Clock Problems Involving a Faulty/Gaining or Losing Clock
Reasoning › Clocks and Calendars · Topic 21.5
A faulty clock gains or loses a fixed amount of time every hour, so its reading differs from the true time by an amount proportional to the true time elapsed. The rule is to compare the time shown by the faulty clock with the true time, use the ratio of clock time to true time, and add the gain or subtract the loss from the true time to read the clock, or reverse the process to get the true time.
7 min read · Reasoning · Clocks and Calendars
Quick Answer
A faulty clock gains or loses a fixed amount of time every hour, so its reading differs from the true time by an amount proportional to the true time elapsed. The rule is to compare the time shown by the faulty clock with the true time, use the ratio of clock time to true time, and add the gain or subtract the loss from the true time to read the clock, or reverse the process to get the true time.
At a Glance
- Question type Clock gains or loses time at a fixed rate
- Key idea Clock time and true time are in a fixed ratio
- Gaining clock Shows more than the true time
- Losing clock Shows less than the true time
- Method Use proportion on elapsed time
- Hands-meeting version If hands meet every M minutes, gain = (720/11 – M) ÷ M × 1440
Where Does It Fit?
This topic combines the clock reading skills of Clock Problems – Angle Between the Hour and Minute Hands and Clock Problems – Coinciding, Opposite and Right-Angle Hand Positions with ratio and proportion. It differs from Mirror Image and Reflection Problems on a Clock Face, which reflects a correct clock in a mirror. A related use of the 65 5/11 minute fact appears in Number of Times Clock Hands Overlap or Form a Right Angle in a Day.
How Does a Gaining or Losing Clock Work?
In short: a faulty clock runs fast or slow by a constant amount per hour, so the gain or loss is proportional to the true time elapsed.
| Type | Clock reading vs true time | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Gaining (fast) clock | Shows more than true time | Gains 3 minutes per hour |
| Losing (slow) clock | Shows less than true time | Loses 2 minutes per hour |
| Correct clock | Equal to true time | Gain or loss is zero |
If a clock gains 4 minutes per hour, then in every true 60 minutes it shows 64 minutes. The ratio of clock time to true time is therefore 64 : 60, which is the key to reversing the problem.
How Do You Solve Faulty Clock Problems?
In short: work in true time, compute the total gain or loss, and then apply it to the clock reading. To find the true time from a clock reading, use the ratio.
- Find the true time elapsed. Count from the moment the clock was correct.
- Find the gain or loss. Multiply the rate per hour by the hours elapsed.
- Apply it. Clock reading equals true time plus gain, or true time minus loss.
- Reverse if needed. Clock minutes elapsed ÷ clock minutes per true hour × 60 gives the true minutes elapsed.
Hands-meeting formula
- A correct clock’s hands coincide every 720/11 = 65 5/11 minutes of true time.
- If a clock’s hands meet every M minutes by true time, then gain or loss in 24 hours = (720/11 – M) ÷ M × 1440 minutes.
- A positive value means the clock gains; a negative value means it loses.
The 65 5/11 minute figure is derived in Clock Problems – Coinciding, Opposite and Right-Angle Hand Positions.
What About a Clock That Is Slow or Fast at the Start?
In short: when the clock is already ahead or behind at the start, the initial error either grows or shrinks with the gain or loss.
- Slow clock that gains: the clock becomes correct when total gain equals the initial slowness.
- Fast clock that gains: the error only grows.
- Time to be correct again: initial error ÷ rate of gain or loss per hour.
For clock readings in a mirror, switch to the method in Mirror Image and Reflection Problems on a Clock Face.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: A clock is set right at 6 AM and gains 3 minutes per hour. What does it show at the true time 4 PM?
- True time elapsed is 10 hours, so total gain is 30 minutes.
- The clock shows 4:00 PM plus 30 minutes.
Answer: 4:30 PM
Example 2
Question: A clock that loses 2 minutes every hour is set right at 9 AM. What does it show at the true time 3 PM?
- True time elapsed is 6 hours, so total loss is 12 minutes.
- The clock shows 3:00 PM minus 12 minutes.
Answer: 2:48 PM
Example 3
Question: A watch gains 4 minutes per hour and is set right at 7 AM. When the watch shows 3:32 PM, what is the true time?
- The watch has run for 8 hours 32 minutes, which is 512 minutes of watch time.
- In 60 true minutes the watch shows 64 minutes, so true time = 512 × 60 ÷ 64 = 480 minutes.
- 480 minutes is 8 hours, so the true time is 7 AM plus 8 hours.
Answer: 3:00 PM
Example 4
Question: A clock is 5 minutes slow at 8 AM and gains 2 minutes per hour. At what true time will it show the correct time?
- The clock must gain 5 minutes.
- At 2 minutes per hour, this takes 5 ÷ 2 = 2.5 hours.
- 8 AM plus 2.5 hours is 10:30 AM.
Answer: 10:30 AM
Example 5
Question: The hands of a clock coincide every 64 minutes of true time. How much does the clock gain or lose in 24 hours?
- A correct clock’s hands coincide every 720/11 = 65 5/11 minutes.
- The faulty clock’s hands coincide every 64 minutes, which is less, so the clock gains.
- Gain = (720/11 – 64) ÷ 64 × 1440 = (16/11) ÷ 64 × 1440 = 360/11 = 32 8/11 minutes.
Answer: It gains 32 8/11 minutes in 24 hours
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Work with true time first and apply the gain or loss afterwards.
- For a clock reading, use the ratio of clock minutes to true minutes.
- Time to correct = initial error ÷ rate of gain per hour.
- A hands-meeting interval smaller than 65 5/11 means a gaining clock.
- Convert the elapsed time to minutes before using ratios.
Common Mistakes
- Adding the gain to the clock reading instead of the true time.
- Using the clock’s elapsed time as if it were true time.
- Subtracting a gain or adding a loss.
- Using 60 minutes instead of 720/11 minutes for the hands-meeting problem.
- Forgetting that a slow clock needs a gain to become correct.
Practice Questions
- A clock gains 5 minutes per hour and is set right at noon. What does it show at the true time 4 PM?
- A clock loses 3 minutes per hour and is set right at 8 AM. What does it show at the true time 2 PM?
- A clock gains 4 minutes per hour and is set right at 7 AM. What does it show at the true time 3 PM?
- A clock is 10 minutes slow and gains 5 minutes per hour. After how many hours is it correct?
- A clock is set right at 6 AM and loses 4 minutes per hour. What does it show at the true time 10 AM?
- A watch gains 5 minutes per hour and is set right at 7 AM. At the true time 7 PM, how many minutes does it show ahead?
Answers: 1) 4:20 PM; 2) 1:42 PM; 3) 3:32 PM; 4) 2 hours; 5) 9:44 AM; 6) 60 minutes ahead.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Exam use A regular clock-and-ratio item.
- Combines skills Joins clock reading with proportion.
- Accuracy Teaches the difference between true time and clock time.
- Link to other topics Builds on Clock Problems – Coinciding, Opposite and Right-Angle Hand Positions.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Mirror Image and Reflection Problems on a Clock Face. It shows how the time on a clock appears in a mirror.
Key Terms and Formulas
- True time The actual correct time
- Clock time The time shown by the faulty clock
- Gaining clock A clock that runs fast
- Losing clock A clock that runs slow
- Rate Minutes gained or lost per hour
- Ratio of times Clock minutes to true minutes
Related Topics
- Clock Problems – Coinciding, Opposite and Right-Angle Hand Positions
- Mirror Image and Reflection Problems on a Clock Face
- Calendar Problems – Finding the Day of the Week for a Given Date
- Calendar Problems Involving Leap Years and Odd Days
Related Topics in Maarg Manthan
Study this topic together with these linked topics from other subjects.
- Clock-Based Problems (Angle Between Hour and Minute Hands, Coinciding/Opposite Hands) (Quantitative Aptitude)
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Gain or loss is proportional to true time elapsed.
- Clock reading = true time + gain, or true time – loss.
- A correct clock’s hands coincide every 65 5/11 minutes.
- Time to correct = initial error ÷ rate.
- Use the ratio to convert clock time to true time.
Do Not Confuse With
- Gaining vs losing Gaining shows more than true time; losing shows less.
- True time vs clock time Gain or loss is based on true time elapsed.
- Slow clock vs losing clock A slow clock is behind now; a losing clock falls further behind.
- Gain per hour vs per day Convert units before calculating.
Memory Hook
Find the true time elapsed, apply the gain or loss, and use the ratio to reverse.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you solve a gaining clock problem?
Find the true time elapsed since the clock was correct, multiply by the gain per hour to get the total gain, and add it to the true time to read the clock. For example, a clock gaining 3 minutes per hour shows 4:30 PM at true 4 PM if set right at 6 AM.
How do you find the true time from a faulty clock reading?
Use the ratio of clock time to true time. If a clock gains 4 minutes per hour, it shows 64 minutes for every true 60 minutes. Multiply the clock's elapsed minutes by 60 and divide by 64 to get the true minutes, then add them to the starting time.
What is the formula when the hands of a faulty clock meet at a different interval?
If the hands meet every M minutes of true time, the gain or loss in 24 hours is 720/11 minus M, divided by M, multiplied by 1440, in minutes. A positive result means the clock gains time, and a negative result means it loses time.
How long will a slow clock take to become correct?
A slow clock that also gains becomes correct when the total gain equals its initial lag. The time needed is the initial error divided by the rate of gain per hour. For example, a clock 5 minutes slow gaining 2 minutes per hour is correct after 2.5 hours.
What is the difference between a slow clock and a losing clock?
A slow clock is behind the true time at the moment, while a losing clock falls further behind as time passes. A clock can be slow yet gaining, in which case it will catch up and show the correct time later, as in a clock 5 minutes slow gaining 2 minutes an hour.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 A clock gaining 3 minutes per hour shows 4:30 PM at true 4 PM if set right at 6 AM.
Gain in 10 hours is 30 minutes.
2 A clock whose hands meet every 64 minutes of true time gains time.
64 is less than 65 5/11.
3 A losing clock shows more than the true time.
A losing clock shows less than the true time.
4 A slow clock that gains can show the correct time later.
When the total gain equals its initial lag.
Related Topics
Browse the full Reasoning index