An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 2.9

Classification Involving Two Different Criteria Applied Simultaneously

Reasoning › Classification (Odd One Out) · Topic 2.9

Classification with two criteria applied together gives a group in which every item but one satisfies both of two conditions, such as even and a perfect square, or domestic and herbivorous. The odd item fails at least one condition. Test each item against criterion one, then criterion two, and mark the item that fails either test.

Share:
Classification Involving Two Different Criteria Applied Simultaneously - Reasoning - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

Quick Answer

Classification with two criteria applied together gives a group in which every item but one satisfies both of two conditions, such as even and a perfect square, or domestic and herbivorous. The odd item fails at least one condition. Test each item against criterion one, then criterion two, and mark the item that fails either test.

At a Glance

  • Format Items that share two properties
  • Method Two-column test
  • Odd item Fails one or both conditions
  • Types Words, numbers, letters
  • Trap Item fails the second condition only
  • Time 30 seconds

Where Does It Fit?

This topic extends the single-property classification of Classification of Words Based on Meaning or Category, Classification of Numbers Based on Mathematical Properties (Prime, Perfect Square, etc.) and Classification of Letter Groups Based on Positional Pattern. Digit-based rules from Classification of Number Groups Based on Digit Sum or Digit Product are often one of the two criteria, and pairs of items with the same logic are in Finding the Odd Pair Out Among Given Pairs.

What Does “Two Criteria” Mean?

In short: the odd item is the one that breaks a combination of two rules, not a single rule.

In 4, 16, 36, 64, 49, the shared conditions are “perfect square” and “even”. All five are perfect squares, so the first condition alone gives no answer. Only 49 is odd, so it fails the second condition and is the answer.

  • One criterion may fit every item, and the other decides the answer.
  • Sometimes one item fails the first criterion and another fails the second, and then a stricter reading of the question is needed.
  • The two criteria can be of the same type (two number properties) or of different types.

How Do You Apply Two Criteria?

In short: make two columns, one for each condition, and tick each item in each column.

  1. Find a criterion that fits most of the items. Write it as column 1.
  2. Find a second feature that divides the remaining items. Write it as column 2.
  3. Tick each item in each column.
  4. The item with a missing tick is the odd one.
  5. If two items have a missing tick, reconsider the criteria and look for a more precise pair.
Group Criterion 1 Criterion 2 Odd one
4, 16, 36, 64, 49 Perfect square Even 49
12, 24, 36, 48, 18 Multiple of 3 Multiple of 4 18
Cow, Goat, Buffalo, Cat, Horse Domestic Herbivore Cat
ACE, EGI, OQS, UWY, BDF Starts with a vowel Gap of 2 BDF
17, 35, 53, 71, 62 Digit sum 8 Odd 62

What Checks Make It Reliable?

In short: verify the answer by testing it against both conditions and testing the others once more.

Verification

  • Does the odd item fail at least one condition?
  • Do all the other items pass both conditions?
  • Is there another item that also fails?

Number conditions use the tests from Classification of Numbers Based on Mathematical Properties (Prime, Perfect Square, etc.) and Classification of Number Groups Based on Digit Sum or Digit Product, and letter conditions use the gaps from Classification of Letter Groups Based on Positional Pattern.

Solved Examples

Example 1

Question: 4, 16, 36, 64, 49

  1. All are perfect squares: 2, 4, 6, 8, 7 squared.
  2. 4, 16, 36 and 64 are even, while 49 is odd.

Answer: 49

Example 2

Question: 12, 24, 36, 48, 18

  1. All are multiples of 3.
  2. 12, 24, 36 and 48 are also multiples of 4, but 18 is not, since 18 divided by 4 leaves 2.

Answer: 18

Example 3

Question: Cow, Goat, Buffalo, Cat, Horse

  1. All five are domestic animals.
  2. Cow, goat, buffalo and horse are herbivores, while a cat eats meat.

Answer: Cat

Example 4

Question: ACE, EGI, OQS, UWY, BDF

  1. ACE (1, 3, 5), EGI (5, 7, 9), OQS (15, 17, 19) and UWY (21, 23, 25) start with a vowel and have gaps of 2.
  2. BDF (2, 4, 6) has gaps of 2 but starts with a consonant.

Answer: BDF

Example 5

Question: 17, 35, 53, 71, 62

  1. All have digit sum 8: 1 + 7, 3 + 5, 5 + 3, 7 + 1, 6 + 2.
  2. 17, 35, 53 and 71 are odd, while 62 is even.

Answer: 62

Shortcuts and Tricks

  • Find the criterion that fits everyone first, then look for the one that splits the group.
  • If two items fail, check whether one of the criteria is wrong.
  • Write the two criteria in short words so that you can tick them quickly.
  • Do the easier criterion first (even or odd, domestic or wild).
  • Confirm the answer by testing the four others on both conditions.

Common Mistakes

  • Stopping after the first criterion.
  • Choosing an item that fails one test while another item fails the other.
  • Using criteria that are too loose.
  • Not rechecking the others against both conditions.
  • Mixing a criterion with a coincidence.

Practice Questions

  1. 8, 64, 216, 512, 27 (cubes that are even)
  2. Ostrich, Emu, Kiwi, Penguin, Eagle (birds that cannot fly)
  3. 15, 25, 35, 45, 20 (odd multiples of 5)
  4. 81, 36, 9, 144, 49 (squares with digit sum 9)
  5. Ganga, Godavari, Krishna, Narmada, Mahanadi (rivers flowing into the Bay of Bengal)
  6. ACE, EGI, OQS, UWY, ADG (start with a vowel and gaps of 2)

Answers: 1) 27; 2) Eagle; 3) 20; 4) 49; 5) Narmada; 6) ADG.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Depth Trains careful checking over speed.
  • Exam use Used in the harder odd one out questions.
  • Logic Builds the habit of testing combined conditions.
  • Link Prepares for Venn and deduction topics.

What Comes Next?

The next topic is Classification of Figures Based on Number of Sides or Symmetry. It classifies figures by number of sides or symmetry, the last topic of this macro.

Key Terms and Formulas

  • Criterion A condition used for grouping
  • Two-column test Checking each item against two conditions
  • Herbivore An animal that eats plants
  • Domestic Kept by people
  • Digit sum Total of the digits
  • Gap Difference between letter positions
  • Classification of Number Groups Based on Digit Sum or Digit Product
  • Classification of Figures Based on Number of Sides or Symmetry
  • Classification of Words Based on Meaning or Category
  • Classification of Numbers Based on Mathematical Properties (Prime, Perfect Square, etc.)

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Find the condition that fits all, then the one that splits.
  • Use two columns and tick each item.
  • The odd item lacks a tick.
  • Recheck the others on both conditions.
  • Drop loose criteria.

Do Not Confuse With

  • One criterion vs two A single rule may fit all items, so the second rule decides.
  • Fails first vs fails second Both are valid ways to be odd.
  • Coincidence vs criterion A shared feature must apply to the whole group.
  • Herbivore vs domestic They are different conditions.

Memory Hook

Two columns, two ticks, one missing tick.

GS Relevance

Two-criteria classification is a higher-difficulty odd one out type in SSC CGL, banking, CAPF and CDS reasoning sections, and it tests careful checking more than speed.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is classification with two criteria?

It is an odd one out question in which items share two conditions, such as even and a perfect square. One item fails at least one of them, and you find it by testing every item against both conditions in turn.

How do you solve two-criteria odd one out questions?

Find a feature that fits most items, then a second feature that splits the group. Tick every item for both features. The item that lacks a tick for either feature is the odd one. Recheck the others to make sure they pass both tests.

What if one criterion fits all the items?

Then the second criterion decides the answer. In 4, 16, 36, 64 and 49, all are perfect squares, so the second criterion of being even identifies 49 as the odd item. Always look for the criterion that divides the group.

How is this different from simple odd one out?

In simple odd one out a single property separates one item from the rest. Here a combination of two properties defines the group, so an item can fit one property and still be the odd one out because it fails the other.

How can I check my answer in these questions?

Test the chosen item against both conditions and confirm that it fails at least one. Then test the other items against both conditions to confirm that they all pass. If another item also fails, one of your criteria is wrong.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 In 4, 16, 36, 64, 49, the number 49 fails the even criterion.
True

49 is a perfect square but it is odd.

2 In a two-criteria question, the odd item must fail both criteria.
False

Failing one criterion is enough.

3 18 is a multiple of 3 and a multiple of 4.
False

18 is not divisible by 4.

4 A cat is a herbivore.
False

A cat eats meat; cats are obligate carnivores.

Share: