An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 20.15

Economy and Environment: Environment Taxes, Green Accounting, Carbon Tax; Sustainability

Indian Economy › Poverty, Inequality, Human and Sustainable Development · Topic 20.15

Economic activity depends on the environment for resources and waste absorption, and markets often ignore these costs as externalities. Environmental taxes, such as a carbon tax or pollution charge, make the polluter pay by putting a price on emissions; the idea of a tax equal to the marginal external damage is known as a Pigouvian tax. Green accounting, also called environmental accounting, adjusts national accounts for depletion of natural resources and environmental degradation, giving a measure such as green GDP. The UN System of Environmental-Economic Accounting is the international framework. India has used a coal cess, introduced as a clean energy cess in 2010, and the Carbon Credit Trading Scheme notified in 2023, which sets up an Indian carbon market.

Share:
Economy and Environment: Environment Taxes, Green Accounting, Carbon Tax; Sustainability - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Externality Cost or benefit not priced by the market
  • Pigouvian tax Tax equal to external damage
  • Carbon tax Price on carbon emissions
  • Green accounting Adjusts national accounts for environmental loss
  • India’s coal cess Introduced 2010
  • Carbon Credit Trading Scheme Notified 2023
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Poverty, Inequality, Human and Sustainable Development

Where Does It Fit?

This topic closes the Prelims part of this macro, after NEP 2020 target 50…">Education in India: Role and Channels in Promoting Economic Growth. It links to Sustainable Development: Brundtland Concept; SDG 2030; SDSN; India and SDGs; National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC) on sustainability and Trade Policy for Viksit Bharat: about, challenges (low regional integration, GVC integration, service export constraints, logistics costs, climate and carbon regulation), reforms, diversification and geopolitical way forward on carbon rules in trade. The Mains view is in Inclusive growth, equity across generations and sustainable development. Previous topic: Education in India: Role and Channels in Promoting Economic Growth. Next topic: Poverty in India: types of poverty, causes, vicious circle of poverty; trickle-down approach, inclusive growth, MPI.

How Can Economic Tools Protect the Environment?

Tool How it works Note
Externality An environmental cost, such as pollution, borne by others and not by the producer A market failure that justifies policy
Environmental tax A tax on pollution or resource use that makes the polluter pay Examples are carbon taxes, plastic levies and pollution charges
Pigouvian tax A tax equal to the marginal external damage of an activity Named after Arthur Pigou
Carbon tax A tax per tonne of carbon dioxide emitted or on fuels by carbon content Raises the price of fossil fuels and pushes lower-carbon choices
Emissions trading A cap on total emissions with tradable permits India’s Carbon Credit Trading Scheme was notified in 2023
Subsidy for green activity Support for clean energy and efficiency Complements taxes, as in Renewable Energy: Installed Capacity, Solar Power, Government Initiatives
Polluter pays principle Those who cause pollution should bear the cost of damage and control Accepted in Indian environmental law

What Is Green Accounting and What Has India Done?

Item Facts
Green accounting Adjusts conventional national income accounts for depletion of natural resources and degradation of the environment
Green GDP GDP minus the cost of environmental damage and resource depletion, a proposed measure of sustainable income
SEEA The System of Environmental-Economic Accounting is the UN framework for such accounts
Why GDP counts mining and pollution control as gains but ignores the loss of natural capital
India’s coal cess Introduced in 2010 as a clean energy cess of Rs 50 per tonne of coal to fund clean energy, and later subsumed in GST compensation cess
Carbon market The Carbon Credit Trading Scheme under the Energy Conservation Act sets up a compliance market for emission intensity targets
Link to trade The EU CBAM puts a carbon price on imports, as in Trade Policy for Viksit Bharat: about, challenges (low regional integration, GVC integration, service export constraints, logistics costs, climate and carbon regulation), reforms, diversification and geopolitical way forward

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Also called: Green accounting is also called environmental accounting. SEEA is the System of Environmental-Economic Accounting. Externalities are also called spillover effects
  • Why tax rather than ban: A tax lets firms choose the cheapest way to cut pollution, and raises revenue
  • Design issues: Carbon taxes can raise prices for the poor, so revenue may be used to compensate households
  • Natural capital: Forests, water and minerals are natural capital that should be counted as assets
  • Sustainability: Sustainable income should keep capital intact, linking to intergenerational equity, as in Sustainable Development: Brundtland Concept; SDG 2030; SDSN; India and SDGs; National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC)
  • Link to energy transition: Carbon pricing and clean energy support the shift described in Energy sector: issues and challenges; government initiatives; Green Energy Corridor; achievements
  • India’s approach: India prefers market-based schemes and energy efficiency over a broad carbon tax, citing development needs
  • Exam hint: Remember Pigouvian tax equals external damage and green GDP adjusts GDP for environmental cost
  • Common errors: Writing that a carbon tax is a subsidy. It is a tax on emissions
  • Another common error: Saying that GDP already includes environmental costs. It does not

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Pigouvian tax: Equals marginal external damage
  2. Carbon tax: Price on emissions
  3. Green GDP: GDP adjusted for environmental cost
  4. SEEA: UN accounting framework
  5. India: Coal cess 2010, CCTS 2023

As an analytical point, putting a price on environmental damage corrects a market failure and aligns private choices with social costs. Green accounting complements this by showing the true cost of growth to natural capital.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Externality Market failure
  • Tools Taxes and trading
  • Accounts Green GDP

What Came Next?

The next topic is the Mains view of poverty in India: types, causes, the vicious circle, the trickle-down approach, inclusive growth and MPI. Next topic: Poverty in India: types of poverty, causes, vicious circle of poverty; trickle-down approach, inclusive growth, MPI.

Key People and Terms

  • Externality Unpriced spillover
  • Pigouvian tax Tax equal to damage
  • Green GDP GDP adjusted for environment
  • SEEA Environmental-economic accounting
  • Carbon tax Tax on emissions
  • Natural capital Stock of natural resources

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Pigouvian tax: equals marginal external damage.
  • Green GDP: GDP minus environmental cost.
  • Coal cess: 2010.
  • CCTS: 2023.
  • Polluter pays principle.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Carbon tax and emissions trading Price set by the state versus quantity capped with a market price
  • GDP and green GDP Conventional output versus output net of environmental cost
  • Subsidy and tax Reward for green action versus charge for pollution

Memory Hook

Price the damage with a Pigouvian tax, and count the loss in green accounts.

Mains Angle

Prelims tests the concepts. Mains answers link taxes to climate policy and trade.

  • Tools Taxes and trading
  • Accounts Green GDP
  • India Market-based approach

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Discuss how environmental taxes and green accounting can promote sustainable growth.”

How to Answer

  1. Intro Externalities.
  2. Tools Carbon tax, trading.
  3. Accounts Green GDP.
  4. Conclude Price and measure damage.

GS Relevance

Prelims: environmental taxes, green accounting, carbon tax, sustainability. GS Paper 3: environment and economy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an environmental tax?

An environmental tax is a tax on pollution or resource use, such as a carbon tax or plastic levy, that makes the polluter pay for the environmental damage caused and encourages cleaner choices while raising revenue for environmental protection.

What is a Pigouvian tax?

A Pigouvian tax, named after the economist Arthur Pigou, is a tax set equal to the marginal external damage caused by an activity, so that the producer takes account of the social cost of pollution and the externality is corrected.

What is a carbon tax?

A carbon tax is a tax on each tonne of carbon dioxide emitted or on fuels according to their carbon content. It raises the price of fossil fuels and encourages a shift to cleaner energy, and revenue can be used to compensate households.

What is green accounting?

Green accounting, or environmental accounting, adjusts national income accounts for the depletion of natural resources and the degradation of the environment. It can produce measures such as green GDP, which shows income net of environmental costs and gives a better view of sustainability.

What has India done on carbon pricing?

India introduced a clean energy cess on coal in 2010, later folded into the GST compensation cess, and notified the Carbon Credit Trading Scheme in 2023 under the Energy Conservation Act to create a compliance carbon market based on emission intensity targets.

Why is GDP an incomplete measure of well-being?

GDP counts the output from mining and polluting activities as gains but does not subtract the loss of natural capital or the cost of environmental damage, so it can overstate sustainable income, which is why green accounting is proposed.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 A Pigouvian tax equals the marginal external damage.
True

It corrects an externality.

2 Green GDP is GDP adjusted for environmental costs.
True

It reflects natural capital loss.

3 A carbon tax is a subsidy for clean energy.
False

It is a tax on emissions.

4 India notified a Carbon Credit Trading Scheme in 2023.
True

It is a compliance carbon market.

5 Conventional GDP subtracts environmental damage.
False

It does not.

Share: