAM became the preferred model.”
How to Answer
- Define Three models.
- Compare Funding, toll, risk.
- HAM 40:60 and annuity.
- Way Model by traffic.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Hybrid Annuity Model?
The Hybrid Annuity Model is a PPP model in which the authority pays 40 per cent of the project cost during construction in five equal instalments linked to progress, and the developer funds 60 per cent, repaid as semi-annual annuity with interest. The authority collects toll. NHAI has awarded HAM projects since January 2016.
What is the difference between BOT and annuity model?
In BOT (toll), the private developer builds, collects toll and bears traffic risk. In the annuity model, the developer builds and operates but the authority pays fixed periodic annuities instead of toll, so traffic risk moves to the authority while the developer faces payment-delay risk.
What is the difference between BOT and HAM?
In BOT the developer funds the whole project and recovers it through tolls. In HAM the authority gives 40 per cent as construction support and repays the rest as annuity, and collects the toll itself, so the developer does not carry traffic risk.
How is interest calculated in HAM?
In HAM the balance 60 per cent is repaid as semi-annual annuity along with interest on the reducing balance at Bank rate plus 3 per cent. For a Rs 1,000 crore project at an assumed 10 per cent rate, total annuities come to Rs 1,065 crore.
Who bears traffic risk in HAM?
The authority bears traffic risk in HAM, because toll collection is its responsibility and revenue. The developer receives annuity payments for the 60 per cent balance, along with operation and maintenance payments, and is exposed mainly to construction, performance and payment-delay risks.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 In HAM the Government provides 40 per cent of the project cost as construction support.
The developer funds 60 per cent, repaid as annuity.
2 In HAM the private developer collects toll.
Toll collection is the responsibility and revenue of the authority.
3 In BOT (toll) the developer bears traffic risk.
Toll collections are the developer's revenue.
4 NHAI started awarding HAM projects in 2016.
Awards began in January 2016.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index