An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 18.11

Currency Convertibility: Current Account Convertibility, Capital Account Convertibility (Tarapore Committee), Partial and Full Convertibility; Dual Exchange System

Indian Economy › External Sector: BoP, Forex and Trade · Topic 18.11

Currency convertibility is the freedom to convert a currency into foreign currencies at the market rate. Current account convertibility (CAC) means free conversion for trade in goods and services, income and transfers; capital account convertibility (CAC) means free conversion for investment, loans and other capital transactions. India accepted current account convertibility under Article VIII of the IMF Articles of Agreement in August 1994, while capital account convertibility is partial, with controls by instrument and by investor type. The Tarapore Committee on Capital Account Convertibility (1997) laid down a roadmap with preconditions such as a gross fiscal deficit of 3.5 per cent of GDP, inflation of 3 to 5 per cent, gross NPAs of 5 per cent and a cash reserve ratio of 3 per cent. The topic was asked in UPSC Prelims 2015.

Share:
Currency Convertibility: Current Account Convertibility, Capital Account Convertibility (Tarapore Committee), Partial and Full Convertibility; Dual Exchange System - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Current account convertibility Accepted in August 1994 (Article VIII of the IMF)
  • Capital account convertibility Partial in India
  • Tarapore Committee 1997, roadmap for capital account convertibility
  • Preconditions Fiscal deficit 3.5%, inflation 3 to 5%, NPAs 5%, CRR 3%
  • Dual system Two exchange rates for different transactions
  • Asked in UPSC Prelims 2015
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: External Sector: BoP, Forex and Trade

Where Does It Fit?

This topic follows Currency Terms: Hard, Soft, Hot, Cheap, Dear, Weak Currency; Hammering; Currency War; Currency Manipulator; Currency Swap and links to Foreign Exchange Market; Exchange Rate Determination; Types of Exchange Rates: Fixed, Floating, Pegged Float, Managed Float, Dual on exchange rate regimes. The Mains view is in Capital account convertibility: rupee convertibility in India and Internationalisation of the rupee: meaning, benefits, challenges, measures. Previous topic: Currency Terms: Hard, Soft, Hot, Cheap, Dear, Weak Currency; Hammering; Currency War; Currency Manipulator; Currency Swap. Next topic: India’s External Debt: Composition (USD Largest, then Rupee, SDR, Yen, Euro); NRI Deposits; Sovereign vs Non-Sovereign Debt.

What Are the Types of Convertibility?

Type Meaning India’s position
Current account convertibility Free conversion of rupees for trade in goods and services, income and transfers Introduced in August 1994 when India accepted Article VIII obligations of the IMF
Capital account convertibility Free conversion for capital transactions such as investment, loans and deposits across borders Partial. Controls remain on certain flows, such as limits on debt investment and external borrowing
Partial convertibility Convertibility for some transactions or some holders and not others India’s capital account regime, with limits by instrument and investor type
Full convertibility Free convertibility on both current and capital accounts for all residents and non-residents Not adopted in India
Dual exchange system Two exchange rates for different types of transactions India had one during 1992-93 under LERMS
Exchange controls Rules restricting free conversion and transfer of currency Managed by the RBI under the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999
Convertible currency A currency that can be freely exchanged without restriction A hard currency is usually convertible

What Did the Tarapore Committee Say?

Aspect Facts and analysis
Committee The Committee on Capital Account Convertibility, chaired by S S Tarapore, submitted its report in 1997 to the RBI
Approach It advised moving to capital account convertibility in stages, subject to preconditions, rather than abruptly
Fiscal precondition Gross fiscal deficit of 3.5 per cent of GDP
Inflation precondition Inflation of 3 to 5 per cent for a three-year period
Banking preconditions Gross non-performing assets of banks of 5 per cent and a cash reserve ratio of 3 per cent
Why preconditions Free capital flows can cause volatility, so a sound fiscal position, low inflation and a strong banking system are needed
Later developments A second Tarapore committee reviewed the roadmap in 2006, and in practice India has liberalised capital flows gradually

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Also called: Current account convertibility is also called Article VIII status. Capital account convertibility is also called CAC in some documents, and full convertibility is also called free float
  • Why India is cautious: The 1997 Asian financial crisis showed the risks of rapid capital account opening, so India chose a gradual path
  • Gradual liberalisation: FDI is largely open under the automatic route, FPI and ECB limits are set by regulation, and resident outflows are allowed under limits
  • Benefits of full convertibility: Lower cost of capital, more investment, and better allocation of savings
  • Risks of full convertibility: Sudden capital flight, exchange rate volatility, loss of monetary autonomy and financial crises
  • Link to the impossible trinity: A country with free capital flows and an independent monetary policy must let its exchange rate float, as in Foreign Exchange Market; Exchange Rate Determination; Types of Exchange Rates: Fixed, Floating, Pegged Float, Managed Float, Dual
  • Link to FPI: Portfolio flows are the most volatile part of the capital account, as in Foreign Capital: FDI, FPI, FII, QFI; Non-Resident Deposits are not FDI; Differences between FDI and FII; Foreign Currency Borrowings / ECBs; Rupee-Denominated Bonds
  • Link to rupee internationalisation: A wider global use of the rupee requires greater convertibility, as in Internationalisation of the rupee: meaning, benefits, challenges, measures
  • Exam hint: Remember 1994 for current account convertibility and 1997 for the Tarapore Committee
  • Common errors: Saying India has full capital account convertibility. It is partial
  • Another common error: Confusing the Tarapore Committee with the Narasimham Committee on banking. Tarapore dealt with convertibility

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. CAC current: August 1994, Article VIII
  2. CAC capital: Partial
  3. Tarapore Committee: 1997, preconditions for capital account convertibility
  4. Preconditions: Fiscal deficit 3.5 per cent, inflation 3 to 5 per cent, NPAs 5 per cent, CRR 3 per cent
  5. Dual system: Two rates, LERMS 1992

As an analytical point, India’s approach to convertibility has been gradual and cautious. Current account convertibility supports trade, while capital account controls protect against sudden flows, and the debate is about how fast to move given the benefits of openness and the risks of volatility.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Types Current and capital
  • Tarapore Roadmap and preconditions
  • Approach Gradual

What Came Next?

The next topic covers India’s external debt: composition, NRI deposits and sovereign versus non-sovereign debt. Next topic: India’s External Debt: Composition (USD Largest, then Rupee, SDR, Yen, Euro); NRI Deposits; Sovereign vs Non-Sovereign Debt.

Key People and Terms

  • Convertibility Free exchange of currency
  • Article VIII IMF commitment on current account
  • Tarapore Committee on capital account
  • Partial convertibility Limited freedom
  • Dual rate Two exchange rates
  • Exchange control Restrictions on currency conversion

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Current account convertibility: August 1994.
  • Capital account: partial.
  • Tarapore Committee: 1997.
  • Preconditions: fiscal deficit 3.5 per cent, inflation 3 to 5 per cent.
  • Asked in UPSC Prelims 2015.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Current account and capital account convertibility Trade and income versus investment and loans
  • Partial and full convertibility Limited versus unrestricted freedom
  • Tarapore Committee and Narasimham Committee Capital account versus banking reform

Memory Hook

Current account free in 1994, capital account gradual after Tarapore.

Mains Angle

Prelims asked this in 2015. Know the dates, the committee and the preconditions.

  • Benefits Capital, efficiency
  • Risks Volatility
  • Approach Gradual, conditional

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Discuss the case for and against full capital account convertibility in India with reference to the Tarapore Committee.”

How to Answer

  1. Intro Types of convertibility.
  2. Case for Capital, efficiency.
  3. Case against Volatility, crises.
  4. Conclude Gradual path with preconditions.

GS Relevance

Prelims: current and capital account convertibility, Tarapore Committee, partial and full convertibility. GS Paper 3: external sector, financial reforms.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is currency convertibility?

Currency convertibility is the freedom to convert a currency into other currencies at the market exchange rate. Current account convertibility covers trade in goods and services, income and transfers, and capital account convertibility covers investment, loans and other capital transactions.

When did India adopt current account convertibility?

India adopted current account convertibility in August 1994 by accepting the obligations of Article VIII of the IMF's Articles of Agreement, which means that the rupee can be freely converted for trade in goods and services, income and transfers.

Is the rupee fully convertible?

No. The rupee is fully convertible on the current account but only partially convertible on the capital account. India keeps controls on certain capital flows, such as limits on external borrowing and portfolio debt investment, to manage volatility.

What was the Tarapore Committee?

The Tarapore Committee on Capital Account Convertibility, chaired by S S Tarapore, reported in 1997 and recommended a staged move to capital account convertibility subject to preconditions such as a gross fiscal deficit of 3.5 per cent of GDP and inflation of 3 to 5 per cent.

What are the risks of full capital account convertibility?

The risks are sudden capital flight, exchange rate volatility, loss of monetary policy autonomy and the possibility of financial crises, as seen in the 1997 Asian financial crisis, which is why India prefers a gradual approach with preconditions.

What is a dual exchange rate system?

A dual exchange rate system has two exchange rates for different types of transactions. India had one in 1992-93 under the Liberalised Exchange Rate Management System, before unifying to a market-determined rate in March 1993.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 India accepted Article VIII of the IMF in August 1994.
True

This made the rupee convertible on the current account.

2 India has full capital account convertibility.
False

It is partial.

3 The Tarapore Committee reported in 1997.
True

It dealt with capital account convertibility.

4 The Tarapore Committee proposed a fiscal deficit of 3.5 per cent of GDP as a precondition.
True

It also proposed inflation of 3 to 5 per cent.

5 Current account convertibility covers investment and loans.
False

That is capital account convertibility.

Share: