Problems on Trains Crossing a Person Who Is Walking or Running
Quantitative Aptitude › Time, Speed and Distance · Topic 10.10
When a train crosses a person who is walking or running, the distance covered relative to the person is the length of the train. The relative speed is the train's speed minus the person's speed in the same direction, or plus the person's speed in the opposite direction.
5 min read · Quantitative Aptitude · Time, Speed and Distance
Quick Answer
When a train crosses a person who is walking or running, the distance covered relative to the person is the length of the train. The relative speed is the train’s speed minus the person’s speed in the same direction, or plus the person’s speed in the opposite direction.
At a Glance
- Distance Length of the train
- Same direction Relative speed = train – person
- Opposite direction Relative speed = train + person
- Crossing time Length ÷ relative speed
- Units Convert km/h to m/s with 5/18
- Difference from a pole The person also moves
Where Does It Fit?
This topic is a variation of Problems on Trains (Crossing Platforms, Poles, Bridges and Other Trains). Instead of a fixed pole, the object crossed is a moving person, so Relative Speed – Same Direction and Opposite Direction on relative speed supplies the rule.
How Does a Moving Person Change the Crossing Time?
In short: the train still has to cover its own length, but it does so at the relative speed with respect to the person.
| Person’s movement | Relative speed | Crossing time |
|---|---|---|
| Standing still | Train’s speed | L ÷ speed |
| Walking in the same direction | Train – person | L ÷ (train – person) |
| Walking in the opposite direction | Train + person | L ÷ (train + person) |
A person walking in the same direction as the train slows the passing, because the train has to catch up. A person walking towards the train speeds the passing up.
How Do You Find the Speed of the Train or the Person?
In short: the crossing time and the length give the relative speed, and the other speed follows by subtraction or addition.
Working backwards
- Relative speed = Length ÷ Time taken to cross the person
- Same direction: train speed = relative speed + person’s speed
- Opposite direction: train speed = relative speed – person’s speed
- Converting units: use 5/18 or 18/5 as in Speed, Distance and Time Basic Relationship and Unit Conversion (km/h to m/s).
- Length from time: if the train crosses a standing man in t seconds at speed v, then L = v × t.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: A 150 m train at 60 km/h passes a man walking at 6 km/h in the same direction. How long does it take?
- Relative speed = 60 – 6 = 54 km/h = 15 m/s.
- Time = 150 ÷ 15 = 10 seconds.
Answer: 10 seconds.
Example 2
Question: A 110 m train at 60 km/h passes a man walking at 6 km/h towards it. How long does it take?
- Relative speed = 60 + 6 = 66 km/h = 66 × 5/18 = 55/3 m/s.
- Time = 110 ÷ (55/3) = 110 × 3/55 = 6 seconds.
Answer: 6 seconds.
Example 3
Question: A 200 m train at 90 km/h passes a runner going the same way at 5 m/s. How long does it take?
- 90 km/h = 25 m/s.
- Relative speed = 25 – 5 = 20 m/s.
- Time = 200 ÷ 20 = 10 seconds.
Answer: 10 seconds.
Example 4
Question: A 120 m train passes a man walking at 5 km/h towards it in 6 seconds. Find the speed of the train.
- Relative speed = 120 ÷ 6 = 20 m/s = 72 km/h.
- Train speed = 72 – 5 = 67.
Answer: 67 km/h.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- The distance to cover is always the length of the train for a person.
- Same direction subtracts the person’s speed; opposite direction adds it.
- Convert the person’s speed to the same unit as the train’s speed before combining.
- If the person’s speed is zero, the problem becomes a pole problem.
- Use the 18 to 5 pairs for fast conversion.
Common Mistakes
- Adding the person’s length or any extra distance.
- Adding speeds when the person walks in the same direction.
- Mixing km/h and m/s.
- Forgetting to subtract the person’s speed after finding the relative speed.
- Treating a moving person as a stationary pole.
Practice Questions
- A 180 m train at 72 km/h passes a man at 18 km/h in the same direction. Time?
- A 150 m train at 90 km/h passes a man at 5 m/s coming towards it. Time?
- A 250 m train at 54 km/h passes a man at 5 m/s in the same direction. Time?
- A 100 m train at 54 km/h takes 10 s to pass a man going the same way. Man’s speed?
- A 300 m train at 90 km/h passes a man at 5 m/s coming towards it. Time?
- A train at 54 km/h passes a standing man in 8 s. Length of the train?
Answers: 1) 12 seconds; 2) 5 seconds; 3) 25 seconds; 4) 5 m/s, which is 18 km/h; 5) 10 seconds; 6) 120 m.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Variation A frequent variation of train problems.
- Exam use Appears in SSC CGL and CAT.
- Link Applies the relative speed idea from Relative Speed – Same Direction and Opposite Direction.
- Speed A single relative speed solves the whole problem.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Distinction Between Average Speed for Equal Distances vs Equal Time Intervals, which separates the equal-distance average from the equal-time average.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Relative speed Train’s speed combined with the person’s speed
- Length of the train Distance covered in crossing a person
- Same direction Person and train moving the same way
- Opposite direction Person and train moving towards each other
- Stationary person A person who does not move
- Crossing time Time for the whole train to pass
Related Topics
- Speed Problems Involving Stoppage Time per Hour
- Distinction Between Average Speed for Equal Distances vs Equal Time Intervals
- Speed, Distance and Time Basic Relationship and Unit Conversion (km/h to m/s)
- Average Speed for Multi-Stage Journeys
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Distance for a person is only the train length.
- Same direction: relative speed is train minus person.
- Opposite direction: relative speed is train plus person.
- Convert units before combining.
- A standing person is a pole problem.
Do Not Confuse With
- Person vs platform A person adds no length; a platform adds its length.
- Same vs opposite direction Same subtracts the person’s speed; opposite adds.
- Moving vs standing person The standing person has zero speed.
- km/h vs m/s Convert both speeds to the same unit.
Memory Hook
The train covers its own length against the relative speed: minus the walker if he goes along, plus the walker if he comes against.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you find the time a train takes to cross a moving person?
Divide the length of the train by the relative speed between the train and the person. If the person walks in the same direction, the relative speed is the train's speed minus the person's speed. If the person walks towards the train, it is the sum of the two speeds.
What distance does a train cover while crossing a person?
A train crossing a person covers a distance equal to its own length relative to the person, because a person has no length. The time is therefore the train's length divided by the relative speed of the train with respect to that person.
How do you find the speed of the train from the crossing time?
Find the relative speed as the train's length divided by the crossing time. Then, for a person walking in the same direction, add the person's speed to get the train's speed; for a person walking towards the train, subtract the person's speed. A 120 m train crossing in 6 seconds gives 20 m/s.
What is the difference between crossing a pole and a moving person?
Crossing a pole uses the full speed of the train, because the pole is fixed. Crossing a moving person uses the relative speed, which is lower if the person walks in the same direction and higher if the person walks towards the train. The distance in both cases is the train length.
How do you convert the person's speed into the same unit?
If the person's speed is in km/h, multiply by 5/18 to convert it to m/s, and if the length of the train is in metres, work in m/s throughout. For example, a person at 18 km/h walks at 5 m/s, and a train at 72 km/h moves at 20 m/s.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 A train crossing a person covers a distance equal to its own length.
A person has no length to add.
2 When a person walks in the same direction as the train, the relative speed is the sum of the speeds.
The relative speed is the difference of the speeds.
3 A 150 m train at 60 km/h passes a man at 6 km/h in the same direction in 10 seconds.
Relative speed 54 km/h is 15 m/s and 150 divided by 15 equals 10.
4 If the person is standing, the problem is the same as crossing a pole.
The relative speed is just the train's speed.
Related Topics
Browse the full Quantitative Aptitude index