An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 17.2

Causes of the Decline of the Mughal Empire

Modern History › India on the Eve of British Conquest · Topic 17.2

The Mughal Empire declined because of weak rulers, wars of succession, quarrelling nobles, a failing army, a vast and unwieldy empire, Aurangzeb's religious and Deccan policies, foreign invasions and an economic and jagir crisis. Historians differ on which cause mattered most.

Share:
Causes of the Decline of the Mughal Empire - Modern History - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • What it is The reasons for the fall of the Mughal Empire in the eighteenth century
  • Two views Empire-related (Mughal-centric) and region-related
  • Eight standard causes Personal despotism, succession wars, nobility, army, vast empire, religious policy, Deccan policy, invasions
  • Key scholars Satish Chandra, Irfan Habib, William Irvine, Sidney Owen and Jadunath Sarkar
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims, Modern History: India on the Eve of British Conquest

Where Does It Fit?

This is topic 17.2 of the category “India on the Eve of British Conquest”. Previous topic: External and Internal Challenges Before the Mughal Empire After Aurangzeb.

How Do Historians View the Decline?

Why the Mughal Empire declined has long been debated by historians. Scholarly opinion falls into two broad lines. The empire-related or Mughal-centric view finds the causes in the structure and working of the empire itself. The region-related view finds the causes in the turmoil and instability in different parts of the empire. The decline was due to both aspects.

The break-up began in the reign of Aurangzeb but picked up speed only after his death in 1707. At his death the process of decline could still have been checked. Several chiefs challenged Mughal authority, but none could assert independence in the face of imperial might. The Sikhs, Marathas and Rajputs lacked the capacity to overthrow the empire. They merely resisted Mughal power to gain and keep independence in their own territories. If Aurangzeb’s successors had been capable, the empire might not have fallen. Most of them were incapable, weak and licentious, and they hastened its collapse.

What Were the Main Causes in Brief?

Cause Explanation
Personal despotism The government depended on the character of the ruler, and the later Mughals were worthless and neglected administration
No law of succession There was always a war of succession, which weakened stability and put partisanship above patriotism
Degenerate nobility The decay of rulers led to a decay of nobles, whose factional quarrels and intrigues cost the empire heavily
Deterioration of the army It proved disastrous for the empire
Too vast an empire It was too large to be run from a centre by weak rulers, given the transport and communications of the time
Aurangzeb’s religious policy It was largely responsible for revolts of Rajputs, Sikhs, Jats and Marathas
Aurangzeb’s Deccan policy A complete failure and an important cause of the fall; it also kept the emperor away from the capital for long
Invasions The invasions of Irani (Persian) and Durrani (Afghan) kingdoms gave a death-blow

What Did Different Historians Argue?

  • Satish Chandra The roots of disintegration lie in the medieval Indian economy, its stagnation in trade, industry and science, and the crisis of the jagirdari system, which hit every branch of state activity. Nobles could not fulfil their ambitions in imperial service and so factions struggled and ambitious nobles bid for independent rule. The emperors could not fit the Marathas into the Mughal framework, so the attempt to build a composite ruling class broke down. Personal failings counted, but within these deeper impersonal factors
  • Irfan Habib The seventeenth- and early eighteenth-century authorities put the greatest weight on economic and administrative causes of the upheaval and knew little of religious reaction or national consciousness. No new order was or could be created by the forces ranged against the empire
  • William Irvine Military inefficiency was the principal, if not the only, cause of the final collapse. The empire had lost military energy at the centre long before its end, and it was doomed before Nadir, Abdali, Dupleix or Clive appeared
  • Sidney Owen The empire was ruined in Aurangzeb’s reign by his reversal of Akbar’s policy of ignoring distinctions of race and religion and by reimposing jaziya. This turned the Rajputs into enemies, while Shivaji and his followers destroyed the empire’s military reputation, exhausted its treasure and created a state within a state. Nadir Shah then completed the humiliation
  • Jadunath Sarkar The fall of the Mughal Empire and of Maratha overlordship came from rottenness at the core of Indian society, shown in military and political helplessness, depraved or weak royalty, selfish nobles and corruption in the public services

These views emphasise, respectively, economy and the jagirdari system, military weakness, religious policy, and social decay. As an analytical point, none of them excludes the others: the decline had political, economic, military and social strands at once.

Why Did Rajputs and Others Turn Away?

Powerful regional groups such as the Jats, Sikhs and Marathas defied Mughal authority in Aurangzeb’s own time, in their bid to create kingdoms of their own. They did not succeed then, but they shaped political events in their regions, and their continuous struggle weakened the empire considerably.

Aurangzeb, and after him Bahadur Shah I, tried to suppress the Rajputs, which spurred them to fight the Mughals. Later Mughals tried reconciliation, but it was too late: the Rajputs no longer trusted the Mughals enough to ally with them for the good of the empire.

Who Were the Later Mughal Emperors?

Emperor Period Key points
Bahadur Shah I Till February 1712 After a nearly two-year war of succession the 63-year-old Prince Muazzam became emperor. He killed his brothers Muhammad Azam and Kam Bakhsh, adopted a peaceful policy with the Marathas, Rajputs and Jats, freed the Maratha prince Shahu, and acted against the Sikh leader Banda Bahadur
Jahandar Shah March 1712 to February 1713 Came to the throne with the help of Zulfikar Khan, who as prime minister introduced the izara system to improve finances; abolished jaziya
Farrukhsiyar 1713 to 1719 Killed Jahandar Shah with the help of the Sayyid brothers, Abdulla Khan and Hussain Ali, known as king makers; abolished jaziya and the pilgrimage tax; gave farmans to the British in 1717; deposed in 1719 by the Sayyid brothers with the help of Peshwa Balaji Vishwanath, then blinded and killed, the first time a Mughal emperor was killed by his nobles
Rafi-ud-Darajat 28 February to 4 June 1719 Ruled for the shortest period among the Mughals
Rafi-ud-Daula (Shah Jahan II) 6 June to 17 September 1719 An opium addict placed on the throne by the Sayyid brothers
Muhammad Shah 1719 to 1748 Called Rangeela for his luxurious life; killed the Sayyid brothers with the help of Nizam-ul-Mulk, who became wazir in 1724 and founded the independent state of Hyderabad; Baji Rao I invaded Delhi in 1737 with a small army of 500 horsemen; Nadir Shah defeated him at Karnal in 1739
Ahmad Shah 1748 to 1754 Incompetent; left affairs to the Queen Mother, Udham Bai, who ruled with the eunuch Javid Khan
Alamgir II 1754 to 1758 Grandson of Jahandar Shah; Abdali reached Delhi in January 1757; the Battle of Plassey was fought in June 1757
Shahjahan III 1758 to 1759 Short reign
Shah Alam II 1759 to 1806 Third Battle of Panipat (1761) and Battle of Buxar (1764); under the Treaty of Allahabad (August 1765) taken under Company protection; granted the Diwani of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa in perpetuity

How Did the Empire Become a Pensioner?

In 1772 the Marathas took Shah Alam II to Delhi, where he lived till 1803. In 1803, after the English defeated Daulat Rao Scindia, he again accepted English protection. After that, the Mughal emperors became pensioners of the English.

  • Akbar II (1806-37) He gave the title of Raja to Rammohan Roy. In 1835 the coins bearing the names of Mughal emperors were stopped
  • Bahadur Shah II (1837-57) Also called Bahadur Shah Zafar, the last Mughal emperor. The Revolt of 1857 made a futile attempt to declare him Emperor of India. He was captured by the English and sent to Rangoon, where he died in 1862

In legal terms the Mughal Empire ended on 1 November 1858, with the declaration of Queen Victoria. That Proclamation followed the Government of India Act, 1858, which passed the Company’s rule to the Crown.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Mains favourite Questions on the decline of the Mughals appear often and expect the historians’ views
  • Direct facts Aurangzeb’s religious and Deccan policies and the role of the Rajputs are standard items
  • Foundation for later topics The causes explain the rise of successor states and the Company’s opening

What Came Next?

Next topic: Shifting Allegiance of Zamindars and the Jagirdari Crisis.

Key People and Terms

  • Mughal-centric view The view that causes of decline lie in the empire’s own structure
  • Region-related view The view that causes lie in instability within the provinces
  • Jagirdari system The system of assigning land revenue to nobles in return for service
  • Primogeniture The rule that the eldest son succeeds, absent in Mughal succession
  • Imperium in imperio A state within a state, as one historian described the Maratha power
  • Composite ruling class A ruling group made up of different communities and regions

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Decline began under Aurangzeb and gathered speed after 1707.
  • Two views: empire-related and region-related.
  • No law of succession led to repeated wars of succession.
  • Aurangzeb’s religious policy and Deccan policy are both causes.
  • Scholars: Satish Chandra, Irfan Habib, Irvine, Owen, Sarkar.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Satish Chandra and Irfan Habib Chandra stresses the jagirdari crisis; Habib stresses economic and administrative causes noted by contemporaries
  • Irvine and Owen Irvine blames military inefficiency; Owen blames Aurangzeb’s religious policy and the Marathas
  • Aurangzeb’s religious and Deccan policies One alienated Rajputs, Sikhs, Jats and Marathas; the other kept him away from the capital

Memory Hook

Weak kings, quarrelling nobles, empty treasury, and invaders at the gate.

Mains Angle

Questions usually ask for causes and for a view on the debate. These points add depth.

  • Multi-cause approach The decline had political, military, economic and social causes together
  • Aurangzeb’s role His religious and Deccan policies are blamed, though the process picked up after 1707
  • Region versus centre Regional turmoil combined with weakness at the centre

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Discuss the causes of the decline of the Mughal Empire and the views of historians on them.”

How to Answer

  1. Explain the debate Introduce the empire-related and region-related views.
  2. List causes Give the eight standard causes with examples.
  3. Add historians Mention Chandra, Habib, Irvine, Owen and Sarkar briefly.
  4. Conclude Say that no single cause explains the fall.

GS Relevance

Prelims: Modern Indian History, India on the Eve of British Conquest. GS Paper 1: Modern Indian history from the middle of the eighteenth century until the present.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the Mughal Empire decline?

The Mughal Empire declined because of weak successors, wars of succession, quarrelling nobles, a failing army, an over-large empire, Aurangzeb's religious and Deccan policies, foreign invasions and an economic and jagir crisis. Historians differ on which cause mattered most.

What are the two views on the decline of the Mughals?

The empire-related or Mughal-centric view finds the causes in the structure and working of the empire itself, while the region-related view finds them in the turmoil and instability in different parts of the empire. The decline was due to both aspects.

How did Aurangzeb's policies contribute to the decline?

Aurangzeb's religious policy led to revolts by Rajputs, Sikhs, Jats and Marathas, and his Deccan policy was a complete failure that kept him away from the capital for a long time. Both are listed among the main causes of the empire's downfall.

Why did wars of succession weaken the Mughals?

The Mughals had no definite law of succession, so every reign ended in a war of succession. These wars weakened the stability of government and encouraged partisanship at the cost of patriotism, and they drained the empire of men and money.

What did William Irvine say about the fall of the Mughals?

William Irvine argued that military inefficiency was the principal, if not the only, cause of the empire's final collapse. He held that the empire had lost military energy at the centre long before it fell and was doomed before Nadir Shah, Abdali, Dupleix or Clive appeared.

What was the jagirdari crisis?

The jagirdari crisis was the shortage of land to give as jagirs to a growing number of nobles, so that income from assigned lands fell short of needs. Satish Chandra sees it as a crisis of the jagirdari system that affected every branch of state activity and fed factional struggle.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Mughal Empire had a settled law of succession based on the eldest son.
False

There was no definite law of succession, which caused wars of succession.

2 Aurangzeb's Deccan policy is counted among the causes of the Mughal decline.
True

It kept him away from the capital for long.

3 The region-related view finds the causes of decline in the turmoil of different parts of the empire.
True

The empire-related view looks to the empire's structure.

4 Irfan Habib blamed military inefficiency as the sole cause of the fall of the Mughals.
False

That was William Irvine's view; Habib stressed economic and administrative causes.

5 The invasions of Nadir Shah and Abdali are listed among the causes of the fall.
True

They gave a death-blow to the empire.

Past Mains Questions on This Topic

This topic comes under India on the Eve of British Conquest. UPSC Mains questions asked on the matching syllabus topic, year-wise with marks:

Share: