Discontent Among Sepoys as a Cause of the Revolt of 1857
Modern History › The Revolt of 1857 · Topic 4.6
The sepoys of the Bengal Army were discontented before 1857. They faced racial discrimination, low pay and little promotion, interference in religion, the withdrawal of foreign service allowance (bhatta) in Sindh and Punjab, the General Service Enlistment Act of 1856 requiring service overseas, and the annexation of Awadh, the home of many of them. As peasants in uniform, they linked the army to the countryside.
5 min read · UPSC Prelims · History · The Revolt of 1857
At a Glance
- Law General Service Enlistment Act, 1856
- Allowance Bhatta withdrawn in Sindh and Punjab
- Awadh Annexation hurt many sepoys’ homes
- Idea Sepoy as a peasant in uniform
- Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: The Revolt of 1857
Where Does It Fit?
This is topic 4.6 of the category “The Revolt of 1857”. Previous topic: Influence of Outside Events on the Revolt of 1857.
Why Were the Sepoys Discontented?
The conditions of service in the Company’s army and cantonments increasingly came into conflict with the religious beliefs and prejudices of the sepoys. Restrictions on wearing caste and sectarian marks, and secret rumours of the proselytising activities of chaplains, often maintained at Indian expense, were taken by the generally conservative sepoys as interference in their religion.
| Grievance | Detail |
|---|---|
| Caste and religion | To the religious Hindu of the time, crossing the seas meant loss of caste |
| Enlistment Act | In 1856 Lord Canning’s government passed the General Service Enlistment Act, under which all future recruits to the Bengal Army had to undertake to serve anywhere required |
| Pay | The sepoy was unhappy with his emoluments compared to his British counterpart |
| Bhatta | A more immediate cause: the order that they would not get foreign service allowance (bhatta) in Sindh or Punjab |
| Awadh | The annexation of Awadh, home of many of the sepoys, further inflamed their feelings |
| Racial discrimination | The sepoy was made to feel subordinate at every step and was discriminated against in promotion and privileges |
The discontent of the sepoys was not limited to military matters; it reflected the general disenchantment with British rule. The sepoy was, in fact, a peasant in uniform whose consciousness was not divorced from that of the rural population. As S. Gopal observed, the army voiced grievances other than its own, and the movement spread beyond the army.
How Did the Sepoy’s Position Compare With the European Soldier’s?
| Point | Position of the Indian sepoy |
|---|---|
| Pay | Lower than that of the European soldier, with little chance of advancement |
| Promotion | Indian officers ranked below the youngest European officer, and senior posts were closed to Indians |
| Status | Treated as subordinate at every step in daily life |
| Allowances | Foreign service allowance withdrawn for Sindh and Punjab |
Why Was the Bengal Army the First to Rise?
The Bengal Army drew most of its recruits from Awadh and Bihar and from high-caste Hindus. Its members felt hurt by the annexation of Awadh, by the loss of allowances and by the threat of service across the seas under the General Service Enlistment Act of 1856. When the cartridge issue appeared, these grievances were already strong. The Bombay and Madras armies were less affected and mostly did not rise.
How Did Army Discontent Become a Mass Revolt?
The sepoy was a peasant in uniform. His family still lived in the village and paid the revenue, and so his grievance was linked to the larger grievances of the countryside. As S. Gopal observed, the army voiced grievances other than its own, which is why the mutiny of the soldiers became the first phase of a much wider revolt.
What Was the History of Army Revolts?
There had been a long history of revolts in the British Indian army: in Bengal (1764), Vellore (1806), Barrackpore (1824) and during the Afghan Wars (1839-42). These are described in Sepoy Mutinies Before 1857. As an analytical point, the grievances of 1857 differ from the earlier mutinies in one respect: the General Service Enlistment Act and the annexation of Awadh affected the whole Bengal Army at once, while earlier mutinies were confined to single units.
How Did Caste Shape Army Life?
The Bengal Army recruited high-caste Brahmans and Rajputs in large numbers, and the Company had long taken care to respect their caste rules, with separate cooking and no service across the sea. Any change in these rules felt like an attack on status, which is why the Enlistment Act of 1856 and the new cartridge caused such alarm among them.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Immediate cause The sepoys’ discontent is the military cause of 1857
- Act The Enlistment Act is a favourite fact
- Link It leads to the cartridge incident
What Came Next?
Next topic: Centres and Spread of the Revolt of 1857.
Key People and Terms
- Sepoy An Indian soldier in the Company’s army
- Bhatta Foreign service allowance
- General Service Enlistment Act 1856 law on service anywhere
- Peasant in uniform The sepoy seen as a villager under arms
- Bengal Army The largest army of the Company, drawn from Awadh and Bihar
- Cantonment A military station
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Enlistment Act: 1856, service anywhere.
- Bhatta withdrawn in Sindh and Punjab.
- Awadh annexation hurt the sepoys.
- Sepoy = peasant in uniform.
- Bengal Army rose first.
Do Not Confuse With
- Sepoy and sowar Sepoy is infantry; sowar is cavalry
- Bengal, Bombay and Madras armies The Bengal Army was the main rebel force
- Bhatta and pay Bhatta is an extra allowance for foreign service
Memory Hook
Pay, bhatta and Awadh: the sepoy’s three wounds.
Mains Angle
Questions ask why the sepoys rose. Use these points.
- Service Pay, promotion and allowances
- Religion Caste and religious interference
- Village link The sepoy shared the grievances of the countryside
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“Why were the sepoys of the Bengal Army discontented before 1857?”
How to Answer
- Introduce The Bengal Army.
- Grievances Pay, bhatta, Enlistment Act.
- Awadh Annexation.
- Conclude Peasant in uniform.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
Why were the sepoys unhappy before 1857?
Sepoys faced restrictions on caste marks, rumours of proselytising chaplains, lower pay than British soldiers, denial of bhatta in Sindh and Punjab, racial discrimination, and the General Service Enlistment Act of 1856. The annexation of Awadh, home to many sepoys, also angered them.
What was the General Service Enlistment Act of 1856?
Under this Act, passed by Lord Canning's government, all future recruits to the Bengal Army had to undertake to serve anywhere the government required. Hindus resented it since crossing the seas meant loss of caste.
What does "peasant in uniform" mean?
It describes the sepoy as a peasant by background, whose consciousness was not divorced from that of the rural population. As S. Gopal observed, the army voiced grievances other than its own, and the movement spread beyond the army.
Why did the annexation of Awadh anger the sepoys?
Awadh was the home of many of the Company's sepoys, so its annexation in 1856 further inflamed their feelings. Along with the denial of bhatta and the Enlistment Act, it added to the grievances that surfaced in 1857.
Why was the Bengal Army the centre of the revolt?
The Bengal Army drew most of its soldiers from Awadh and Bihar and from high-caste Hindus. It was affected by the annexation of Awadh, the Enlistment Act and the loss of allowances, and it was the first to rise in 1857, while the Bombay and Madras armies largely stayed loyal.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 Sepoys received foreign service allowance in Sindh and Punjab before 1857.
The government denied them bhatta there.
2 The General Service Enlistment Act was passed in 1856.
It applied to future recruits of the Bengal Army.
3 The phrase "peasant in uniform" describes the sepoy.
His outlook was close to that of the rural population.
4 Social reforms such as the abolition of sati were welcomed by most Indians as protection.
A large section saw them as outside interference.
5 The sepoys received bhatta for service in Punjab.
It was withdrawn.
Past Mains Questions on This Topic
This topic comes under The Revolt of 1857. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:
Related Topics
Browse the full Modern History index