Comparison of Surds of Different Orders
Quantitative Aptitude › Logarithms, Surds and Indices · Topic 14.5
To compare surds of different orders, such as a square root and a cube root, convert them to the same order by taking the LCM of the orders and raising each radicand to the matching power. The surd with the larger radicand under the common order is the larger number.
6 min read · Quantitative Aptitude · Logarithms, Surds and Indices
Quick Answer
To compare surds of different orders, such as a square root and a cube root, convert them to the same order by taking the LCM of the orders and raising each radicand to the matching power. The surd with the larger radicand under the common order is the larger number.
At a Glance
- Order The index of the root, such as 2 for √ and 3 for ∛
- Method Convert to the LCM of the orders
- Compare Larger radicand means larger surd
- Sums of surds Square both sides, then compare
- Same radicand Smaller order gives the larger value when the radicand exceeds 1
- Trap Do not compare radicands before making the order equal
Where Does It Fit?
This topic follows Simplification of Surds and Rationalization of Denominators and uses the fractional index rule from Laws of Indices and Exponents. It leads into Surd Equations – Solving for the Unknown Variable, where roots appear inside equations.
How Do You Compare Surds With Different Orders?
In short: the order of a surd is the index of its root. To compare √2, ∛3 and ⁴√5, write them all as 12th roots, and then compare the numbers under the root.
| Surd | Order | Multiply the order by | Radicand raised to the power | As a 12th root |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| √2 = 21/2 | 2 | 6 | 26 = 64 | ¹²√64 |
| ∛3 = 31/3 | 3 | 4 | 34 = 81 | ¹²√81 |
| ⁴√5 = 51/4 | 4 | 3 | 53 = 125 | ¹²√125 |
Since 64 < 81 < 125, the order is √2 < ∛3 < ⁴√5. A decimal check agrees: √2 is about 1.414, ∛3 about 1.442 and ⁴√5 about 1.495.
- Step 1: find the LCM of the orders. For 2, 3 and 4 it is 12.
- Step 2: raise each radicand to the power (LCM ÷ order).
- Step 3: compare the new radicands. The larger radicand gives the larger surd.
How Do You Compare Sums and Multiples of Surds?
In short: bring a coefficient inside the root, or square both sides when two sums of surds are compared. Both sides must be positive for squaring to keep the order.
| Comparison | Method | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3√2 and 2√5 | Move the coefficient inside | √18 and √20 | 2√5 is larger |
| √7 + √3 and 2√5 | Square both sides | 10 + 2√21 (about 19.17) and 20 | 2√5 is larger |
| √6 + √2 and √5 + √3 | Square both sides | 8 + 2√12 (about 14.93) and 8 + 2√15 (about 15.75) | √5 + √3 is larger |
Square rule
- If x and y are positive and x² < y², then x < y.
- (√a + √b)² = a + b + 2√(ab).
The squaring method also works with the difference of two surds, but remember that squaring a negative number loses the sign, so check that both sides are positive first. Related simplification steps appear in Simplification of Surds and Rationalization of Denominators.
What Special Cases Appear in Exams?
- Same radicand, different orders: for a radicand greater than 1, the smaller order gives the larger value, so √5 > ∛5 > ⁴√5.
- Radicand less than 1: the pattern reverses. For example ∛0.5 > √0.5, since 0.51/2 is about 0.707 and 0.51/3 is about 0.794, so the cube root is larger.
- Greatest or smallest of several: convert all to the common order once, and then rank them in a single pass.
- Same-order comparison: if the orders are equal, just compare the radicands directly.
Solved Examples
Example 1
Question: Arrange √2, ∛3 and ⁴√5 in increasing order.
- The LCM of 2, 3 and 4 is 12.
- √2 = 26/12, so the radicand is 26 = 64.
- ∛3 = 34/12, so the radicand is 34 = 81.
- ⁴√5 = 53/12, so the radicand is 53 = 125.
Answer: √2 < ∛3 < ⁴√5.
Example 2
Question: Arrange √3, ∛4 and ⁶√10 in decreasing order.
- The LCM of 2, 3 and 6 is 6.
- √3 = 33/6, so the radicand is 33 = 27.
- ∛4 = 42/6, so the radicand is 42 = 16.
- ⁶√10 has radicand 10. Rank 27 > 16 > 10.
Answer: √3 > ∛4 > ⁶√10.
Example 3
Question: Which is larger, √7 + √3 or 2√5?
- Both numbers are positive, so square them.
- (√7 + √3)² = 7 + 3 + 2√21 = 10 + 2√21, which is about 10 + 9.165 = 19.165.
- (2√5)² = 20.
- Since 20 > 19.165, the second number is larger.
Answer: 2√5 is larger.
Example 4
Question: Which is larger, √2 or ∛3?
- The LCM of 2 and 3 is 6.
- √2 = 23/6, with radicand 23 = 8.
- ∛3 = 32/6, with radicand 32 = 9.
Answer: ∛3 is larger, since 9 > 8.
Example 5
Question: Which is larger, 3√2 or 2√5?
- Move each coefficient inside the root: 3√2 = √18.
- 2√5 = √20.
- Compare 18 and 20.
Answer: 2√5 is larger.
Shortcuts and Tricks
- Find the LCM of the orders first. Doing this before any other step prevents most errors.
- When comparing a root with a coefficient, move the coefficient inside the root by squaring it.
- Use a decimal check with known values: √2 = 1.414, √3 = 1.732, √5 = 2.236, √7 = 2.646.
- For the sum of two roots against a single root, square both sides, since the cross term 2√(ab) is easy to estimate.
- Keep powers small by using the LCM and no larger common multiple.
Common Mistakes
- Comparing radicands such as 3 and 4 without first making the orders equal.
- Using the product of the orders instead of the LCM. It still works but makes numbers very large.
- Squaring when one side could be negative, which can reverse the inequality.
- Forgetting that for a radicand below 1 the larger order gives the larger value.
- Treating √a + √b as √(a + b) before comparing.
Practice Questions
- Which is larger, √5 or ∛11?
- Which is larger, ⁴√10 or ∛5?
- Which is larger, 5√3 or 4√5?
- Is √6 + √2 greater than √5 + √3?
- Which is smallest among √2, ∛3 and ⁶√6?
Answers: 1) √5, because 125 > 121; 2) ⁴√10, because 1000 > 625; 3) 4√5, because 80 > 75; 4) no, the second is larger; 5) ⁶√6, since 6 < 8 < 9.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Direct questions Ordering roots is a classic SSC and CAT question.
- Speed The LCM method works in under a minute.
- Foundation It reinforces fractional indices from Laws of Indices and Exponents.
- Estimation It trains the habit of checking an answer with a decimal.
What Comes Next?
The next topic is Solving Equations Involving Exponents and Logarithms. It uses indices and logarithms to solve equations in which the unknown is an exponent.
Key Terms and Formulas
- Order of a surd The index of the root
- Radicand The number under the root sign
- LCM of the orders The common order used for comparison
- Common order The single root index to which all surds are converted
- Square both sides The method to compare two sums of positive surds
- Coefficient The multiplier in front of a surd
Related Topics
- Simplification of Surds and Rationalization of Denominators
- Solving Equations Involving Exponents and Logarithms
- Laws of Indices and Exponents
- Laws of Logarithms and the Change of Base Rule
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Make the orders equal with the LCM before comparing radicands.
- Larger radicand under the same order means a larger surd.
- To compare sums of positive surds, square both sides.
- For a radicand greater than 1, a smaller order gives a larger value.
- Move a coefficient inside by squaring it: a√b = √(a²b).
Do Not Confuse With
- Order vs radicand The order is the root index, and the radicand is the number under the sign.
- LCM vs product Use the LCM of the orders, not their product, to keep numbers small.
- Sum vs product of surds √a + √b is not √(a + b), and squaring handles both sides correctly.
- Below 1 vs above 1 The comparison between roots reverses for a radicand less than 1.
Memory Hook
Same order first, then the bigger radicand wins.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you compare surds of different orders?
To compare surds of different orders, find the LCM of their orders and rewrite each surd as a root of that order. Raise each radicand to the power of the LCM divided by its own order, and the surd with the larger new radicand is the larger number.
What is the order of a surd?
The order of a surd is the index of its root. A square root has order 2, a cube root has order 3 and a fourth root has order 4. Surds can be compared directly only when they have the same order, so a common order is found first.
Which is larger, root 2 or cube root 3?
The cube root of 3 is larger than the square root of 2. With a common order of 6, the square root of 2 becomes the sixth root of 8, and the cube root of 3 becomes the sixth root of 9, and 9 is greater than 8.
How do you compare the sum of two surds with a single surd?
To compare a sum of surds with a single surd, square both sides, since both are positive. For root 7 plus root 3 and twice root 5, the squares are about 19.17 and 20, so twice root 5 is the larger value.
Does the larger order always give the smaller value?
For a radicand greater than 1, a larger order gives a smaller value, so the square root of 5 is greater than the cube root of 5. For a radicand between 0 and 1 the pattern reverses, so the cube root of 0.5 is greater than its square root.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 The cube root of 3 is greater than the square root of 2.
Over a common order of 6, the radicands are 9 and 8.
2 The fourth root of 5 is smaller than the square root of 2.
Over a common order of 4, the fourth root of 5 is 5 and the square root of 2 is 2² = 4, so the fourth root of 5 is larger.
3 2√5 is greater than √7 + √3.
Squaring gives 20 and about 19.17.
4 For a radicand greater than 1, a larger order gives a larger value.
A larger order gives a smaller value, as in √5 > ∛5.
Related Topics
Browse the full Quantitative Aptitude index