An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 3.3

Judicial System Under Early British Administration

Modern History › Pre-1857 British Administration and Its Impact · Topic 3.3

The early British judicial system was built by Warren Hastings (1772 to 1785), who set up district Diwani and Fauzdari courts and the Sadar Diwani and Sadar Nizamat Adalats, and by Cornwallis (1786 to 1793), who separated revenue from justice and issued the Cornwallis Code on the principle of rule of law. Bentinck later reformed the structure. The Supreme Court at Calcutta had come in 1773.

Share:
Judicial System Under Early British Administration - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Hastings District Diwani and Fauzdari courts, 1772
  • Supreme Court Calcutta, under the Regulating Act of 1773
  • Cornwallis Code of 1793; separation of revenue and justice
  • Bentinck Reorganised courts and used Indian judges
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: Pre-1857 British Administration and Its Impact

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 3.3 of the category “Pre-1857 British Administration and Its Impact”. Previous topic: The Charter Acts (1793, 1813, 1833, 1853) and Their Administrative Provisions.

What Was the Judicial System Before the British?

In pre-colonial India, in the Mughal era and earlier, the judicial system neither adopted proper procedures nor had a regular gradation of courts from highest to lowest or courts distributed in proportion to the area they served. Most litigation among Hindus was decided by caste elders, village panchayats or zamindars. For Muslims the unit of judicial administration was the qazi, an office held by religious persons, located in provincial capitals, towns and qasbas. Rajas and badshahs were the fountainhead of justice, and the process could be arbitrary.

How Did the Common Law System Begin?

The beginning of a common law system based on recorded judicial precedents can be traced to the establishment of the Mayor’s Courts at Madras, Bombay and Calcutta in 1726 by the East India Company. As the Company changed from a trading company into a ruling power, new elements of a judicial system replaced the existing Mughal legal system.

What Did Warren Hastings Do, 1772-1785?

Court Details
District Diwani Adalats Established to try civil disputes, under the collector; Hindu law applied to Hindus and Muslim law to Muslims; appeals went to the Sadar Diwani Adalat, which functioned under a president and two members of the Supreme Council
District Fauzdari Adalats Set up to try criminal disputes, under an Indian officer assisted by qazis and muftis, with general supervision by the collector; Muslim law was administered
Sadar Nizamat Adalat At Murshidabad, headed by a deputy nizam (an Indian Muslim) assisted by the chief qazi and chief mufti; approved capital punishment and the acquisition of property
Supreme Court Established at Calcutta under the Regulating Act of 1773; competent to try all British subjects within Calcutta and the subordinate factories, including Indians and Europeans; original and appellate jurisdictions

The jurisdiction of the Supreme Court often clashed with that of the other courts. The Regulating Act is covered in Constitutional Development 1773-1858: Regulating Act to the Act of 1858.

As an analytical point, Hastings’s scheme kept the existing personal laws and Indian officers in the criminal courts, while placing the courts under the collector, so that the revenue and judicial functions were still joined, a feature that was removed in the next phase, in Judicial Reforms Under Cornwallis and Bentinck. The first police arrangements of the same years are in Evolution of the Police System in Modern India.

What Did Cornwallis Do, 1786-1793?

Under Cornwallis the District Fauzdari Courts were abolished and replaced by circuit courts at Calcutta, Dacca, Murshidabad and Patna. These had European judges and acted as courts of appeal in both civil and criminal cases. The Sadar Nizamat Adalat was moved to Calcutta and placed under the Governor-General and members of the Supreme Council, assisted by the chief qazi and chief mufti. The District Diwani Adalat became the District, City or Zila Court under a district judge, and the collector became responsible only for revenue, without magisterial functions.

Gradation of civil courts Level
1 Munsiff’s Court, under Indian officers
2 Registrar’s Court, under a European judge
3 District Court, under the district judge
4 Four Circuit Courts, as provincial courts of appeal
5 Sadar Diwani Adalat at Calcutta
6 King-in-Council for appeals of 5,000 pounds and above

What Was the Cornwallis Code?

  • It separated revenue administration from the administration of justice.
  • European subjects were also brought under the jurisdiction of the courts.
  • Government officials were answerable to the civil courts for actions done in their official capacity.
  • The principle of the sovereignty of law was established.

His reforms of the civil services are in Evolution of the Civil Services: Cornwallis to the Charter Act of 1853, and the court system he reformed in Judicial Reforms Under Warren Hastings.

What Did Bentinck Do, 1828-1833?

Bentinck abolished the four Circuit Courts and transferred their functions to collectors under the supervision of the commissioner of revenue and circuit. A Sadar Diwani Adalat and a Sadar Nizamat Adalat were set up at Allahabad for the convenience of people in the Upper Provinces. Until then Persian was the official language of the courts; now a suitor could use Persian or a vernacular language, while English replaced Persian in the Supreme Court.

In 1833 a Law Commission was set up under Macaulay for the codification of Indian laws. It led to a Civil Procedure Code (1859), an Indian Penal Code (1860) and a Criminal Procedure Code (1861).

What Was the Overall Character of the Early Judicial System?

The early British courts replaced a system of personal and religious law with courts organised by territory. Warren Hastings built district courts and appellate courts at Calcutta, Cornwallis separated revenue and justice and issued a Code, and Bentinck reformed the structure, giving a larger place to Indian judges. The change brought rule of law in form, but costs, delays and English procedure made courts inaccessible to many Indians.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Reforms Hastings and Cornwallis are matched with their judicial steps
  • Principle The Cornwallis Code introduced rule of law
  • Link It connects to the civil service and the Regulating Act

What Came Next?

Next topic: Charter Act of 1813: one-way free trade Tariffs Nearly 80 per…">Impact of British Administration: Industrialization and Ruin of Artisans and Handicraftsmen.

Key People and Terms

  • Sadar Diwani Adalat Chief civil appellate court
  • Sadar Nizamat Adalat Chief criminal appellate court
  • Fauzdari Adalat District criminal court
  • Mayor’s Court Court set up in 1726 in the presidency towns
  • Cornwallis Code 1793 code of regulations
  • Rule of law Principle that officials are bound by law

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Mayor’s Courts: 1726.
  • Hastings: courts in 1772.
  • Supreme Court: 1773.
  • Cornwallis Code: 1793.
  • Bentinck: 1828 to 1835.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Diwani and Fauzdari Adalat Civil and criminal courts
  • Hastings and Cornwallis Hastings built the court structure; Cornwallis added the Code and separation of powers
  • Supreme Court and Sadar Adalat The Supreme Court was a Crown court at Calcutta; the Sadar Adalats were Company courts

Memory Hook

Hastings builds the courts, Cornwallis writes the code, Bentinck cleans the house.

Mains Angle

Questions ask about the strengths and weaknesses of the judicial system. Use these points.

  • Strength Rule of law and uniform procedure
  • Weakness Costly, slow and complex for the poor
  • Indians Judges and legal officers were few at the top

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Describe the evolution of the judicial system under early British rule and evaluate its impact.”

How to Answer

  1. Introduce Courts before the British.
  2. Hastings District courts and Supreme Court.
  3. Cornwallis and Bentinck The Code and reforms.
  4. Conclude Rule of law and its limits.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, Pre-1857 British Administration and Its Impact. GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

How was justice administered before the British?

Hindu disputes were mostly decided by caste elders, village panchayats or zamindars, and Muslim cases by qazis in capitals, towns and large villages. Rajas and badshahs were the fountainhead of justice, and the procedure could be arbitrary, without a regular gradation of courts.

What were the Mayor's Courts?

They were courts set up by the East India Company at Madras, Bombay and Calcutta in 1726. They mark the beginning of a common law system in India, based on recorded judicial precedents, which gradually replaced the Mughal legal system.

What did Warren Hastings's civil courts look like?

He established District Diwani Adalats under the collector to try civil disputes, applying Hindu law to Hindus and Muslim law to Muslims, with appeals going to the Sadar Diwani Adalat, which worked under a president and two members of the Supreme Council.

What were the main judicial reforms of Cornwallis?

Cornwallis separated revenue administration from justice, replaced the Fauzdari courts with circuit courts staffed by European judges, graded the civil courts from the Munsiff to the Sadar Diwani Adalat, and brought officials and Europeans under the courts through the Cornwallis Code.

What were the principles of the Cornwallis Code?

It separated revenue and justice, brought European subjects under the jurisdiction of the courts, made government officials answerable to the civil courts for official acts, and established the principle of the sovereignty of law, which became a basis of the later judicial system.

What did Bentinck do for the judiciary?

Bentinck abolished the four circuit courts and gave their functions to collectors under a commissioner, set up Sadar courts at Allahabad, allowed suitors to use a vernacular language instead of Persian, and replaced Persian by English in the Supreme Court.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Mayor's Courts were established in 1726.
True

At Madras, Bombay and Calcutta.

2 The Sadar Nizamat Adalat was established at Murshidabad under Hastings.
True

A deputy nizam headed it.

3 The Supreme Court at Calcutta was established under the Regulating Act of 1773.
True

Its jurisdiction clashed with other courts.

4 The Cornwallis Code separated revenue administration from the administration of justice.
True

It also made officials answerable to civil courts.

5 Bentinck established circuit courts in Bengal.
False

Cornwallis established them; Bentinck abolished them.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under Pre-1857 British Administration and Its Impact. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: