An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 13.5

Land Revenue Policy: Mahalwari System

Modern History › Economic Policies of the British · Topic 13.5

The Mahalwari system was a system of land revenue in which the revenue was settled with the village or estate, jointly responsible for its payment. Regulation VII of 1822 introduced it in the North-Western Provinces, and Merttins Bird and Thomason improved it. It was used in the North-West Provinces, Punjab and Central Provinces, covering about 30 per cent of British India.

Share:
Land Revenue Policy: Mahalwari System - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Introduced Regulation VII of 1822
  • Settled with Village or estate (mahal)
  • Area North-West Provinces, Punjab, Central Provinces
  • Share About 30 per cent of British India
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Economic Policies of the British

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 13.5 of the category “Economic Policies of the British”. Previous topic: Land Revenue Policy: Ryotwari System.

What Was the Mahalwari System?

The Mahalwari system was a land revenue system in which the revenue was settled with the village community, or mahal, whose members were jointly responsible for payment. It was recommended by Holt Mackenzie in 1819 and formally introduced by Regulation VII of 1822 in the North-Western Provinces, and improved by Robert Merttins Bird in 1833, whose work in Saharanpur became the model, and later by James Thomason. It was extended to the Punjab, Central Provinces and Awadh, and covered about 30 per cent of the area under British rule.

What Were Its Main Features?

Feature Detail
Settlement with The village or estate, through headmen or landlords
Revenue Originally 80 per cent of the rental, reduced to about 66 per cent in 1833 and 50 per cent later
Records Careful survey and records of each field and right
Revision Every twenty to thirty years
Responsibility The whole village was jointly liable
Area North-West Provinces, Punjab, Central Provinces

How Did It Work in Practice?

The system tried to avoid the faults of the Permanent Settlement and the Ryotwari system by recognising village communities, but in practice the revenue was heavy and the share of the Government was high. The landlords or headmen who paid the revenue often became owners, and the position of tenants was weak. Revenue assessments were made at long intervals, and the rigid collection caused indebtedness, which led to the loss of land to moneylenders.

How Did Ruralisation Affect Agriculture?

The ruin of artisans, described in Deindustrialisation: Ruin of Artisans and Handicraftsmen, drove many to villages and into agriculture. This increased pressure on land and upset the village economic set-up. An overburdened agriculture was a major cause of poverty during British rule.

What Did Revenue Policy Do to the Peasant?

The government, interested only in maximising rents and securing its share of the revenue, enforced the Permanent Settlement in large parts of the country. A key feature of the new settlement was transferability of land, which caused great insecurity to tenants, who lost all their traditional rights in land. The government spent little on improving the productivity of land.

Group Effect on the peasant
Zamindars With increased powers, they resorted to summary evictions and demanded illegal dues and begar to maximise their share of the produce, and had no incentive to invest in improving agriculture
Moneylenders The overburdened peasant had to go to the moneylender to pay the zamindar’s dues; the moneylender, often also the village grain merchant, forced the farmer to sell produce at low prices to clear his debts, and could manipulate the judiciary and the law in his favour
Government Took its revenue share, and spent little on land improvement

Who Bore the Triple Burden?

The peasant became the ultimate sufferer under the triple burden of the government, the zamindar and the moneylender, and his hardship increased at times of famine and scarcity. This was as true of zamindari areas as of areas under the Ryotwari and Mahalwari systems. The peasant became landless. As an analytical point, in each system the peasant faced a different mix of the three pressures, but the common element was that the claim of the state and of intermediaries on the produce was fixed or rising while the peasant’s own income depended on weather and prices, which made debt and loss of land likely in any bad year.

What Was the Impact on Village Society?

The changes altered the village. The tenant who had once held land by custom now held it at the will of the zamindar, or of the purchaser who had bought the zamindari at auction, so security of tenure, the basis of the peasant’s life, was gone. The relation between the cultivator and the landlord, which in earlier times had included duties on both sides, became a contract of rent and payment, enforced by courts to which the moneylender had easier access than the peasant. Debt moved land from the farmer to the lender, and in a land shortage, since displaced artisans were also looking for land, rents rose. As an analytical point, the main change was in who bore the risk: under older arrangements the risk of a bad harvest was shared among the village, the ruler and the cultivator, whereas under the new system the cultivator carried it almost alone, and so a failed monsoon could mean loss of land or life. This is the setting for the famines described in Famines and Poverty Under British Rule.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Facts The 1822 Regulation and the areas are asked
  • Contrast Compared with the other systems
  • Effects Revenue and indebtedness

What Came Next?

Next topic: Land Revenue Policy: Permanent Settlement (Zamindari System).

Key People and Terms

  • Mahal A village or an estate
  • Mahalwari Settlement with the village
  • Holt Mackenzie Recommended the system
  • Merttins Bird Improved it in 1833
  • Thomason Lieutenant-Governor of the NWP
  • Joint liability Shared responsibility for revenue

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Regulation VII of 1822.
  • Settled with the village.
  • North-West Provinces, Punjab.
  • About 30 per cent of the area.
  • Improved by Merttins Bird.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Mahalwari and Ryotwari Village versus cultivator
  • Mahalwari and Permanent Settlement Village community versus zamindar
  • Holt Mackenzie and Munro North versus south

Memory Hook

Mackenzie’s mahal pays together.

Mains Angle

Questions ask for a comparison of the three revenue systems. Use these points.

  • Community Village jointly liable
  • Records Detailed survey
  • Burden Heavy revenue

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Compare the Mahalwari system with the Ryotwari and Permanent Settlement systems.”

How to Answer

  1. Introduce The three systems.
  2. Mahalwari Features.
  3. Comparison Differences.
  4. Conclude Effects.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Economic Policies of the British. GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Mahalwari system?

The Mahalwari system was a system of land revenue in which the revenue was settled with the village community, which was jointly responsible for payment, in the North-Western Provinces, Punjab and parts of central India.

When was the Mahalwari system introduced?

The Mahalwari system was introduced formally by Regulation VII of 1822 in the North-Western Provinces, after a proposal by Holt Mackenzie in 1819, and revised by Merttins Bird in 1833. This answer belongs to the topic "Land Revenue Policy: Mahalwari System" in the macro "Economic Policies of the British".

What area was under the Mahalwari system?

About 30 per cent of the area under British rule was under the Mahalwari system, mainly in the North-West Provinces, the Punjab and the Central Provinces. This answer belongs to the topic "Land Revenue Policy: Mahalwari System" in the macro "Economic Policies of the British".

How did Mahalwari differ from Ryotwari?

In the Mahalwari system the revenue was settled with the village as a whole, while in the Ryotwari system it was settled with each cultivator separately. This answer belongs to the topic "Land Revenue Policy: Mahalwari System" in the macro "Economic Policies of the British".

What were the effects of the Mahalwari system?

The system gave the Government a regular income and good land records, but the revenue demand was heavy and tenants had weak rights, so that many peasants became indebted. This answer belongs to the topic "Land Revenue Policy: Mahalwari System" in the macro "Economic Policies of the British".

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Mahalwari system was introduced in 1822.
True

By Regulation VII.

2 It was a settlement with individual cultivators.
False

With villages.

3 It covered the North-West Provinces.
True

And the Punjab.

4 It was introduced by Cornwallis.
False

He began the Permanent Settlement.

5 The whole village was jointly liable.
True

For the revenue.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Economic Policies of the British. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: