An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 3.15

Privatisation: Disinvestment, Token Disinvestment, Strategic Disinvestment, Navratna Autonomy; Reform Measures effective April 2001; Approaches to Disinvestment

Indian Economy › Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms · Topic 3.15

Privatisation is the transfer of ownership or management of a public sector enterprise to private hands, and in India it has mainly taken the form of disinvestment, which is the sale of government equity in public sector undertakings. Token disinvestment sells a small part of the shares to raise money while the government keeps ownership and control, and strategic disinvestment sells a substantial stake, up to 50 per cent or more, together with transfer of management control to a private buyer. India began disinvestment in 1991-92, raised about Rs 3,038 crore from minority stakes in 31 enterprises, and sold Air India to Tata Sons in 2021.

Share:
Privatisation: Disinvestment, Token Disinvestment, Strategic Disinvestment, Navratna Autonomy; Reform Measures effective April 2001; Approaches to Disinvestment - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Start 1991-92 with minority sales
  • Token disinvestment Small stake, government keeps control
  • Strategic disinvestment Large stake with management transfer
  • Nodal body DIPAM in the Finance Ministry
  • Landmark Air India sold to Tata Sons, 2021
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Economic Planning, Economic History and Reforms

Where Does It Fit?

After the sector reforms in Liberalisation in 1991: Industrial Sector Reforms, Financial Sector Reforms (Pre-1991 Financial Sector Regulation), Tax Reforms (Reduction in Income and Corporate Taxes; Indirect Tax Reforms; GST), Foreign Exchange Reforms, Trade and Investment Policy Reforms (Dismantling Pre-Reform Policies), this topic covers the second pillar of LPG, privatisation. Previous topic: Liberalisation in 1991: Industrial Sector Reforms, Financial Sector Reforms (Pre-1991 Financial Sector Regulation), Tax Reforms (Reduction in Income and Corporate Taxes; Indirect Tax Reforms; GST), Foreign Exchange Reforms, Trade and Investment Policy Reforms (Dismantling Pre-Reform Policies). Next topic: Globalisation: Trade Barriers, Tariff Hikes, Outsourcing; Effect on Power Loom Industry.

How Do Token and Strategic Disinvestment Differ?

Feature Token disinvestment Strategic disinvestment
Stake sold A small part, typically a minority A substantial block, up to 50 per cent or more
Control Stays with the government Passes to the strategic buyer
Main aim Raise money for the budget and broaden shareholding Improve management and efficiency, and exit non-core business
Method Public offer, offer for sale to the public, auction on exchanges, ETFs Competitive bidding, with a strategic partner or buyer chosen
Example Minority sales in 31 enterprises in 1991-92, ETF-based sales BALCO to Sterlite in 2001, Air India to Tata Sons in 2021
Effect on public sector status Enterprise remains a public sector undertaking Enterprise becomes a private company if control passes

What Are the Main Approaches to Disinvestment?

Approach What happens Instrument or example
Minority stake sale Government sells less than 50 per cent and keeps control IPO, follow-on public offer, offer for sale through exchanges
Strategic sale Control and management pass to a strategic partner Modern Foods, BALCO, VSNL, Air India
Exchange traded funds A basket of public enterprise shares sold as units to the public CPSE ETF in 2014 and Bharat 22 ETF in 2017
Initial public offering of a government company A new listing that sells part of an unlisted enterprise LIC IPO in May 2022
Buyback and merger Enterprise buys back shares or one enterprise acquires another ONGC with HPCL in 2018
Closure and asset monetisation Sick units closed or assets leased and sold NITI Aayog NMP 1.0 target Rs 6 lakh crore, FY 2022 to FY…">National Monetisation Pipeline from 2021

What Else Should You Remember?

  • What privatisation means: Privatisation can range from a share sale to full transfer. It is wider than disinvestment, which is one route and which may leave the state in control
  • Start of disinvestment: Disinvestment began in 1991-92 with the sale of minority stakes in selected enterprises through bundles of shares to public financial institutions, raising about Rs 3,038 crore
  • Disinvestment Commission: The Disinvestment Commission under G. V. Ramakrishna was set up in August 1996 to advise on which enterprises to sell and by how much
  • Navratna autonomy: Navratna status was created in 1997. A Navratna enterprise may invest up to Rs 1,000 crore, or 15 per cent of its net worth, in a single project without government approval, as per Department of Public Enterprises guidelines revised from time to time. Maharatna status, created in 2009, carries a higher limit of Rs 5,000 crore. See Public Sector Undertakings: Types of Public Sector Enterprises (Departmental Undertaking, Statutory Corporation, Government Company, Control Boards, Cooperative Society); Maharatna, Navratna, Miniratna Criteria; Privatisation of PSEs
  • Reform measures effective April 2001: On 1 April 2001 India removed the last quantitative restrictions on imports of 715 items, which opened more sectors to private and foreign competition and affected public enterprises. The same period saw the first strategic sales, including BALCO to Sterlite in 2001 and VSNL to Tata in 2002
  • Institutions: A Department of Disinvestment was created in 1999 and became a ministry in 2001. It was merged back into the Finance Ministry in 2004 and renamed the Department of Investment and Public Asset Management, DIPAM, in 2016
  • National Investment Fund: Created in 2005 to hold disinvestment proceeds, with income used for social sector schemes and the recapitalisation of public enterprises
  • Policy of 2021: The Atmanirbhar Bharat policy for public sector enterprises of 2020 and the budget of 2021-22 set a strategic sector with a minimum presence of a few public enterprises in areas such as atomic energy, space and defence, banking, insurance and power, and privatisation of enterprises elsewhere
  • Air India: The government sold Air India to Tata Sons for about Rs 18,000 crore, including debt taken over, in October 2021, and handed it over in January 2022
  • Fiscal link: Disinvestment proceeds are a capital receipt, as in Classification of Receipts: Revenue Receipts (Tax and Non-Tax) and Capital Receipts (Loans, Sale of Government Assets, Disinvestment). For DIPAM and the National Investment Fund see Disinvestment in PSUs: DIPAM, Token Disinvestment, Strategic Disinvestment; National Investment Fund (NIF)
  • Arguments for: Fiscal receipts, better management, widening of share ownership, release of resources for health and education
  • Arguments against: Sale of assets at low prices, loss of dividends, job losses, concentration of ownership and loss of strategic control
  • Mains view: Mains questions are covered in Disinvestment of PSUs; DIPAM; Strategic Disinvestment Policy

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Definitions: Token disinvestment keeps control with the government and strategic disinvestment transfers it
  2. Navratna autonomy: Investment limits without government approval
  3. Dates: 1991-92 start, 1996 commission, 1999 department, 2016 DIPAM
  4. April 2001: Removal of quantitative restrictions on 715 items
  5. Common errors: Treating all disinvestment as privatisation, or saying that Navratna enterprises can be sold without approval

As an analytical point, disinvestment works best when it is tied to better governance and used for productive capital spending. A sale only to meet a budget gap risks selling assets to cover recurring costs.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • Types Token and strategic
  • Institutions DIPAM and commissions
  • Autonomy Navratna rules

What Came Next?

The next topic covers globalisation, trade barriers, outsourcing and the power loom industry. Next topic: Globalisation: Trade Barriers, Tariff Hikes, Outsourcing; Effect on Power Loom Industry.

Key People and Terms

  • Disinvestment Sale of government equity
  • Token disinvestment Small stake sale
  • Strategic disinvestment Sale with management control
  • DIPAM Investment and public asset management
  • Navratna Enterprise with greater autonomy
  • Bharat 22 ETF Basket of public enterprise shares

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Start: 1991-92, about Rs 3,038 crore.
  • Disinvestment Commission: 1996, Ramakrishna.
  • DIPAM name: 2016.
  • Navratna status: 1997; Maharatna: 2009.
  • Air India sold to Tata Sons in 2021.

Do Not Confuse With

  • Disinvestment and privatisation Share sale versus transfer of control
  • Token and strategic disinvestment Control kept versus control passed
  • Navratna and Maharatna Lower versus higher autonomy limits

Memory Hook

Token keeps the keys, strategic hands them over.

Mains Angle

Questions ask for the merits and demerits of disinvestment. These points give a frame.

  • Why Fiscal and efficiency
  • How Minority and strategic sales
  • Risks Undervaluation and jobs

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“Distinguish between disinvestment and privatisation, and discuss the case for and against strategic disinvestment of public sector enterprises in India.”

How to Answer

  1. Define Disinvestment versus privatisation.
  2. History 1991 to 2021.
  3. Debate Efficiency versus control.
  4. Way Transparent, tied to investment.

GS Relevance

Prelims: privatisation, types of disinvestment, Navratna autonomy, DIPAM, approaches and milestones. GS Paper 3: public sector reform, fiscal resources, privatisation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is disinvestment in India?

Disinvestment is the sale or dilution of the government's equity in public sector undertakings. It may be a small sale that keeps government control or a strategic sale that passes control to a private buyer. India started disinvestment in 1991-92 as part of the reforms.

What is the difference between token disinvestment and strategic disinvestment?

In token disinvestment the government sells a small stake and keeps ownership and control. In strategic disinvestment it sells a substantial stake, up to 50 per cent or more, with transfer of management control to a private buyer, as in the sale of Air India to Tata Sons.

What is the difference between disinvestment and privatisation?

Disinvestment is the sale of government shares in a public enterprise, and it may leave the state in control. Privatisation is the wider shift of ownership or management to private hands, and it needs the government to hand over control, as in strategic sale.

What is Navratna autonomy?

Navratna autonomy is the greater financial and operational freedom given to selected public enterprises from 1997. A Navratna enterprise can invest up to Rs 1,000 crore, or 15 per cent of net worth, in a project without government approval, under guidelines revised from time to time.

What is DIPAM?

DIPAM is the Department of Investment and Public Asset Management in the Ministry of Finance, renamed in 2016 from the Department of Disinvestment. It handles disinvestment, strategic sale, and management of the government's investments in central public sector enterprises.

Why is disinvestment important for UPSC?

It links public sector reform, fiscal policy and the LPG reforms. Prelims asks the types of disinvestment, institutions and Navratna rules, and Mains asks whether privatisation improves efficiency and how to avoid selling assets below value in GS Paper 3.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 In token disinvestment the government keeps control of the enterprise.
True

Only a small stake is sold.

2 Air India was sold to Tata Sons in 2021.
True

Handed over in January 2022.

3 DIPAM was renamed in 2016.
True

From the Department of Disinvestment.

4 Strategic disinvestment leaves management with the government.
False

Management control passes to the buyer.

Share: