Probability Problems on Balls Drawn from Bags Without Replacement
Quantitative Aptitude › Permutation, Combination and Probability · Topic 22.9
Balls drawn from a bag without replacement means each ball taken out is not put back, so the number of balls falls after every draw. Drawing several balls together gives the same probability as drawing them one after another without replacement.
7 min read · Quantitative Aptitude · Permutation, Combination and Probability
Quick Answer
Balls drawn from a bag without replacement means each ball taken out is not put back, so the number of balls falls after every draw. Drawing several balls together gives the same probability as drawing them one after another without replacement.
At a Glance
- Key idea Balls are not put back
- Combination method Favourable / total combinations
- Sequential method Multiply changing fractions
- Drawn together Same as without replacement
- Total ways for r balls from n nCr
Where Does It Fit?
This topic applies the ideas of Probability – Classical Definition and Basic Addition/Multiplication Rules and Combination and Selection Problems to a very common exam setting, the bag of coloured balls. It also prepares the ground for Probability Using the Complementary Event Rule, where the complementary event shortens many ball problems.
What Does Drawing Without Replacement Mean?
In short: when balls are drawn without replacement, the ball taken out stays out, so the bag has one ball fewer at the next draw and the chances change from draw to draw.
If you draw r balls together from a bag of n balls, or draw them one by one without putting any back, the probability of every outcome is the same. This is why the same problem can be solved by either of two methods.
| Situation | Bag after first draw | Effect on next draw |
|---|---|---|
| Without replacement | One ball fewer | Probabilities change (dependent draws) |
| With replacement | Same bag restored | Probabilities stay the same (independent draws) |
| Drawn together | r balls fewer | Treated like without replacement |
Dependent draws use the idea of Conditional Probability and Bayes’ Theorem (CAT-Level): the chance of the second ball depends on what the first ball was.
How Do You Solve It Using Combinations?
In short: count the ways to choose the favourable balls and divide by the ways to choose any balls, so P = favourable combinations / total combinations.
Combination method
- Total combinations = nCr, for r balls from n balls.
- Favourable combinations = product of the nC r terms for each colour wanted.
- P(event) = favourable combinations / total combinations.
Take a bag with 5 red, 4 blue and 3 green balls, 12 in all, and draw 2 together. The total number of ways is 12C2 = 66.
| Event | Favourable ways | Probability |
|---|---|---|
| Both red | 5C2 = 10 | 10/66 = 5/33 |
| One red and one blue | 5 × 4 = 20 | 20/66 = 10/33 |
| Both blue | 4C2 = 6 | 6/66 = 1/11 |
| Both same colour | 10 + 6 + 3 = 19 | 19/66 |
For a mixed selection such as one red and one blue, multiply the ways for each colour: 5C1 × 4C1.
How Do You Solve It Using the Sequential Method?
In short: multiply the probability of each draw in turn, reducing the number of balls and the number of the drawn colour after each draw.
For both balls red from the same bag: P(first red) = 5/12 and P(second red given first red) = 4/11. The product is 20/132 = 5/33, which matches the combination method.
- Order matters here: for one red and one blue in any order, add P(red then blue) = (5/12)(4/11) and P(blue then red) = (4/12)(5/11). The total is 40/132 = 10/33.
- Which method to choose: use combinations when many balls are drawn together, and the sequential method when only two or three balls are drawn in order.
- Checking: the probabilities of all possible outcomes must add up to 1.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: A bag has 5 red, 4 blue and 3 green balls. Two balls are drawn together. Find the probability that both are red.
- Total ways = 12C2 = 66.
- Favourable ways = 5C2 = 10.
- P = 10/66 = 5/33.
Answer: 5/33.
Example 2
Question: In the same bag, three balls are drawn together. Find the probability that all are of different colours.
- Total ways = 12C3 = 220.
- Favourable ways = 5 × 4 × 3 = 60 (one of each colour).
- P = 60/220 = 3/11.
Answer: 3/11.
Example 3
Question: A bag has 6 white and 4 black balls. Three balls are drawn together. Find the probability that at least one is black.
- Use the complement. P(no black) = P(all white) = 6C3 / 10C3 = 20/120 = 1/6.
- P(at least one black) = 1 – 1/6.
Answer: 5/6.
Example 4
Question: A bag has 3 red and 2 green balls. Two balls are drawn one by one without replacement. Find the probability that the second ball is green.
- P(red then green) = (3/5)(2/4) = 3/10.
- P(green then green) = (2/5)(1/4) = 1/10.
- Add the two cases: 3/10 + 1/10 = 4/10.
Answer: 2/5.
Example 5
Question: A bag has 3 red and 4 blue balls. Two balls are drawn together. Find the probability that both are of the same colour.
- Total ways = 7C2 = 21.
- Both red: 3C2 = 3. Both blue: 4C2 = 6.
- Favourable = 3 + 6 = 9, so P = 9/21.
Answer: 3/7.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- When many balls are drawn together, use combinations. For two or three balls, use the sequential method.
- For at least one of a colour, find the probability of none of that colour and subtract from 1.
- For a mixed selection, multiply the combinations for each colour: for example 5C1 × 4C1 for one red and one blue.
- The probability that the second ball has a given colour is the same as for the first ball, if the first ball is not seen.
- Always check that the probabilities of all outcomes add up to 1.
Common Mistakes
- Using the same denominator for both draws. After a draw without replacement, the denominator falls by 1.
- Forgetting that drawing together is the same as drawing without replacement, and using independent probabilities.
- Counting only one order when the question allows both orders, such as red then blue or blue then red.
- Adding probabilities for two draws that should be multiplied, or multiplying for events that should be added.
- Using combinations for the favourable ways but permutations for the total, so the ratio is wrong.
Practice Questions
- A bag has 4 red and 6 blue balls. Two are drawn together. Probability that both are red?
- A bag has 5 red and 3 white balls. Two are drawn together. Probability of exactly one white?
- A bag has 3 red and 2 blue balls. Two balls are drawn with replacement. Probability that both are red?
- Balls numbered 1 to 10 are in a bag. Three are drawn together. Probability that all are even?
- A bag has 4 red and 6 blue balls. Three are drawn together. Probability that none is red?
- A bag has 3 red and 2 blue balls. Two are drawn without replacement. Probability that both are red?
Answers: 1) 2/15; 2) 15/28; 3) 9/25; 4) 1/12; 5) 1/6; 6) 3/10.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Frequent Bag problems appear in SSC CGL and CAT probability sets.
- Concept Teaches dependent events and the effect of removing items.
- Speed The combination method gives fast answers for many-ball draws.
- Link Same method is used in card problems, as in Probability Problems on Cards, Dice and Coins.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Probability Using the Complementary Event Rule. It shows how to use 1 minus the probability of the opposite event to shorten ball and dice problems.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Without replacement Drawn items are not put back
- With replacement Drawn items are put back before the next draw
- Dependent events Events where the first outcome changes the second
- nCr Number of ways of choosing r items from n
- Complement The event that the given event does not happen
Related Topics
- Probability Problems on Cards, Dice and Coins
- Probability Using the Complementary Event Rule
- Fundamental Principle of Counting (Addition and Multiplication Rules)
- Permutation of Distinct Objects and Objects with Repetition
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Drawing together equals drawing one after another without replacement.
- P = favourable combinations / total combinations.
- Sequential draws without replacement reduce the denominator by 1 each time.
- P(at least one) = 1 – P(none).
- All outcome probabilities add to 1.
Do Not Confuse With
- With vs without replacement With replacement keeps the bag the same; without replacement changes it after each draw.
- Combination vs permutation For drawing together, use combinations, because order does not matter.
- Independent vs dependent Draws without replacement are dependent.
- Add vs multiply Multiply for successive draws; add for different ways of the same outcome.
Memory Hook
Together means without replacement: choose, count and divide.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What does without replacement mean in probability?
Without replacement means a drawn item is not put back, so the number of items in the bag falls after every draw. The probability of later draws changes, and the draws are dependent, unlike draws with replacement where the bag is restored each time.
Is drawing two balls together the same as drawing without replacement?
Drawing two balls together gives the same probabilities as drawing them one after another without replacement. In both cases the second ball cannot be the first one, so either the combination method or the sequential method can be used to find the answer.
How do you find the probability of both balls being red?
Find the number of ways to choose both balls from the red balls and divide by the number of ways to choose any two balls. For 5 red balls out of 12, the probability is 5C2 divided by 12C2, which is 10 over 66, or 5/33.
How is at least one ball of a colour found quickly?
The probability of at least one ball of a colour is found by taking the probability that none of the balls drawn is that colour and subtracting it from 1. This complement method avoids adding several cases, and is much faster when many balls are drawn.
When should the combination method be used for ball problems?
The combination method is best when several balls are drawn together, because it counts favourable selections and total selections directly. The sequential method suits draws of two or three balls in order, where multiplying changing fractions is short and easy to check.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 Drawing two balls together gives the same probabilities as drawing them one after another without replacement.
The second ball cannot be the first, so the two methods agree.
2 From 5 red, 4 blue and 3 green balls, the probability that two balls drawn together are both red is 5/33.
5C2 = 10 and 12C2 = 66, so the probability is 10/66 = 5/33.
3 Draws without replacement are independent events.
The result of the first draw changes the bag, so the draws are dependent.
4 From 5 red, 4 blue and 3 green balls, the probability that three balls drawn together are all of different colours is 3/11.
The favourable ways are 5 x 4 x 3 = 60 and 12C3 = 220, so the probability is 60/220 = 3/11.
Related Topics
Browse the full Quantitative Aptitude index