An Initiative by SAARTHI IAS
Maarg Manthan · Topic 11.22

Genetically modified crops: way forward; High-value crops: economic, environmental, socio-cultural and policy factors

Indian Economy › Agriculture: Crops, Inputs, Technology and Productivity · Topic 11.22

The way forward on genetically modified (GM) crops in India is a transparent, science-based national policy, which the Supreme Court directed on 23 July 2024 in Gene Campaign v. Union of India, the case on herbicide-tolerant GM mustard DMH-11. Only one GM crop, Bt cotton (approved in 2002 and now about 95 per cent of cotton area), is grown commercially. High-value crops are fruits, vegetables, flowers, spices, nuts and plantation crops that earn more per hectare than cereals. Their spread rests on economic, environmental, socio-cultural and policy factors, and the Union Budget 2026-27 backs coconut, cashew, cocoa, sandalwood and hill nuts.

Share:
Genetically modified crops: way forward; High-value crops: economic, environmental, socio-cultural and policy factors - Indian Economy - MaargX UPSC Maarg Manthan

At a Glance

  • Supreme Court split verdict 23 July 2024, Gene Campaign v. Union of India
  • Only GM crop grown Bt cotton, approved 2002, about 95% of cotton area
  • Cotton yield About 450-500 kg per hectare against about 800 kg global
  • Horticulture output, 2024-25 (second advance estimates) 367.72 million tonnes
  • Fruit and vegetable exports, 2024-25 USD 1,818.56 million
  • Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Agriculture: Crops, Inputs, Technology and Productivity

Where Does It Fit?

This Mains topic follows the Prelims account of seeds and biotechnology in Seeds: Seed Replacement Rate (SRR), Breeder Seed, Foundation Seed, Certified Seed; Genetically Modified Crops; Biotechnology in Agriculture and uses the cropping-pattern ideas in Changes in cropping patterns: drivers; rice-wheat cropping system; role of millets in health and nutritional security. It leads into the wider technology topic Biotechnology in the aid of agriculture: benefits and use and the programme view in PLFS July 2023 to June 2024) Agri and allied GVA Estimated Rs 52.08…">Government Intervention in Indian Agriculture; Situation of Indian Agriculture; Agriculture Infrastructure Fund. Previous topic: Recent developments: Animal Husbandry Infrastructure Development Fund (AHIDF); Agriculture Infrastructure Fund. Next topic: Biotechnology in the aid of agriculture: benefits and use.

What Is the Way Forward on Genetically Modified Crops in India?

Issue Evidence and way forward
The regulator GM crops need approval of the Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee (GEAC) under the Environment Ministry before environmental release. The GEAC cleared HT mustard DMH-11 conditionally in 2022
The court case On 23 July 2024 a Supreme Court bench of Justices B.V. Nagarathna and Sanjay Karol delivered a split verdict. Justice Nagarathna held the approval flawed, citing procedural lapses, the right to a safe environment under Article 21 and the precautionary principle. Justice Karol held that a ban on herbicide-tolerant crops was not warranted and the approval was not vitiated. The matter went to the Chief Justice for a larger bench
The common direction Both judges directed the Union to frame a national policy on GM crops covering research, cultivation, trade and commerce, after consultation with experts, State Governments and farmer representatives. The Environment Ministry was to hold a national consultation, preferably within four months
Conflicts and labelling The Court asked the Union to check the credentials and conflicts of interest of experts, and told it to follow Section 23 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 on labelling of GM food, especially GM edible oil
Bt cotton record Bt cotton was approved in 2002 and about 95 per cent of the cotton area is now under it. A 2012 study found yield gains of about 24 per cent and profit gains of about 50 per cent over conventional cotton
Where Bt cotton struggles India’s cotton yield is about 450-500 kg per hectare against about 800 kg globally. Pink bollworm has shown significant resistance to Bt cotton since 2014, and approval of advanced traits such as Bollgard-II RRF is still being urged
Genome-edited rice ICAR released two genome-edited rice varieties in May 2025, DRR Dhan 100 (Kamala) and Pusa DST Rice 1, made by SDN-1 editing with no foreign DNA. India exempted SDN-1 and SDN-2 edited plants from stringent biosafety rules in 2022, but activists call them unsafe
Way forward Frame the national policy with crop-by-crop risk assessment, publish biosafety data, label GM foods, use independent long-term testing, protect farmers from seed monopoly, fix refuge and resistance management, and treat gene-edited crops with a separate, clear rule

What Economic, Environmental, Socio-Cultural and Policy Factors Drive High-Value Crops?

Factor How it works, with evidence
Economic: returns Fruits, vegetables, flowers, spices, medicinal plants and plantation crops earn higher net return per unit of land than cereals and pulses. Horticulture is about 37 per cent of the gross value of output of the crop sector
Economic: scale and trade Horticulture output rose from 280.70 million tonnes in 2013-14 to 367.72 million tonnes in 2024-25 (second advance estimates), with fruits at 114.51 and vegetables at 219.67 million tonnes. Fruit and vegetable exports were USD 1,818.56 million in 2024-25
Economic: risks Perishability, price swings, high initial cost and long gestation of tree crops such as sandalwood need cold chains, processing and credit, as in Recent developments: Animal Husbandry Infrastructure Development Fund (AHIDF); Agriculture Infrastructure Fund
Environmental Perennial and tree crops can protect soil and give cover, and drip use saves water. But walnuts and almonds are sensitive to snowfall shifts and heat
Socio-cultural Labour-intensive crops create rural, women and tribal employment. Food habits and rising demand for fruit, vegetables and nuts help demand. Small holdings, lack of skills and risk aversion slow the shift
Policy: schemes The Mission for Integrated Development of Horticulture supports nurseries, protected cultivation, PKVY Launched 2015 First organic state Sikkim, 2016…">organic farming, post-harvest management and cold chains
Policy: Budget 2026-27 A Coconut Promotion Scheme, a programme for cashew and cocoa to make India self-reliant and build Indian Cashew and Indian Cocoa as global brands by 2030, state partnership for sandalwood, agarwood in the North-East and nuts such as almonds, walnuts and pine nuts in hilly regions. The Budget also announced Bharat-VISTAAR, a multilingual AI advisory tool
Policy: price signals Only 52 per cent of gross cropped area is irrigated and support prices favour cereals, which discourages diversification. Price support for horticulture is thin, so market links are the real policy

What Else Should You Remember?

  • Asked angle: Flagged as asked in UPSC Mains 2025. Use the two-part answer: policy path for GM crops first, then the four-factor frame for high-value crops
  • GM crops and food security: GM crops can cut pest losses and herbicide use, but yield gains are not automatic. The cotton data show that a single trait loses value as pests adapt
  • GM mustard: Herbicide-tolerant mustard DMH-11 sits in the case on oilseeds self-reliance, because India imports a large share of edible oils, as in Agricultural Trade Facts: Largest Rice Exporter; Edible Oil Customs Duty; Import Composition (Pulses, Edible Oils, Fresh Fruits, Spices)
  • Concerns on GM crops: Biosafety, effects on non-target species, gene flow, seed control by firms, farmer indebtedness and consumer choice are the standard concerns
  • Precautionary principle: Where harm is uncertain, regulators should act with caution, which is the basis of Justice Nagarathna’s reasoning
  • Link with natural farming: Natural farming in PMFBY launched 18 February 2016 PMFBY farmer premium 2% kharif, 1.5% rabi, up to 5% commercial and horticultural PMFBY…">Precision farming: benefits; crop insurance in India; ZBNF features and relation to organic farming promotes input reduction without GM traits, so the policy choice is not either or
  • High-value crops and income: Diversification toward horticulture is one way to raise income on small holdings, linked with the integrated farm in Integrated farming systems
  • Link with technology: Satellite mapping, AI advisory and digital records in Technology in the aid of farmers: e-technology scope and significance; AI in agriculture; ICT initiatives; challenges; way forward help manage orchards and high-density crops
  • Way forward on high-value crops: Crop-wise and region-wise plans, nursery and planting material quality, farmer producer organisations for bargaining power, cold chains, processing, quality standards for export and climate-resilient varieties

Why Does It Matter for the Exam?

  1. Typical question: give the way forward for GM crops and discuss factors that favour high-value crops
  2. Case to cite: Gene Campaign v. Union of India, 23 July 2024, split verdict on HT mustard DMH-11
  3. Numbers to quote: Bt cotton 2002 and about 95 per cent of area; horticulture 367.72 million tonnes in 2024-25
  4. Frame to use: economic, environmental, socio-cultural and policy, in that order
  5. Common errors: saying that GM mustard is commercially grown, or that the Court banned GM crops

As an analytical point, the Court did not ban or approve GM mustard. It asked for a national policy, which means the real way forward is a rule-based, transparent process for each crop, with gene-edited crops handled under their own clear norms.

Why Is This Topic Important?

  • GM crops Policy and court direction
  • Bt cotton Only GM crop in the field
  • High-value crops Four-factor frame

What Came Next?

The next topic widens from GM crops to the whole range of biotechnology tools used in agriculture, from tissue culture to gene editing. Next topic: Biotechnology in the aid of agriculture: benefits and use.

Key People and Terms

  • GM crop Crop with a transferred gene
  • GEAC Approves GM release
  • DMH-11 GM herbicide-tolerant mustard hybrid
  • SDN-1 Edit without a template or foreign DNA
  • High-value crop Crop with high return per hectare
  • MIDH Horticulture mission

Exam Corner

Points to Remember

  • Supreme Court split verdict: 23 July 2024.
  • Court asked for a national GM policy after consultation.
  • Bt cotton approved 2002; about 95 per cent of cotton area.
  • Genome-edited rice released May 2025.
  • Budget 2026-27: coconut, cashew, cocoa, sandalwood, hill nuts.

Do Not Confuse With

  • GM crop and genome-edited crop Foreign gene inserted versus a small edit without foreign DNA
  • Bt cotton and GM mustard Grown since 2002 versus not released
  • High-value crop and cash crop Return per hectare versus sold for cash, as in sugarcane or cotton

Memory Hook

Policy before planting: label, test, consult, then decide.

Mains Angle

Give both halves equal space. For GM crops, use the court direction as the hinge; for high-value crops, use four factors.

  • GM way forward National policy, biosafety, labelling
  • Evidence Bt cotton gains and limits
  • Factors Economic, environmental, socio-cultural, policy
  • Way forward Markets, cold chains, climate-resilient varieties

A Question You May Face

An original practice question, not a past paper question.

“What is the way forward for genetically modified crops in India? Examine the economic, environmental, socio-cultural and policy factors behind the growth of high-value crops.”

How to Answer

  1. Intro State the 2024 Supreme Court direction and define high-value crops.
  2. Body 1 GM crops: Bt cotton record, GM mustard case, genome editing.
  3. Body 2 High-value crops: four factors with data.
  4. Body 3 Policy steps and gaps.
  5. Conclusion Science with consent, and markets with income.

GS Relevance

GS Paper 3: agriculture, technology and biotechnology, cropping patterns, food processing, and awareness in biotechnology. Flagged as asked in UPSC Mains 2025 and a live 2026 issue because of the Budget 2026-27 high-value crop strategy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the Supreme Court say about GM mustard?

On 23 July 2024 a two-judge bench gave a split verdict on the approval of GM mustard DMH-11. Both judges directed the Union to frame a national policy on GM crops covering research, cultivation, trade and commerce, after consulting experts and States. The matter went to a larger bench.

Which GM crop is grown in India?

Bt cotton is the only genetically modified crop grown commercially in India. It was approved in 2002 and now covers about 95 per cent of the cotton area. Yields of about 450-500 kg per hectare remain well below the global average of about 800 kg.

What is the way forward for GM crops in India?

The way forward is a transparent national policy with crop-wise risk assessment, public biosafety data, labelling of GM food, independent testing, conflict-of-interest checks on experts, protection of farmers from seed monopoly, and a clear separate rule for gene-edited crops such as the 2025 rice varieties.

What are high-value crops?

High-value crops are fruits, vegetables, flowers, spices, medicinal plants, nuts and plantation crops that give a higher net return per hectare than cereals and pulses. They are more labour-intensive, need market and cold-chain support, and are promoted through the Mission for Integrated Development of Horticulture.

What are the factors behind high-value crops?

Economic factors are higher returns and rising demand. Environmental factors include climate sensitivity and water use. Socio-cultural factors are employment for women and tribal groups and changing diets. Policy factors include horticulture missions, the Budget 2026-27 crop plans and market links, with price support favouring cereals.

What did Budget 2026-27 announce for high-value agriculture?

The Union Budget 2026-27 announced a Coconut Promotion Scheme, a cashew and cocoa programme to build Indian brands by 2030, state partnership for sandalwood, support for agarwood in the North-East and nuts in hilly regions, and Bharat-VISTAAR, a multilingual AI advisory tool for farmers.

PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis

1 The Supreme Court in July 2024 banned all GM crops in India.
False

It split on GM mustard and asked for a national policy.

2 Bt cotton was approved in India in 2002.
True

It is the only GM crop grown commercially.

3 The GEAC functions under the Environment Ministry.
True

It approves release of genetically modified organisms.

4 High-value crops generally earn lower returns per hectare than cereals.
False

They earn higher net returns.

Share: