Externalities (Positive and Negative); Public Goods
Indian Economy › Basics of Micro and Macro Economics · Topic 1.13
An externality is a cost or benefit of an economic activity that falls on people who are not part of the transaction and is not reflected in the market price. A negative externality, such as air pollution from stubble burning, imposes a cost on others, so the market produces too much of it. A positive externality, such as vaccination, gives a benefit to others, so the market produces too little. A public good is non-rival and non-excludable, such as national defence or street lighting, so private firms will not supply it because of the free rider problem, and the government provides it from taxes.
6 min read · UPSC Prelims and Mains · Indian Economy · Basics of Micro and Macro Economics
At a Glance
- Negative externality Cost on third parties, overproduction
- Positive externality Benefit to third parties, underproduction
- Public good Non-rival and non-excludable
- Fix for negative Pigouvian tax, regulation, trading permits
- Fix for positive Subsidy or public provision
- Exam link UPSC Prelims and Mains, Indian Economy: Basics of Micro and Macro Economics
Where Does It Fit?
Price floors and ceilings were one kind of market intervention. Externalities and public goods are the other main case of market failure, and they explain taxes, subsidies, environment rules and public spending studied in later macros. Previous topic: Market Intervention in Capitalist Systems: Minimum Price Intervention (Price Floor, Protecting Producers), Price Ceiling (Protecting Consumers), Managing Consequences. Next topic: Basic Terms: Goods and Services, Final Good, Intermediate Good, Consumption Good, Capital Good, Fixed Asset, Depreciation, Stock and Flow.
What Are Positive and Negative Externalities?
| Basis | Negative externality | Positive externality |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Cost imposed on third parties, not paid by the producer or consumer | Benefit conferred on third parties, not paid to the producer or consumer |
| Alternate name | External cost, spillover cost | External benefit, spillover benefit |
| Private versus social | Social cost exceeds private cost | Social benefit exceeds private benefit |
| Market outcome | Overproduction or overconsumption | Underproduction or underconsumption |
| Examples | Stubble burning, vehicle and factory emissions, river pollution, traffic congestion, noise | Vaccination, education, research and development, afforestation, a neighbour garden |
| Policy response | Pigouvian tax, regulation, tradable permits, polluter pays | Subsidy, public provision, awareness |
How Do Public Goods Differ From Other Goods?
| Type of good | Rival? | Excludable? | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Private good | Yes | Yes | Food, clothes, a mobile phone |
| Public good | No | No | National defence, street lighting, lighthouse, public parks in principle, flood control |
| Common pool resource | Yes | No | Fish in the open sea, groundwater, grazing land |
| Club good (toll good) | No | Yes | Cable television, toll expressway, private park, a subscription service |
What Else Should You Remember?
- Pigouvian tax: Named after Arthur Pigou. A tax equal to the external cost so that the producer pays the full social cost. Example: if private marginal cost of making a good is Rs 50 and each unit causes Rs 20 of pollution damage, social marginal cost is Rs 70, and a tax of Rs 20 per unit corrects the price signal
- Coase theorem: Proposed by Ronald Coase. If property rights are well defined and bargaining costs are low, parties can settle an externality by negotiation, whoever holds the right. It fails when many people are affected or the costs of bargaining are high
- Polluter pays principle: The producer of pollution bears the cost of damage and remediation. It guides Indian environment law and rulings of the National Green Tribunal
- Tradable permits: A cap on total pollution with permits that firms can trade. India runs the Perform, Achieve and Trade scheme for energy efficiency and is setting up a Carbon Credit Trading Scheme under the Energy Conservation (Amendment) Act, 2022
- Public good features: Non-rival means that one person consumption does not reduce what is left for others. Non-excludable means that nobody can be prevented from using it, even if they do not pay
- Free rider problem: People enjoy the good without paying, so private firms cannot earn enough revenue and supply it. The state funds it through taxation, which is why defence, police and lighthouses are public provisions
- Provision and production: Public provision means the government pays, but production can be by private firms through contracts, as with road construction under public-private models
- Merit goods: Goods considered desirable for all and under-consumed if left to the market, such as education, health care and subsidised food. The mid-day meal scheme and the Public Distribution System are examples. They are different from public goods because they are rival and excludable
- Demerit goods: Goods harmful to society, such as tobacco and alcohol, discouraged by sin taxes
- Tragedy of the commons: Described by Garrett Hardin in 1968. Open-access resources are overused because each user gains fully while the cost is shared. Elinor Ostrom received the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2009 for showing that communities can manage commons by rules
- Indian examples: Burning of crop residue in north India adds to winter air pollution in Delhi and nearby areas, an example of a negative externality. Pulse Polio and immunisation give a positive externality by reducing disease spread. Both are examples of market failure that need state action, as in Types of Economies and Economic Systems: Capitalist, Socialist, Mixed; Open Economy and Closed Economy
- Link with price control: Where the market fails, the state may also set prices, as in Market Intervention in Capitalist Systems: Minimum Price Intervention (Price Floor, Protecting Producers), Price Ceiling (Protecting Consumers), Managing Consequences
- Network and information effects: Digital platforms create positive network externalities, because each new user raises the value for others, which is a feature of services such as UPI
Why Does It Matter for the Exam?
- Identify the type: Questions give a situation and ask whether it is a positive or negative externality
- Public good test: Check both non-rival and non-excludable
- Policy tools: Pigouvian tax for negative, subsidy for positive, Coase for bargaining
- Related ideas: Free rider, merit good, common pool resource and tragedy of the commons
- Common errors: Calling education or health a public good, since they are merit goods, or treating a toll road as a pure public good
As an analytical point, externalities explain why markets alone cannot protect the environment or ensure adequate health and education. Effective policy prices pollution, rewards positive spillovers and gives clear property rights.
Why Is This Topic Important?
- Externalities Type identification
- Public goods Two features tested
- Policy tools Tax, subsidy, permits
What Came Next?
The next topic begins the macroeconomic section with basic terms such as goods, assets, depreciation, stock and flow. Next topic: Basic Terms: Goods and Services, Final Good, Intermediate Good, Consumption Good, Capital Good, Fixed Asset, Depreciation, Stock and Flow.
Key People and Terms
- Externality Spillover to third parties
- Public good Non-rival, non-excludable
- Free rider Uses without paying
- Pigouvian tax Tax equal to external cost
- Merit good Under-consumed desirable good
- Commons Rival, non-excludable resource
Exam Corner
Points to Remember
- Public good: non-rival and non-excludable.
- Negative externality: overproduction; positive: underproduction.
- Pigouvian tax = external cost per unit.
- Common pool resource: rival, non-excludable.
- Tragedy of the commons: Garrett Hardin, 1968.
Do Not Confuse With
- Public goods and merit goods Non-rival and non-excludable versus desirable but rival and excludable
- Common pool resource and public good Rival versus non-rival
- Pigouvian tax and Coase theorem State tax versus private bargaining
Memory Hook
Spill-out costs need a tax, spill-in gains need a subsidy, and what nobody can be stopped from using needs the state.
Mains Angle
Questions link externalities to pollution and health. These points give a frame.
- Concept Spillovers and market failure
- Examples Pollution, vaccination
- Tools Tax, permits, subsidy
A Question You May Face
An original practice question, not a past paper question.
“What is an externality? Discuss how India can address negative externalities such as air pollution using economic instruments.”
How to Answer
- Define Positive and negative.
- Example Stubble burning, emissions.
- Tools Pigouvian tax, permits, regulation.
- Way Polluter pays with support for change.
GS Relevance
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an externality in economics?
An externality is a cost or benefit of an activity that affects people who are not part of the transaction and is not reflected in market prices. Pollution is a negative externality and vaccination is a positive externality. Both lead to market failure that the government may correct.
What is the difference between positive and negative externalities?
A negative externality imposes a cost on others, so social cost exceeds private cost and the good is overproduced. A positive externality gives a benefit to others, so social benefit exceeds private benefit and the good is underproduced. Taxes address the first and subsidies the second.
What is a public good with examples?
A public good is non-rival, meaning one person use does not reduce availability for others, and non-excludable, meaning nobody can be prevented from using it. National defence, street lighting and lighthouses are examples. Private firms do not supply them because of free riders.
What is the free rider problem?
The free rider problem arises when people can enjoy a good without paying for it, so they have no reason to contribute. Because revenue is hard to collect, private firms do not supply public goods, and the government provides them using tax money.
What is a Pigouvian tax?
A Pigouvian tax is a tax on an activity equal to the external cost it causes, so the producer bears the full social cost. If a good causes Rs 20 of pollution damage per unit, a tax of Rs 20 per unit makes private cost equal social cost.
What is the difference between public goods and merit goods?
Public goods are non-rival and non-excludable, like defence. Merit goods, such as education, health care and subsidised food, are rival and excludable but considered so desirable that the state encourages their consumption. Public goods are provided by the state because the market cannot supply them.
PYQ Practice — Statement Analysis
1 A public good is non-rival and non-excludable.
Both features define a public good.
2 Vaccination is an example of a negative externality.
It is a positive externality as it benefits others.
3 A common pool resource is rival but non-excludable.
Fish stocks and groundwater are examples.
4 Education is a pure public good.
It is a merit good, being rival and excludable.
Related Topics
Browse the full Indian Economy index